Lectures M2-Final Flashcards
Optimal fat reserves
for animals
- Animals must maintain short-term and long-term fat reserves
Benefits of fat reserves: insurance, insulation
Costs of fat reserves: weight, increased energy expenditure, reduced mobility → increased predation risk
- Animals show adaptive fat storage (must optimally balance fat reserves, which is a cost)
- Winter in higher latitudes = longer nights, lower temperature, higher variance + uncertainty
Fat reserves in humans
- Sufficient energy for over 50 days!
> 60% of the brain (myelin is mostly fat)
10-20% in men
15-25% in women
When do animals store more fat
- animals in higher latitudes would store more fat in the winter than in either fall or spring
- animals that experience more interruptions would store more fat
4 considerations when determining what an animal should eat
- encounter rate
- energy content
- handling time
- predation risk
Encounter rate
of items encountered per unit time
Handling time
time from capture to complete ingestion
e.g. takes time to feed, access, sit in the flower, etc.
Should the grizzly eat the whole fish or just brain and eggs (richest in calories)?
Answer: it depends:
- Assume that prey 1 (brain) and prey 2 (fish body) have the same encounter rate
- Prey 1 has about twice the energy content than prey 2
- If the encounter rate with prey 1 is sufficiently high, avoid prey 2
The optimal diet model
depends on (3 things)
a simple mathematical model that allows us to predict what prey types a forager should eat based on the energy content, encounter rate, and handling time of each type
2 key predictions of the optimal diet model
- If the encounter rate with the most profitable prey (prey 1) is above a threshold level, only this prey should be eaten
- The encounter rate with prey 2 should not affect the decision whether to feed on prey 2
A test of the optimal diet model with great tits
mealworm density
Presented mealworms at varying density and encounter rate
Prediction:
- At low prey densities, both types should be eaten
- At high prey densities, even when the large prey is less common than the small prey (0.3:0.7), only the large prey should be eaten
Result:
- pretty much that except some small prey were still taken
The optimal patch (of food) residence time
- A forager should stay in the current patch until its rate of intake is equal to the average rate of intake in other patches
- A forager should stay longer in a patch if the travel time between patches is longer
Travel time great tits experiments
- became more difficult to find more mealworms the more they caught them
- greater travel time increased duration in the patch
same as predictions
Simple mathematical models predict… (3 things)
all related to food
- what food types animals should choose,
- where they should forage, and
- how long they should feed in a patch before moving on to another patch
The moose dilemma + solution
dilemma: balancing (i) energy-rich, sodium-poor terrestrial plants and (ii) sodium-rich, energy-poor aquatic plants
The moose solution: such a model predicts that a moose should spend ~18% of its foraging time on the sodium-rich, energy-poor aquatic plants (approximately what moose do)
The central challenge for most animals is staying alive
predation
Predators to humans
Few large predators: bear, mountain lions
Large animals: bison, elk
Venomous animals: snapes, etc.
3 adaptations by humans that reduce their probability of being hit by cars
like predator avoidance
- avoidance in space
- avoidance in time
- inspection/vigilance
Analogy is imperfect because, unlike predators, car drivers do not attempt to hit pedestrians
Predator-prey arms race: vervet monkeys and crown eagles
- monkeys stay away from exposed tree tops
→ eagles fly among trees
→ monkeys have a special eagle alarm call and attempt to drop to dense bushes
→ eagle has short wings, which helps if it has to plunge through the canopy
Prey has evolved good counter adaptations
Balancing courtship and antipredatory behaviour: tree frogs
tree frog males use their call to attract females, but this might instead attract a bat predator and biting flies that transmit disease
Balancing feeding and antipredatory behaviour - 2 key questions
Food and patch choice: should an animal prefer lesser quality food at a safer place?
What is the optimal amount of fat?
