Luke's Notes Flashcards
When is evidence admissible when obtained illegally?
When there was no government action during the obtaining of the evidence.
“Seizure of person”
Occurs when a reasonable person in suspect’s position would not feel free to leave or otherwise terminate the encounter.
“Seizure of Property”
“Meaningful interference with an individual’s possessory interest in property”
How long must property be taken to amount to a seizure?
Taking property, even briefly, is seizure, but placing a tracking device on it is not.
How much force is necessary to seize a person?
Any use of force to restrain a suspect, or a show of authority followed by submission (including just pulling over for flashing lights).
What if police use new technology?
Judges decide REP and consider whether technology is known/readily available to citizens.
What is a “Search”
Government intrusion into a reasonable expectation of privacy.
What is the Katz test?
DF must have:
1) Expectation of privacy (such as pulling curtains closed)
2) Which society is prepared to recognize as reasonable
10 examples of no REP in public:
(1) The scent of marijuana escaping a suitcase
(2) Speaking in a glass phone booth where lip readers can see
(3) A private conversation where the other party has permitted police to record it
(4) Information in a pen register (phone company records of calls made)
(5) Header information (to and from) for e-mails
(6) Hand writing or voice exemplars
(7) Bank records
(8) Things in open fields, unoccupied areas beyond the curtilage of the home (even if police trespass into the open fields or breach a fence to get in)
(9) Naked eye observation by air so long as police comply with flight limitations
(10) Discarded property such as commingled garbage and abandoned rental premises.
What is “Standing”
To claim the EXCLUSIONARY remedy (if owner has REP but wrongdoer doesn’t), only those who are actual victims of the alleged violation have standing to challenge it.
What constitutes standing?
Ownership or possessory interest in the place searched.
Drivers have standing for any vehicle stop, but when do passengers have standing?
Only when stop is unconstitutional. Passengers have no privacy interest in interior of car and can not object to illegal search.
Is ownership of property sufficient for standing?
No. If you are a landlord and rent out the property, you are not in possession of it. And, if you own drugs, and throw them in someone’s purse, you have no right to exclude others from the purse.
What is the “exclusionary rule”?
A judge made rule which states that unconstitutionally obtained evidence must be excluded stemming from government action.
What is the “fruit of the poisonous tree”?
Any additional evidence derived from the initial illegality, including oral statements and physical objects. It is thrown out.
Exceptions to the “exclusionary rule”?
KING
- Knock & Announce Violation — exclusionary rule doesn’t apply to faulty knock (usually 15-20 seconds)
- Impeachment — even non-mirandized statements, except coerced confessions
- Non-guilt phase proceeding — watch for where evidence is introduced, e.g., grand jury / habeus corpus / civil proceedings / parole revocation hearing
- Good Faith Exception — good but for defective search warrant
Who bears the burden of showing that a warrant was improperly issued?
Defendant.
What are the requirements of a valid warrant?
- Probable Cause
- Particularity
- Neutral & Detached Magistrate
What is “Probable Cause”?
Must provide relevant facts that lead to the conclusion that it is MORE PROBABLE THAN NOT that a person committed a crime or that evidence will be found in a particular location. Information presented cannot be STALE (too old).
What are the requirements for Probable Cause?
- Must point to GUILT of a CRIME: Facts suggest a fairly narrow range of possibilities (not descriptions fitting large numbers of people or a large segment of the community).
- Must not be AMBIGUOUS: some uncertainty as to perp OK, NOT whether crime occurred; if unsure whether there was a crime, can’t start searching people.
- If as consistent with innocent activity as criminal, NO PC for arrest
- Hearsay tips may lead to PC if reliable, considering the totality of circumstances: Informant has “basis of knowledge” and high amount of “veracity”; Gates: Deficiency in one may be compensated for by a strong showing as to3 the other (e.g., anonymous but highly detailed tip, or a very reliable source with details that would otherwise be innocent / not very particular)
When are hearsay tips allowed?
When they are reliable, considering the totality of circumstances. Informant has “basis of knowledge” and “high amount of veracity” (old rule).
New rule (Gates): Deficiency in one may be compensated by a strong showing as to the other.
What is “Particularity”?
Must describe with REASONABLE CERTAINTY the place to be searched and the items to be seized. This includes right address or good description of particular place to be searched.
What information for a warrant is required if place to be searched is in a Multi-Unit Building?
Must specify apartment. If didn’t know it was multi-unit until got there, can search more IF:
(1) Nature of building unknown and could not have been discovered with reasonable investigation, AND
(2) discovery occurred after police proceeded so far that withdrawal would jeopardize search AND
(3) Upon discovery, reasonable efforts made to determine which unit most likely connected to criminality.
What is “Neutral and Detached Magistrate”?
(1) Not involved in search or investigation
(2) Not paid only upon issuing warrant
(3) Court clerk okay if capable of determining whether PC exists (within scope of expertise)
How to rehabilitate warrant if NOT issued by a NaDM?
Was the search done in good faith? If so, okay so long as officer should/could not have known it was NOT a good warrant.
So if officer misleads magistrate, then warrant is invalid. But if magistrate effs up, warrant can be relied on in good faith.
What is required for Plain View?
- Lawful vantage point from where evidence can be plainly viewed (watch for way to be lawfully present in house, e.g., hot pursuit or emergency response)
- AND has lawful right of access to the object (no trespass)
- AND incriminating of the item is “immediately apparent” by 5 senses (not hunch/curiosity)