Malpractice & Risk Management Flashcards
Define medical malpractice
Negligence on the part of a physician, allied health care professional, or hospital that causes physical or emotional damage to the patient
How do we define standard of care?
What most trained providers would do to treat a specific injury or illness
- In theory all providers would have the “same” treatment plan/intervention
If standard of care is not used =
Negligence
Who determines whether the standard of care was met/used?
Medical expert/witness
Medical expert/witnesses are
Objective
What can guide medical expert/witnesses?
Published guidelines, protocols
What is negligence?
Failure to exercise a degree of care
Res ipsa loquitur means what in Latin?
The thing speaks for itself
Res ipsa loquitur is a doctrine of law that one is presumed negligent if…
He/she had exclusive control of whatever caused the injury
- Even if there is no specific evidence of an act of negligence
- Without negligence, the accident would not have happened
Under res ipsa loquitur, who is liable for negligence?
All those connected with the act
What is gross negligence?
Conscious and voluntary disregard of the need to use reasonable care, which is likely to cause foreseeable grave injury or harm to persons
- Implies a level of intent or severe carelessness
What is the statue of limitations in WI for malpractice?
3 years from the time the malpractice occurred OR within one year of the discovery of the injury so long as no more than 5 years had passed
What is the NAME of the statue of limitations in WI for malpractice?
Discovery Rule
What is the $ limit for claims for non-economic damages (i.e.g pain + suffering)
$750,000
Life of a law suit
Error -> notify risk mgmt -> negligence claimed by pt. (beginning of discovery period) -> lawyer/insurance -> mediation (required!) -> law suit is filed if mediation failed -> data retrieval (both sides review ALL records) -> settle OR litigation within the court
Average time from being “put on notice” to completion is how many years?
7
Only __% of cases go to trial
7%
What percent of cases that go to trial are won by plaintiffs?
21%
Who pays for attorney fees, expert fees, court costs?
Insurance company
Who is sued more: physicians OR PAs/PA + physician teams?
Physicians (7600 : 199 in 2019)
4 elements of a negligent action
- Duty
- Breach of duty
- Breach caused injury
- Injury resulted in compensable damages
What is duty?
Evidence that the health care provider had a duty to provide medical care
- Defined when treatment had begun (when you first see the patient)
What is breach of duty?
Evidence that standard of care was not met
- Action or failure to act
Injury/proximate cause (causation)
Proof that an injury occurred + breach was the actual cause of the claimant’s injury
- Whether it would or wouldn’t change the outcome is considered (“the pt. would have died anyway”)
A claimant must have sustained _______ or ________ damage to prosecute a medical negligence suit successfull
Economic or emotional
Examples of damage
- Increased medical bills
- Lost wages
- Death-disability-deformity
- Pain & suffering
- Lost companionship?
Two types of malpractice awards
Compensatory & punitive
What is a compensatory malpractice award?
Money to restore pt to prior functioning or accommodate disability
What are punitive malpractice award?
Deter future wrongful conduct
Common malpractice pitfalls
M - missed diagnoses (not broad ddx)
A - assessment inadequate (e.g. PE)
L - legibility causing medical errors
P - proper documentation & privacy rights
R - results not followed through on
A - alliances with patients - build rapport
C - consent not clearly disclosed
T - timely care (delayed diagnosis or referral)
I - insurance
C - communication
E - ethical practitioner
Reasons PAs are sued
- Lack of adequate supervision (outside of scope)
- Untimely referral
- Failure to diagnose (missed or delayed) M/C!!! ~50%
- Inadequate exam
- Lack of documentation
- Lack of communication
What is negligent supervision?
Employer fails to reasonably monitor and control an employee’s actions