- feed or scan
- keep feeding or flee
- stay in shelter or resume feeding
Balancing feeding and anti predatory behaviour - ants example
Ants could choose between two patches containing liquid ant diet of different concentrations. The high concentration patch was either safe or had a predator
Ants preferred the safer, less rewarding patch as long as:
- it was not much worse (as low as ~ 8 times worse concentration)
- the predator remained active
Horse sensitivity to weight
Horse racing: must calculate the exact weight they must put on a horse to equalise horses
0.3% of horse weight (1.5 kg) would cause a ½ body length speed reduction
Great tits optimal body fat
predation
- added weight decreases ascent angle
- can’t evade predation
- aviaries with more protection = fatter birds
- more fat in years with no predators
- More fat when food is less certain
- Less fat when predation risk is higher
Optimal egg hatching choice in red-eyed tree frogs
the over water hatching thing
- respond to vibrations signalling predation by dropping into the water
The leaves are associated with terrestrial predators (snakes and wasps), the water has aquatic predators (shrimp and fish)
strongly prefer to hatch @ 7 days night
if certain of terrestrial predation, hatch days 5/6
otherwise hatch days 7–11
Parasitism
- Major cause of mortality in all animals including humans
- For historic reasons, we term tiny parasites such as bacteria and viruses disease
Death from ‘parasites’
~37 million people in the world have AIDS, 2.1 million are infected annually, 1.1 million died in 2015
- More than 35 million people have died of AIDS since 1981
~2 million people, mostly children die from malaria each year
- Flu kills about 30,000 people a year in the USA
- SARS, avian flu, COVID-19
Malaria
- Malaria may have killed half of all the people that ever lived
- More people are now infected than at any point in history
- Up to half a billion cases & 2 million deaths every year, half of those are children in sub-Saharan Africa
Parasite avoidance in tree frogs
- Snails are intermediate hosts of a trematode parasite (Protozoa)
- Many parasites have a complex lifestyle where they move from one host to another
= tree frogs use them as a cue - Low density + low parasite infections rates
Compared egg laying sites with:
- No snails (control)
- Low density + high parasite infections rates
- High density + high parasite infections rates
- Low density + low parasite infections rates
- Low density + low parasite infections rates
No snails: happy tree frogs laid thousands of eggs
Infected snails: no eggs laid
Uninfected snails: laid some eggs, but more when few snails
Dramatic sensitivity to presence of parasites and host that transmits this parasite
Lion’s sex roles
Females raise young and hunt (risky)
Males eat, have sex and protect their female mates and their offspring
If the male of the family dies, a male will invade and eat her cubs because he won’t protect cubs that aren’t his, then they make new babies together
roles provide greatest fitness to both sexes
Cinderella effect (step-parents)
Step-parents are more likely to use violence against, and withdraw resources from, their children than are genetic parents
Why do males and females look different?
Who is usually more ornamented?
Because of sexual selection (which is a type of natural selection)
Males → tend to be more colourful and ornamented than the females in many species
Natural selection
differential survival or reproduction of individuals differing in one or more heritable traits
Sexual selection
differential reproduction owing to heritable variation in the ability to obtain mates
Optimal gamete size
result of?
result of divergent selection
Females: large gametes (egg)
Human egg is 100μm
Males: small gametes (sperm)
Sperm is 3μm
(bimodal distribution graph)
Investment per gamete
Female:
- Gametes: large, immobile
- Limited by: resources to gametes
- Can invest in relatively few gametes
Male:
- Gametes: small, mobile
- Limited by: access to females (this underlies sexual selection
- Can produce many gametes
Operational sex ratio
of males ready to mate / # of females ready to mate
Two typical outcomes of operational sex ratio + connection to male ornamentation
- Females are choosy, males are typically more promiscuous
- Male ornaments serve in female choice - Males compete with other males for access to females
- Male weapons serve in male-male competition
Sexual selection stronger in males or females
- Typically stronger in males
- Males can gain more than females from traits that increase their mating success
- Typically, males have more ornaments, so females would choose them, and weapons for male-male competition
Why are human sex roles confusing
- not clear which sex is more ornamented
- males larger and stronger
due to…
- biparental care + mutual mate choice
Grebe mating and parental care (video)
Mutual assessment of partners through coordinated movement and food exchange:
- Dancing, repeating each other’s movements
- Each gives a gift: sample of what each plants to contribute when they make their nest together
Shared parental care
Mate choice - who chooses who?
- The focus is on females choosing males (fundamental aspect of sexual selection)
- Do males choose females? If the investment is more equal like in biparental care, it makes sense for males to choose a female as well
Mate choice experiment - flies multistep process
How do female flies choose?
