Lecture Content Flashcards
What are single case designs and what is the main issue with them?
a design where the IV is assessed using data from a single participant
all single case designs lack generalizability! (due to there only being one participant)
What are the types of single case designs?
- ABA Reversal Design
- behaviour observed at baseline –> treatment –> baseline - ABAB Reversal Design
- behaviour observed at baseline –> treatment –> baseline –> treatment - Multiple Baseline Design
- Observing behaviour after manipulation is introduced under several circumstances –> different people, different places/settings, or different behaviours
(ex. a baseline for how much a student reads at home is set, and then how much that child reads at school is measured)
What are 2 reasons why ABAB Reversal Designs are typically better than ABA Reversal Designs?
- Limits the external error that ABA designs often have
- More ethical to end on treatment (B) rather than withdrawal of treatment (A) as treatment may be beneficial to participant
What are some characteristics of Quasi-Experimental Designs?
- cannot make casual inferences, but indicates how variables are related
- Often used when random assignment is impractical or not possible
- uses preexisting categories/groups
What are the 6 types of Quasi-Experimental Designs?
- One-group posttest only design
- One-group pretest-posttest design
- Non-equivilant control group
- Non-equivilant control group pretest-posttest design
- Interrupted Time Series Design
- Control Series Design
What are multiple repeated measures designs? What designs fall into this category?
Designs that have multiple pretests and posttests overtime rather than just 1
Interrupted time series designs and control series designs are both multiple repeated measures designs
What are the 3 types of developmental designs?
- Cross-sectional
- talk to people at different ages at one time - Longitudinal
- talk to the same people over periods of time
- *Expensive and difficult to do because of how long it takes - Sequential
- 2 groups of people at a cross-sectional time point, and follow both groups over time
- provides a stronger argument for what might be a natural human development!
- a combo of cross-sectional and longitudinal
How do Quasi and Correlational Experiments differ?
Quasi = can deal with multiple (2+) discrete groups without inherent order
Correlational = can deal ONLY with 2 discrete groups without inherent order
**both have no randomization and both measure outcome measures
List and explain the 5 threats to internal validity
- History
- any external event that effects participants between 1st and 2nd measurements
- Ex. midterms are between 1st and 2nd condition of violent video game study - Maturation
- People change over time (become tired, hungry or more mature)
- Ex. mom gives sick son a drink to help him feel better, he feels better a few days later but likely because sickness got better over time not due to the drink - Testing
- Where having a pretest itself can be enough to change a participants protest (like a practice effect)
- Ex. reflecting on how much they smoke in the prestest could be enough to reduce their smoking - Instrument Decay
- basic characteristics of a measurement instrument (timers, software programs, etc.), or the way the participant uses it (become tired, use rating scale differently), changes over time
- Ex. piano recital with rubric example - Regression toward the Mean
- participants who are selected because of their extreme scores tend to later score closer to the mean
- Ex. very hard to get 99% or 1% twice on an exam
What do we try to understand from factorial graphs?
Trying to understand interactions!
What are the steps for gathering info from a line graph?
- Look if the lines are parallel
- If NOT parallel, then there is an interaction! - Look at the midpoints of the lines
- Midpoints = marginal means!
- Marginal means tell you if there is a main effect of the moderator variable (second IV) - Look at the average values between the DV at each level of the IV
- If they are different, it tells you there is a main effect of the primary factor (first IV) that’s on the x-axis
What can we determine depending on if a factorial line graph crosses or not?
IF overlap/crosses –> cannot determine that one IV is always going to lead to higher changes in DV
If NO overlap –> can determine that the IV will always lead to changes in DV
What are simple main effects?
effect of ONE IV on the DV within a single level of the 2nd IV
Ex. More dogs will sit when you tell them to “sit” rather than not telling them to “sit” –
IF you hold food in your hand
^Only one level of second variable = presence of food
^One full effect of first variable = no command, command
Why do we have to decide on one way to split the data for factorial designs?
We cannot analyze data in all possible combinations –> choose the difference that you want to focus on
(usually always the x-axis!)
When choosing a way to split data, what axis is usually always focused on/chosen?
The x-axis (1st variable)
Often trying to see how the moderator (2nd variable) effects that specific chosen interaction on the x-axis!
What are IV x PV designs?
Are a 2x2 factorial design!
allows researchers to investigate how different types of individuals (PV) respond to the same manipulated variable (DV)
Ex.
Factor 1 (iv) = violent vs non-violent video games
Factor 2 (pv) = male vs female
Describe the difference between crossed factorial and nested factorial designs?
crossed factorial = research study that allows for full crossover of ALL possible conditions
nested factorial = one IV is nested in the other IV, so no full crossing
Ex. leaves are nested in trees. Therefore, if a study uses tree species as factor A and leaves as another factor B, factor B (leaves) is nested in factor A (trees)
What set of principles do we use in Canada and what is used in US to evaluate ethical research issues?
Canada = TCPS
US = Belmont Report
List the 3 ethical principles of TCPS (Belmont Report)
- Concern for Welfare (Beneficence)
- Respect for Persons (Autonomy)
- Justice (Justice)
What does Concern For Welfare (Beneficence) involve?
It provides a risk-based analysis
Asks: “Is the participants’ experiences vastly different from their everyday experiences?”
What are the types of risks Concern for Welfare looks at?
- Physical risk (harm to body)
- Emotional/Psychological Harm
- Social Risk (determining if there is a NEED for this study –> would it be ethically wrong for society to not do this study)
- Privacy & Confidentiality
What are exemptions of studies that would not need to meet concern for welfare guidelines?
- program evaluation
- studies that do not involve human/living participants (ex. archival research)
- evaluating teaching method
What does Respect for Persons (Autonomy) involve?
Must treat participants as autonomous people who are able to make deliberate decisions regarding participation.
Why or why not is deception minimal risk?
DECEPTION IS NOT MINIMAL RISK - it’s a violation of respect for persons
What are sins of commission and sins of omission for deception?
Sins of commission (doing something):
- lying
- misleading participants to believe things about experiment or themselves that are not true
Sins of ommission (not doing something):
- leaving out details bc researcher is worried that detail will limit participants desire to participate in study
What must occur with debriefing?
- must explain purpose of research at end of study
- apologize and explain why deception was necessary
- ask participants not to tell anyone!
(debriefing is important with Respect for Persons)
What does the ethical principle of Justice involve?
Fairness and sound rational in participant recruitment
*one population should not bear all the risks of research!
Justice protects disempowered and socially vulnerable populations!
What is assent?
Assent is consent of children given by parents as children cannot express real consent
*This was obviously not received with residential schools –> Indigenous people have a history of experiencing disproportionate costs to research even today
List the benefits of animal research
- allows researchers to control genetic makeup of “participants” –> easier to draw conclusions
- Easier to study physiological, neurological, and genetic foundations of bahaviours.
List and describe the 3 R’s of ethical animal research
- Replacement
- Only do studies on animals if alternatives do not exist - Refinement
- Minimize/eliminate animal distress by modifying experimental procedures
- Includes living conditions - Reduction
- choose animal designs that require the fewest animal subjects as possible
What are some main beliefs animal rights groups hold?
- animals are just as likely as humans to suffer
- animals have inherent rights and values equal to humans
- animals should not bear burden of research to benefit other species
*these all reflect the ethical principle of justice!
Researchers are encouraged to take the perspective of ___________________________
TRUSTING THE PARTICIPANT
What are quantitative variables?
data that can be measured/counted
(NUMERICAL DATA)
What are qualitative variables?
descriptive data of things that cannot be numerically measured/counted