final Flashcards
Emotional expression
Theories and studies;
James-lange theory;
emotion is tied to bodily reaction
Emotion is embedded into bodily experience
Jumping up and down associated with happiness
Jump up and down because you are happy, not when you are happy
Act brave, be brave
Act sad, isolate yourself, will experience sadness
Emotional expression
Theories and studies;
Cannon-bard theory;
assimilation and reaction are two separate things
Various life situations can simultaneously elicit both an emotional experience and bodily responses, such as increased blood pressure or sweaty palms
Schachter-singer theory
There are two crucial elements of emotional experience: physiological arousal and the cognitive interpretation of this arousal
Physiological impacts of emotion are the same across culture, cognitive appraisal differentiates
Emotional expression
Theories and studies;
Universal emotions;
no 1 single number of universal emotions that everyone agreed on
How many emotions?
In buddhist tradition the basic seven emotions are described as happiness, anger, sorrow, joy, love, hate, and desire
Most classifications include 5 to 9 emotions:
Anger, fear, happiness, sadness, and disgust are present in most national classification
Surprise, contempt, interest, shame, trust and anticipation are present in other classifications
Emotional expression
Theories and studies;
Van bezooijen (1983) study on recognition of emotions amongst 3 groups
dutch did the best, boys did worse in joy
Recognition of emotional intonation in the voice
Van bezooijen, otto, heenan (1983)
Speakers were asked to a express a standard phrase with the nine emotions, disgust, surprise, shame, interest, joy, fear, contempt, sadness, and anger
The phrase “two months pregnant” was used for the study
Participants listened to recording in a language lab and they had to make a forced judgement
Dutch significantly did better than taiwanese or japanese subjects in identifying dutch vocal expressions of emotion
The other two groups were able to identify the great majority of the emotions examined
The two emotions that the taiwanese and japanese subjects identified most accurately were sadness and anger but joy lost most of its recognizability
Emotional expression
Theories and studies;
Safdar (2009) study on emotional display rules
major findings, diff between americans, canadians and japanese, diff between americans and canadians
Emotional display rules are culturally prescribed rules that influence the emotional expression of people from any culture depending on what that particular culture has characterized as an acceptable expression of emotion
Emotional display rules across cultures
Canadians (N=199), Americans (N=256), and Japanese (N=380)
Display rule assessment inventory (DRAI), asking participants to judge the appropriateness of displaying certain emotions in different situations. Participants are given scenarios that vary with regard to 21 target persons, 2 locations, and 7 emotions
Means of expression of seven emotions
Japanese significantly expressed powerful emotions less than americans and canadians
Sadness and fear; powerless emotions, no significant diff between canadians, americans and japanese
Research findings;
Japanese display rules permit the expression of powerful emotions (anger, contempt, disgust) significantly less than those of the two north american groups
Japanese also think that they should express positive emotions (happiness, surprise) significantly less than canadian sample
When looking at gender; men iexpressed powerful emotions more than women and women expressed powerless emotions and happiness more than men
Norms of politeness in japan
Leadership and negotiations
Theories and concepts
Cross-cultural negotiation process
, requires an early agreement on the distribution of talk and the exchange of information
Leadership and negotiations
Theories and concepts
Study by guss (2000) with german and indian students;
imagine uncle left u company, simulation test, who did better what risks each engaged in, indian more engaged more defensive in decision making, germans more risky and expansive with decision making
Making decision using computer simulation
Study by guss
Students of business administration in India and Germany
Participants had to imagine that they were the director of a company that produces textiles in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia (an equally unknown place for most of the Indian and German students)
Computer simulations, also called microworlds, were used
It allows the comparison not only of the outcome of the decision but also of the process of dynamic decision-making
The program shows an alarm message. A low number of alarms indicates good decision making
No differences were found in the strategic and tactical errors committed by the Indian and German students
In the general decision-making behaviour, no difference was found
The german participants were more successful- they had more total property after the 20 years
The german decision-making strategy could be described as expensive-risky, whereas the Indian strategy was a defensive-incremental one
German showed a relatively stable decision-making behaviour
individualism/collectivism and decision making
Studies show that individualistic values are related to active, and assertive decisions-making strategies, whereas collectivist values are related to and more passive, cautious, collaborative and avoiding strategies
Leadership and negotiations
Theories and concepts
Leadership styles
Leadership
The ability of an individual to influence, motivate, and enable others to contribute toward the effectiveness and success of the organization
Relationship orientation in leadership
Leaders in developing countries place high importance in establishing close interpersonal relationships with subordinates
Leaders assume responsibility for the followers and in return, they seek loyalty
This prevalent leadership style is referred to as paternalism
Power orientation in leadership
Leaders exercise power in developing countries
The decision making process reflects the power inequality. Usually the process is centralized and the decisions are made unilaterally
There is a duality of maintaining good interpersonal relations with the subordinates and acting in an authoritative way on the other, benevolent paternalism
