Lectures 1-5 Flashcards
What is the Technology readiness level of a product
defines the maturity of the product
What does TRL stand for
technology readiness level
What is the form of a product
The shape of the product
What is the function of a product
The function of the product
What is ergonomics
The design for human use and interface
What is aethetics
Design for beautiful appeal
What is product design a combination of?
Engineering design and industrial design
What does industrial design include
Aesthetics, ergonomic, safety and reliability
How many technology readiness levels are there
9 with TRL0 being the idea and TRL9 being a commercially applicable product
What describes the different stages a product goes through from an idea to a product with a fully commercial application
Technology readiness levels
When a new product uses new technology, what TRLs should it go through
all of them
When a product uses existing technology, which TRLs should it go through
From TRL4 (small scale prototype)
Does a product have to sequentially go through the TRL levels
No, level 2 may start before level 1
What TRL levels do universities deal with
TRL 0-4
What TRL levels do industry tend to deal with
TRL 2-9
Why is it important for products to go through systematic methods and procedures?
So that decisions can be made efficiently and effectively
How many parts may a car contain
10,000 parts
Why is a product so complex
because a product has thousands of parts and each part involves a lot of precise design information. Also each part may also represent a complex technology itself
Give an example of a known unknown
true safety margins (some safety margins may be less than thought)
Give an example of an unknown unknown
load cases that cannot be predicted
Explain the complexity of organisations that may occur when producing a car
Designing a car involves multiple companies with diverse multi-disciplinary design teams consisting of thousands of people. A car may contain parts from 100s of different suppliers in a hierarchical structure
Why must each part have a paper trail
so that it can be shown where a part has come from and that the original supplier has quality control methods and has carried out necessary test verification. This is to help give proof if a company is prosecuted for false claims
Describe the complexity of documentation
The fact that commercial products need verification and documentation
What are the 8 major objectives of a car
Technical performance Cost Environment Ergonomics Aesthetics Reliability and Safety Manufacturing
What work is done and method used by mechanical engineers for Technical performance
Vibration analysis
Strength design
Through material selection
What work is done and method used by mechanical engineers for Cost
materials selection and life cycle costing through life cycle costing
What work is done and method used by mechanical engineers for Environment
life cycle analysis and material selection through life cycle analysis
What work is done and method used by mechanical engineers for Ergonomics
Ergonomic design and modelling. Beneficial to liaise with an industrial engineer
What work is done and method used by mechanical engineers for Aesthetics
industrial design through colour selection and following aesthetic guidelines. Beneficial to liaise with an industrial designer
What work is done and method used by mechanical engineers for Reliability and safety
reliability modelling. beneficial to liaise with a reliability engineer
What work is done and method used by mechanical engineers for Manufacturing
Complete manufacturing design with tolerance analysis. Beneficial to liaise with a manufacturing engineer
What objectives come under Technical performance for a car
- Drive: speed, acceleration, range, stability, turning circle
- Size: cabin space, number of seats, boot space
What objectives come under Cost for a car
- Purchase cost
- Maintenance (MOT, servicing)
- Running cost (Tax, insurance, fuel consumption)
- Depreciation (resale value)
What objectives come under ergonomics for a car
- Space
- Forces
- Comfort
- Man machine interface
What objectives come under safety for a car
- Crumple zones
- Warning lights
- Braking systems
- Driver’s view
- Fail safe (bolts facing up not down)
What objectives come under reliability for a car
- Redundancy (Manual and central locking, extra bolts on engine head)
- fail safe
What objectives come under luxury for a car
- Comfort extras (air con, seat adjustment and quality)
- Convenience
- entertainment
What objective come under Environment for a car
- Emissions
- Waste
- Full consumption
What objectives come under aesthetics
- External (character line, borders, curves)
- Internal (textures, colours, blending)
- General (biomimetics)
Give the case study of Toyota accelerator pedal problem and what it is an example of
- Illustrates how a company can experience problems due to unknown unknowns (a scenario they didnt know they didnt know about)
- Cars had to be recalled due to the accelerator pedal being able to get caught on the floor mats which could have been very dangerous
- cost of the recall was $2 billion
- They solved the problem by reducing the size of the pedal and introducing a new design of floor mat
- A brake override system was implemented that would cut of the engine if the break and accelerator are both detected as being pressed
- They made a million correct decisions throughout the design of the car, but a single incorrect decision can have massive implications
What are the 7 challenges of product design?
- Fast changing environmental conditions
- Conflicts between form and function
- retaining information
- High reliability
- Products have multiple objectives
- Products are complicated
- Many stages are required to develop products
What are the three main areas of complexity for products
- Complexity of the product
- Complexity of organisations
- Complexity of documentations
What does it mean to have a vast ‘design heritage’
When a product has gone through multiple life cycles and knowledge has been retained throughout the process
What is meant by a dominant design
Through adaptive design, a design is gradually modified and improved to become a design that is commonly seen among products within the same market as it has been recognised through the adaptive process as being the most successful design
Give an example of a car that has gone through many generations of design cycles
Honda accord
What is meant by the conflicts between form and function
When a particular form might effect the product in being able to complete its desired function.
Give an example of where there has been a conflict between form and function
The millennium bridge
What are the key changes around environmental conditions which may effect future products.
- Push to remove diesel cars and replace with electric (air quality, taxing etc)
- Publicity about amounts of plastic waste
What is the current challenge for the car industry due to fast changing environmental conditions
The EU has given a target for the amount of CO2 emissions, therefore the industry invested in diesel technology (as it is more efficient at using fuel compared to petrol) in order to meet these targets However the government have started taxing diesels and the media have been badly publicising them therefore sales of diesels have reduced making it highly unlikely for the industry to meet the targets
Give 4 examples of key area for future development in engineering and product design
- Electric cars
- Robotics
- Renewable energy
- Domestic products
What is the biggest industry in the UK
Automotive
Why is a design process needed
A design process is needed to systematically co-ordinate the efforts of large multi-disciplinary design teams
Give an example of a multi-objective design
Aircraft seat with • Technical requirements • ergonomic requirements • aesthetic requirements • Entertainment systems
According to Pahl and Beitz, what are the 3 modes of design
- Incremental design
- Adaptive design
- Original design
Explain incremental design, why and when it is used
Minor changes/improvements to an existing product
very common because it presents low-risk design. Common in industries with mature products such as high volume products (cars, domestic appliances)
Incremental design is enable by new elements of technology such as new materials and new manufacturing processes
It also occurs when a fault has been detected
Give an example of incremental design
Improve the windscreen material in a car
Explain Adaptive design
When significant changes/improvements are made to whole sub systems
It is common when significant new technologies come along such as airbags/crumple zones
Give an example of adaptive design
The implementation of airbags/crumple zones
Explain Original design
This is when major changes or improvement are made to whole sub systems.
The original design is not common because it is high risk. It tends to happen when there is an acute need as with pollution and energy concerns with motor cars
It is risky due to the need for the entire design to be error free. Changing all design details make it more likely for something to go wrong in comparison to incremental design
Give an example of original design
The change from IC engine to hybrid drive train in a car
What are the high level stages in a product life cycle
- Motivation
- Creation
- Operation
- Disposal