Mental Illness & Crime & Special Issues with Juveniles Flashcards
Was Jared Lougher (the Tuscon Shooter 2011) found NGI? Competent?
- Shot congresswoman in a shopping mall
- He left a note saying he is not NGI but there were still issues related to competency
- He can’t trust the government because of mind control
Was James Holmes (Batman Shooter 2012) found NGI? Competent?
- Called Batman Shooter because it was at the midnight opening of Batman and he shot people
- He was in control of his actions and boobytrapped his apartment (he knew the wrongfulness of his behavior)
- People made sure that he was not found NGI (social pressure)
- He did not want the death penalty
- Not a sane way he thought about murder
- Agreed to prison sentence
What was found in the Andrea Yates trial?
- She killed five of her children
- First trial not found to meet NGI
- However, there was a mistrial
- There was a new trial and found to meet NGI
- Review this from discussion notes
- Still in psychiatric facility
How do we assess malingering?
- How consistent are symptoms are with the psychotic process?
- Voices outside of head and in both ears
- People do not see writing or experience ringing when experiencing psychosis – this can be a test question
- Distracted with hearing voices
- Pay attention to collateral information
- Delusions related to medical care to monitor certain areas of the body and will not accept this information/medical advice
How does the Son of Sam case relate to malingering?
- Serial killer in NY
- Unsuccessfully tried to malinger
- He thought these golden retrievers were inserting thoughts into people’s heads
- He admitted to faking it and is probably psychopathic
How do lie detectors work?
- Use of control question test (base rate information)
- Not reliable to be used in court settings
- Skin conductance, heart rate (physiological arousal)
Do the differences in manipulation skill and physiological arousal make polygraph less accurate for high PCL-R? (Describe Patrick and Iacono study)
- Prison sample
- Informed subjects goal is can they “beat a lie detector test”
- Other inmates would lose money and be informed if they failed (meaningful reaction)
- Set up mock theft
- High PCL-R no more likely to beat a polygraph than Low PCL-R
- Correctly classified 87% of all subjects
- Only 1 psychopath and 2 non-psychopaths who took money classified as truthful
What percentage of people were able to beat a polygraph if taught? And how?
47% (Bite tongue during control questions and press toes on the floor during control questions)
Explain what was concluded from the study with police officers and polygraphs?
- Police officers are not better than college students at detecting lie
What was concluded from the MacArthur article Violence Risk Assessment Study Revisited article? What’s the debate?
- 1988 researcher reported not more dangerous than general population
- But these population samples were drawn from high-risk neighborhood
- But in fact the violence was high - 27.4% had been violent
- Violence by self-report or family, not always by the legal system
- Issue that was missed initially – if substance abuse abuse and mental illness had comorbidity relationship there was a higher risk for violence in the community
What percentage of gun-related killings in the US between 2001 and 2010 were committed by people with serious mental illness?
4-5%
What percentage of violence is committed by someone with a serious mental illness?
4%
What percentage of mass shootings were done by someone who was mentally ill?
22%
How do we think about the base rate bias as it relates to mass shootings?
- Low frequency but sensational events
- Law develops due to this bias (state by state basis)
- Tendency to view out groups in terms of labels and link behavior of one to the entire group
-Failure to consider base rate in population - Failure to consider real dangerous
What happened in Nikolas Cruz case? How do we assess mental illness concerns?
- 2018 (Killed 17 people at Parkland School)
- Survived and legally obtained AR-15
- Mental health concerns but debate over whether they were serious mental health concerns (depression? developing psychopathy?)
- Given life without parole
- People were calling the police about him and his mother died 6 months before he committed the shooting)
- Takeaway: People with mental health concerns do, even major depression do not go shoot up a school