1. Male orients when discovering a female
- Taps her
- Sings a song to convince the female he is right for her
- Licking: instincts rely on smell and taste, so male gets both olfactory and taste info about the female from a variety of chemicals
- Male attempts to copulate, but female has full control over the mating
- If she accepts, she typically changes her posture so he can copulate
What do female flies consider while choosing males? (4 things)
- Smell/taste = body odour/flavour composition: compatibility and quality
- Song: compatibility and quality
- Body size: larger is better (below a species threshold)
- Recent matings: discriminate against more than 2 recent matings
Mate choice in pied flycatchers
2 vague things they need
female pied flycatchers prefer males who:
1. sing
2. have contrasting colours
Why do birds sing
means come mate + establishing territories
- each bird listens to its ones range of sound among the other
When do birds sing
Dawn:
- Light intensities are too low for finding food, no insects out
- Air is calm, which is good for sound transmission
- This makes dawn the best time for singing
calm air + cannot find food + female fertility is highest at dawn
What birds sing (m/f) + why
Typically, only the males (suggests that sexual selection is involved)
- Attract females
- In male-male interactions (territorial defense)
Song repertoire size and pairing date in sedge warblers
Large repertoire was preferred by females, so they paired with females early = earlier pairing date
increases fitness
- offspring older by migrating time
- those who nest earlier have a higher chance of successfully producing offspring (due to possible nesting failures)
Muting red-winged blackbirds experiment
Territorial red-winged blackbirds were trapped and their syrinx nerves were removed
vs. control males
Results
Muted males had:
- more intrusions
- more fights
- more territory losses
Shows: important function of bird song in male mating
So, why do females choose?
4 reasons
- Direct benefits
- Good genes (indirect benefits)
- Runaway selection
- Sensory exploitation
Direct benefits - mate choice
Females prefer males with the highest positive effect on females’ fitness (survival and / or reproduction)
This also exists in humans (e.g. gifts)
Nuptial gifts in scorpionflies = example of …
example of a direct benefit
- Females reject males that do not offer them prey (dead insects) + prefer males that offer large prey
- Direct fitness benefit of nuptial gifts: females that receive larger nuptial gifts produce more eggs and perhaps have longer lifespan
- females mate longer with those who bring them large prey (up to 20mm^2)
Female choice in barn swallows = example of …
relates to parasitism
example of a direct benefit
- Males have longer tails than females
- Males with longer tails have fewer parasitic mites → females prefer longer-tailed males
- Longer tail = fewer parasitic mites + more parental care of young + greater reproductive success + fledglings with larger body mass
- Females that choose males with longer tails likely have a higher reproductive success
Why can’t we just look at direct benefits
- In many animals, the males contribute only sperm (genes) to the “family”
- That is, the males provide neither food nor help in raising the offspring
- So direct benefit is less likely
Sage grouse
leks
- Only 66 males on leks in spring 2009
- Canada’s most endangered species: 400 individuals (2019)
used to be 10 million - Sagebrush plant is necessary for nesting and wintering habitat
- High quality cover is essential for nesting and brood rearing
- The leks are at traditional sites, used for many generations (indicates social learning)
Leks
a specific location where males come in spring every year, and when females are ready, they come and choose one of the males
SARA: Species At Risk Act
- A new Canadian law from 2003
- Scientists and NGOs have worked with the government on a bill that can truly protect animals and plants
Environmental organisations have won in 2012 a legal battle that required the federal government to take further action for protecting the sage grouse in Alberta
Ecojustice Canada
Ecojustice goes to court and uses the power of the law to defend nature, combat climate change, and fight for a healthy environment for all
Cock of the rock and leks video = example of…
mate choice copying
The male’s contribution: sperm transferred during a brief mating
- Males assemble in groups of dozens
- Female is dull, males are bright orange (sexual selection)
- Each male owns a particular patch of ground on which he displays alone, each tries to persuade the female to land beside them.