Exploitative paternalism is also common in developing countries
Leadership and negotiations
Theories and concepts
The GLOBE project;
types of leaders acceptable across culture; paternalistic but humble valued in developing
Prejudice and discrimination
Use of scientific theories to justify systematic racism;
intelligence test, phrenology, eugenics
Revised binet-simon intelligence scale to stanford-binet intelligence scholl
Misuse of IQ test (early 20th century)
Lewis terman (1877-1956); controversial figure in psychology, developed IQ test further, believed intelligence is innate, little influence of environment on intelligence, nature is driving factor for development of intelligence, once we have high level of intelligence it is set
promoted IQ as a measure of innate ability
Revised binet-simon intelligence scale to stanford-binet intelligence scale
The scale was biased and favoured white, middle-class culture
Because intelligence is fixed and inherited, if certain groups score lower it proves their inferiority
He argued for inferiority of some groups
His ideas were used to support segregation policies
Highly influential, used in court cases
Prejudice and discrimination
Study by TMU (2020) of 178 corporations
90% of executive positions occupied by white men
Diversity in canadian corporations;
a study by toronto metropolitan university (2020) of 178 corporations in calgary, montreal, toronto, and vancouver found:
Less than 1% of board members and executives are black
91% of board members are white
Other factors;
Lack of inclusive policies
Microagressions and stereotypes in workplace interactions; backhanded compliments
Culture and identity
Theories and concepts
Facets of identity
Facets of identity
Identity is multifaceted and includes self-concept and how people perceive themselves in relation to others and the world around them
Personal identity
Social identity
Cultural identity
Cross-sectional identity
Culture and identity
Theories and concepts
Independent and interdependent self
The independent vs interdependent self-construal
Markus & kityama 1991
Western or individualistic construal is based on the view that self is an independent and a separate entity from others
Eastern or collectivistic construal is based on the view that self is connected to others and inseparable from a social context
Self behaves, primarily, as a consequence of internal attributes vs. behaviour of interdependent self is contingent on what the actor perceives to be the thoughts, feelings, and actions of others
Interdependent may study something they are not interested in like engineering to impress others
The independent self gives rise to self-actualization vs the interdependent self gives rise to fulfilling and creating obligation
Interdependent self is more responsive to social environment than independent, independent takes into account environment as a way of expressing themselves
Consequences
Impact of independent vs interdependent self construal on self-perception (markus 1991)
More self reference (I am) in individualistic vs collectivistic societies
Internal attributes such as abilities or personalities are the most salient relevant information for those with an independent self-construal
Culture and identity
Theories and concepts
Development of bicultural identity;
migration, cultural exposure
Bicultural identity
Refers to identifying with two distinct cultures
Develops in several ways;
Family characteristics; if parents are born outside of canada and you are born in canada you may have both cultural identities
Migration
Cultural exposure
Negotiating cultural identity
Bicultural identity can lead to;
Cultural integration
Cultural conflicts; family values major one, what is accepted in the family
Culture and identity
Theories and concepts
Third-culture kid
Third culture kid
(useem 1950) refers to expatriate children who spend their formative years in cultural contexts different from their or their parents culture
TCK is a specific category of multicultural identity
Culture and identity
Theories and concepts
Choubak and safdar (2023) study on intersectionality of group membership
4 groups (iranian, nigerian, british), 2 genders, 2 sexualities, measured bias towards groups
British male immigrants rated high on competence but not as high on warmth
Examining intersectionality
Choubak and safdar (2023) examined the interplay of the three social group memberships in the bias patterns toward immigrants
Participants (N= 1,105) Canadians, female N= 630 (57%), male N= 466 (42%)
96% were heterosexual
80% were university students
Methodology
Participants were presented different vignettes. Before seeing the vignette, each participant was presented with a cover story, stating that the study was part of a lager research exploring media consumption and human psychology
Information was provided on the immigrants background (age, education, job credentials) and nationality (British, chinese, nigerian, iranian), gender and sexuality
Same competence/education and job experience, differing genders and races
Participants had to rate how they view the person on positive biases; warmth and competence
Graph for stereotype ratings by ethnicity, gender and sexual orientation
Men were perceived to be more competent
Nigerian lesbian women were perceived to be most competent compared to other women, and more than nigerian gay man
Iranian lesbian women also considered highly competent
If women comes from country were sexual inequality is high and they are homosexual, going against the grain, perceived as competent
Women perceived as warmer than men
Gay men perceived to be warmer than straight men
Warmth associated with femininity and sexuality
Conclusion
Heterosexual british men perceived more competent than iranian and nigerian heterosexual men
For the most part, heterosexual men tended to receive more extreme scores than their non-prototypical counter parts, non proto-typical immigrants, on the other hand, received more mixed bias patterns
Heterosexual women, as a group, followed most of the paternalistic bias pattern, as most fell
into the high-warmth and low-competence
cluste
A pattern on prototypicality (i.e., hetersosexual man) vs non-prototypicality i.e., all
women, gay men) emerged.
