Material Mind Flashcards
Mind and Body Problem
Problem of understanding the relationship between the mind and body is
Example:
If the mind and the body are seperate
Dualism
Human mind and body are seperate, two things operating
Substance Dualism
Is Cartesian Dualism, named after Descartes
- Mind isn’t brain
- Mind exists as a seperate substance from body, composed of different substances
Two types of substances:
Non-physical/immaterial (mind and soul)
Physical/material (bodies and brain)
Non-physical
How do you weigh or measure a soul?
Physical
Can be weighed and measured
Descartes Arguments:
- Mind and body are different substances
- Mind is immaterial and certain therefore cannot be changed, degraded or destroyed
- Mind and body causally interact with one another
1st Meditation:
Senses are not trustworthy, and senses are bodily therefore it’s subject to change and deception and the mind does not change.
- Cannot be certain we have a body
2nd Meditation:
- One thing certain - My Mind!
- “I think therefore I am”
- We are a thinking thing
- I can conceive myself without a body
- Mind knows better than senses (body), a doctor might know your body better then you but never your mind
Wax analogy
Wax is put next to a fire, it loses it’s shape, colour, smell and taste. Does the same wax remain? Yes. Despite what we had perceived through our senses the wax is still wax and we know that.
- We know our surroundings through reason, the mind is better known then the human body.
6th Meditation P1
P1: I can be sure I have a mind
P2: I cannot be totally sure that I have a body
C: Therefore, mind and body are two different substances
6th Meditation P2
P1: Mind is permeant and unchanging
P2: Physical things are always degrading
C: Therefore mind is not physical but must be a non-degrading substance
6th Meditation P3
P1: Ideas in mind resulted from physical behaviour
P2: Physical experiences that produce ideas in mind
C: Mind and body must interact with each other
Materialism/Physicalism
Belief that everything is physical, just a physical body of which the mind is an aspect of located or identical to the brain
Problem for Descartes:
Mind and body are two different substances, therefore how can they work together?