- Males compete and females raise the family on their own
Two females made the same male choice (remember fish colour copying)
Larval hymenoptera predator defense
secrete a viscous compound that glues together the appendages of predators, sometimes killing them
Annelid predator defense
Bioluminescent bombs: small sacs of green fluorescent light that annelid worms secrete when encountering predators, so the worm can escape the danger
Natural selection on antipredator tactics
If an individual makes an error with respect to the antipredator tactics it uses, its future reproductive success may be zero
- So natural selection operates very strongly
Two types of antipredator behaviours
- Help prey avoid detection by predators
- Function once prey encounters a predator
Benefit of avoiding predators
Avoiding detection helps as they decrease not only the probability of being captured and eaten but also the costs associated with fleeing or fighting back
Three ways to avoid predators
- Blending into the environment
- Being quiet
- Choosing safe habitats
Blending into the background - 3 examples
- Beach mouse
- Cephalopods
- Australian cuttlefish
Beach mouse camouflage
what mutation
- Fur coloration matches the background of the beaches on which they live
- Further from the beach = darker, closer to the beach = lighter (light sand)
- Mechanism: single mutation in the melanocortin-1 receptor (Mc1r)
Cephalopods (octopuses, squids, cuttlefish) camouflage
- Behaviorally change colour to blend into their environment, decreasing their chances of being attacked by a predator
- Have sharp night vision to also do this at night
Australian cuttlefish different camouflage types (3)
- used to hide from predators with good night vision
- Uniform camouflage (rare):
pattern: single skin colour that matched their background
used when: mimicking the rocks around them - Mottled camouflage (common):
pattern: small dark/light splotches all over skin, the size and colour mimicking its background
used when: background is composed of small rocks and dark algae - Disruptive camouflage:
pattern: changed colour + pattern, taking on large light and dark stripes to visually break up it’s body to not look like a cuttlefish
used when: sometimes used to mimic background, or just in general so it doesn’t look like a cuttlefish
Gulf toadfish and being quiet
- Gulf toadfish are preyed on by adult bottlenose dolphins
- Dolphins orient toward the “boat-whistle” sound produced by male toadfish during breeding season
toadfish listen for pop sounds from dolphins, then reduce their call rates + showed higher cortisol
Choice of Nesting Sites in Parrots
TC nesters: bird taxa that contain both species that nest in tree cavities
OC “other” cavity nesters: species that nest in other sorts of cavities (ex. Termite mounds, the sides of cliffs)
- ancestral state was tree cavity nesting
- multiple independent evolutions of other cavity nesting
- likely due to predation pressures
bc OC nesters have longer nesting periods but not larger clutch sizes (=not due to competition)
Coevolution, Naive Prey, and Introduction Programs - environmental conservation
what type of cues
Olfactory cues from predators that were similar to predators in Europe that rabbits have evolved with: (foxes, cats, ferrets) Australian rabbits responded with adaptive antipredator behaviours
Olfactory cues from quoll: (an endemic Australian predator), rabbits did not display antipredator behaviours, leaving them susceptible to quoll predation.
Neuroendocrine changes
regulated by … cortex
Frontal cortex regulates the effect of stressors on behaviour, alters neurological and endocrinological responses to stressors
Mice with stressors (behaviour)
Expose mice to two different stressors: the odour of a predator OR physical stress via immobilisation using the universal mouse restrainer
- increased the circulation of the neurotransmitters acetylcholine, serotonin, and dopamine within the frontal cortex
predators caused more anxiety than being restrained
chlordiazepoxide (reduces anxiety in humans) = no more increase in these neurotransmitters
5 behaviours upon predator encounter
- Fleeing
- Approaching to obtain info
- Feigning death
- Signalling to the predator
- Fighting back
Examples of fleeing behaviours
most common antipredator response
- Bird flying into the trees for safety
- Fish heading for cover in a coral reef
- Embryonic tadpoles falling from a branch into the relative safety of the water
Meta-analysis: what determines if an animal will flee
The meta-analysis found that many variables, including the degree of crypsis, the distance to a refuge, morphological traits relating to defence, and the prey’s experience with a predator influenced decisions about when to flee
Flight initiation distance
distance between prey and predator at which point they decide to flee
The Genetics of Schooling Behaviour in Fish
Variation in the Eda gene (chromo 4) in part explains variation in stickleback schooling behaviour
Offspring from benthic (shore) population parents with the inserted promoter schooled in a manner more similar to pelagic (open water) than wild-type benthic fish.