* Biases directed towards the heterosexual men
of each ethnic background of focus
resembled the biases generally directed
towards their respective ‘generic ethnic group’
in society.
Physical health
Health beliefs and practices
Witchcraft amongst Azande in southern Sudan
organized belief on how to deal with health and death, even if it does not work, belief does not drop
Witchcraft
Witchcraft amongst Azande in southern Sudan was studied by Evans-pritchard
Azandes beliefs; even if witchcraft does not work, their beliefs do not change
Physical health
Health beliefs and practices
Holistic healing beliefs from India;
Ayurveda is ancient system of holistic healings based on balancing three elements or Doshas; Vata or air/ether, Pitta (digestion/metabolism) or fire/water, and Kapha (stability/structure-nourishement) or earth/water
Physical health
Health beliefs and practices
Traditional chinese medicine;
based on ying and yang
Traditional chinese medicine is ancient system and is based on balance of Yin and Yang, acupuncture, and herbal remedies
White; light, warm, aggressive, independent, self-sufficient, positive
Dark; moon, cool, passive, dependent, nurturing, negative
Physical health
Health beliefs and practices
Universalism and relativism argument for female circumcision
Universalism/relativism
Female circumcision
It is an operation that involves excision of all or part of the clitoris
It is followed in at least 20 African countries and some Arab countries
Type of circumcision (how much is cut) varies
Relativism argument;
The operation will ensure the attenuation of sexual drives and protects the women against her oversexed nature, saving her from temptation or disgrace, lowers libido
Universalism argument;
Certain practices especially involving women and children should be condemned. Government and communities should curb such practices.
Culture-sensitive programs
One of the key activities that psychologists can help with is the creation of culturally sensitive programs that can help people to take immediate steps and improve their health
Physical health
Health beliefs and practices
Leene et al (2008) study in rural area of guatemala
Leene (2008) study in rural area of guatemala
The program was implemented in 21 communities. Participants were health promotors and rural women a total of 410 indigenous women.
The program had 4 modules;
1. Explaining factors affecting health of women
2. Learning about the relation between health and nutrition
3. Discussing hygeine
4. Sexuality
3 months after implementation, significant improvement in cleanliness, talking about taboo topicas such as sex, preparing nutritious food etc
Mental health
Definitions and concepts
v How is “mental health” defined?
* Is it a lack of mental illness?
* Is it being happy?
* Is it not having emotional
pendulums?
Life below zero, at zero and
above zero
Mental health
Definitions by WHO
World Health Organization (2022) defined mental health
as “a state of mental well-being that enables people to:
1. Cope with the stresses of life
2. Realize their abilities
3. Learn well and work well
4. Contribute to their community
However, “culture influences how we define a problem
AND how we solve it” (Hernandez et al., 2009, p.1047)
Mental health
Central vs peripheral symptoms
Inclusive approach to clinical psychology
An inclusive approach to psychopathology combines two perspectives. Therefore, each disorder can manifest as:
Central symptoms (etic component)
A set of central symptoms that can be observed in practically all world populations
Peripheral symptoms (emic component)
A set of symptoms that are culture specific.
Major depressive disorder
Central symptoms
Dysphoria, anxiety, tension, lack of energy, and ideas of insufficiency
Peripheral symptoms of depression varies cross culturally
Guilt (western), headaches (latino and mediterranean), weakness, imbalance, and tiredness (china and asian countries), problems with heart (middle eastern nations)
Sadness across cultures; body knows sadness
Mental health
Depression outside of western context
DEPRESSION BEYOND WESTERN CONCEPTS
Acceptance of hopelessness-
Buddhist concept
* The cultural ideology of Buddhists in Sri Lanka makes depression an undiagnosable condition
* Hopelessness is central and expected
* Not depressive, just good Buddhist.
Restructuring of depression- Hopi
* Hopituh Sinom
(Indigenous Native
American)
* No equivalent to
depression but 5
separate illnesses-
* Worry Sickness,
Unhappiness,
heartbreak, drunken
like craziness and
disappointment
pouting
Un- bottled emotions - Kaluli
* Kaluli from tropical forest N of Mount Bosavi
(Papua New Guinea)
* Not Socialized for
suppressing emotions
* No self-blame for
misfortunes- more
outward blame and
anger
* Thus- No word for
depression
* Somatic expression
Mental health vs mental illness
Different terminology
What distinguishes common everyday feeling from
a clinical disorder?
Psychological dysfunction or abnormal behaviours
are associated with
1. Distress
2. Impairment in functioning(occupational, social
and interpersonal)
3. A response that is not typical or culturally
expected. (Barlow and Durand, 2012)
MENTAL ILLNESS
When abnormal behavior is persistent and invasive- that becomes
a disorder.
PREVALENCE OF MENTAL ILLNESSES
As per the WHO World Mental Health Report, 2019-
* 970 (52.4% Female) million individuals living with
mental disorders in 2019.
* 301 million (31%) had anxiety disorders and 280
million (28.9%) with depressive disorders.
* 283 million- alcohol use disorder
* 36 million had drug use disorder.
* Schizophrenia (1 in 200 adults) prevalent in 24
million
* 703 thousand lost their life to suicide
Prevalence across countries
* Common in all countries
* Slightly more common in high-income
countries (15.1%) than in low-income
(11.6%)
* Americas (15.6%), East Mediterranean (14.7%), Europe
Psychological treatment
The use of mental health treatment varies across ethnic groups due to a variety of factors
Psychotherapy is a western, cultural practice
Use of mental health services
Asians seek disproportionately fewer psychological treatment services in north america than whites
Blacks and first nations tend to use outpatient mental health services at a higher rate than whites
Ethnic minority patients have a tendency to drop out of treatmetn before it can be effective more frequently than whites
Psychological treatment
Psychotherapy
Psychotherapy
Psychotherapy is the treatment of psychological disorders through psychological means, generallly involving verbal interaction with a professional therapist
Cultural settings can affect diagnostic practices and psychotherapy
Psychotherapy is re-socialization: “a method for correcting faulty individual learning of the culture’s precepts”
For a therapy to be accepted in a society it must make sense in that society
Debate on cultural competency
The debate on cultural competency
Competency is an ability to perform a task adequately
In therapy is the ability to conduct psychotherapy competently with a range of culturally diverse clients
VS
Cultural competency; The ability to provide effective treatment which differs according to the client’s ethnicity
General competency
General competency and cultural competency overlap but have distinct effects
Fuetres et al reported that ethnic minority clients rated their therapists as being higher in multicultural competency if the therapists were rated high on therapeutic alliance and empathy which are relevant in all treatments
Cultural competency
Constantine (2003) found that cultural competency was related to ethnic minority clients satisfaction beyond general competency
Culturally competent therapist
Sue et al (1982;1992) argue that culturally competent therapists should have:
Cultural awareness; being aware of own biases, aware of own ethnocenturism
Cultural knowledge; being knowledgable about clients culture, how what they went to get out of therapy fits with cultural practice
Cultural skills; necessary skills to engage in a manner that is culturally meaningful to client; sensitive, culturally relevant
Criticism of cultural competency
Is cultural competency motivated by political correctness?
Stereotyping ethnic minorities; predisposed notion of client based on culture, assuming they hold traditional values
Ignoring other diversity characteristics
Over- emphasizing the role of culture in mental health
Current thoughts on cultural competency
Focus on culture is a reaction to ethnocentric bias inherent in psychotherapy
Psychotherapy is a cultural phenomenon
Some see talking as interfering with thinking and that clients should think more talk less
Cultural competency lacks theoretical framework and adequate measures of the construct, underdeveloped