Heritability of Conditioned Fear Responses - rodents
Hypothesis: if natural selection has shaped conditioned fear responses, then this suite of behaviours should be heritable
Fear conditioning = increased amygdala activity = increased heart rate, defecation, freezing behavior, etc = suggests it plays a key role in the conditioned fear response
Approaching predators benefit + definition + result
- Allow prey to gather important information to reduce chance of mortality
Characterized by: a series of moves toward the predator interrupted by stationary pauses and sometimes alternating with moves away from the predator
Result in: prey retreating, prey rejoining a social group of conspecifics nearby, or an escalation in which prey actually attack the predator
The Costs and Benefits of Thomson’s Gazelles Approaching a Predator
Pros:
- Decrease current risk of predation
- Allow gazelles to gather information about a potential threat
- Serve to warn other group members of the potential danger associated with predators
Cons:
- opportunity cost of lost time
Larger gazelle groups = inspection behaviour is most common and most pronounced = cheetahs move farther away = decreased prey mortality
Death feigning in insects
in response to a predator, an insect falls and then remind frozen, absolutely still (tonic immobility)
Death Feigning in the Adzuki Bean Beetle
Negative genetic correlation exist between the length of death feigning and the ability to fly
Long-duration = poor flyers
Short-duration = better flyers
and v.v.
beetles in populations selected for long bouts of death feigning had higher brain concentrations of dopamine than beetles from populations selected for short bouts of death feigning
die longer = happy
Signalling to predators purpose
prey transmit information to a predator to deter an attack, warning the predator of the dangers of contact, or that it has been sighted and may not succeed in capturing a prey
Warning Coloration in Monarch Butterflies
Monarch butterflies: ingest milkweed plants, which contain cardiac glycosides: chemicals that are toxic to birds, but do not harm the monarchs
If a bird predator eats a monarch: toxins in the monarch make the predator violently ill + birds learn to associate monarch colour with illness, so they avoid feeding on monarchs
predators learn from watching others get sick, also sense toxin upon only touching
Tail Flagging as a Signal in Ungulates
individuals flag their tails after a predator has been sighted, most often when the predator is at a safe distance
Many possible functions…
- Entice predator to attach from further = unsuccessful
- Warn group members
= Can make them close ranks or engage in other antipredator behaviours
- Signal to the predator that is has been spotted and that the deer will be too fast to catch
Chemical Defense in Bombardier Beetles - current
Predation threat = they mix chemicals from the reservoir and reaction chamber to spray a hot, acidic, noxious chemical of p-benzoquinones that injures predators
selectively aim
Chemical Defense in Bombardier Beetles - ancestors
M. contractus: oldest extant bombardier beetle species has a similar mechanism, suggesting that it is an ancestral characteristic
Rear attack = froth secretion, which builds up on the body of the beetle and wards off predators.
Front attack = forces the chemical secretion forward, along tracks on its forewings
Why? Lowers the temperature of the chemicals from 100°C to 55°C
Suggests that: spraying an extremely hot chemical secretion may be a derived trait, but that frothing and using the forewing tracks to disseminate a somewhat reduced heat spray is the ancestral version of the trait
Social Learning and Mobbing in Blackbirds
- Noisy friarbird: novel bird that neither had seen before and it looked nothing like their known predators
- Naive blackbird saw the friarbird alone. Model blackbird saw friarbird + a little owl (known predator)
- From the viewpoint of the naive subject, the little owl was out of sight, so that when the model mobbed the little owl, the naive individual saw it mobbing a friarbird
Results:
- Cultural transmission of information about what constitutes a danger: when naive blackbirds saw a model mobbing a friarbird, they were more likely to mob this odd new creature than if they had not been exposed to the mode
- Found the blackbird cultural transmission chain to be six birds long: naive birds who learned from models were able to become new models, etc.
Predation and Foraging Trade-Offs
Time engaged in anti predator activity could be spent on: foraging, mating, resting, playing, etc.
Antipredator behaviour can create pressure to perform other behaviours differently: forage in the vicinity of a refuge, mate at times when predation is minimal, etc
Predation pressure affects virtually every aspect of foraging