Lecture and Recitation 1 Flashcards
What is Quantitative
Thought of as Objective Research questions like “How many” and “strength of association” Tests a theory Measurable Researcher is separate from process Strives for generalization → leads to prediction Basic element of analysis is numbers Context free “Counts the beans”
What is Qualitative
Thought of as Subjective
Research questions like “what”, “how” and “why”
Develops a theory
Interpretive
Researcher is part of the process
Strives for uniqueness → leads to understanding
Basic element of analysis is words/ideas
Context dependent
Provides information as to “which beans are worth counting”
Definitions
● Collecting, analyzing and interpreting data by observing what people do and say. Qualitative research refers to the meanings, concepts, definitions, characteristics, metaphors, symbols and description of things.
● Qualitative research is subjective and uses very different methods of collecting information, including individual, in-depth interviews and focus groups. The nature of this type of research is exploratory and open-ended.
(Features of Qualitative Research)
Naturalistic
○ Context dependent
○ Actions are understood within settings
○ Circumstances are important
(Features of Qualitative Research)
Descriptive Data
○ Narrative form of reporting is common, quotations are used to illustrate and substantiate.
○ Data includes interviews, field notes, photographs, video footage, personal documents, etc.
(Features of Qualitative Research)
Concerned with process
Process is just as, or more, important than outcomes or products. ○ Attention to: ■ How meaning is derived ■ How labels come to be applied ■ How assumptions are made
(Features of Qualitative Research)
Inductive
○ Theories develop from bottom-up rather than top-down
○ The direction you will travel comes after you are been collecting data and spent time with the participants
○ “You are not putting together a puzzle whose picture you already know” - you are not coming with assumptions there may be surprises along the way.
○ Use parts of the study to learn what important questions are
(Features of Qualitative Research)
Meaningful
○ Participant perspectives are important - what they think about the world, not what you think
○ Accuracy of interpretations can be checked with the participants - you have to confront your assumptions, subjective of the research and they can help you understand better
○ Interplay or dialogue between researchers and participants
What are the Strengths of Qualitative Research?
● Research done in natural settings (usually/mostly)
○ Not only observe but also participate, engage with what you are researching, become part of it.
● Emphasis on informant interpretations and meanings
○ To really understand
● Seek understanding of informants world
○ Thick Description (Clifford Geertz)
● Humanizing research process by raising the role of the researched
● High level of flexibility in research process
○ Serendipity: when you are looking for something and you find something else
What are the Weaknesses of Qualitative Research?
● Problems of reliability - the difficulty of replicating findings
● “Subjectivity” of nature of data collection and analysis
● Risk of collecting meaningless and useless information from participants
● Problems of ethics: entering the personal world of the participant
○ Sensitive issues/breaking the rules, is it okay to document?
● Very time consuming
Name the FIVE historical moments:
- The traditional (1900-1950): associated with the positivist paradigm where qualitative research aims to reflect the principles of (natural) scientific enquiry.
- The modernist or golden age (1950-1970): where we see the appearance of post-positivist arguments. This is also part of
- The blurred genres (1970-1986): where a variety of new interpretive, qualitative perspectives come into the foreground: hermeneutics, structuralism, semiotics, phenomenology, cultural studies and feminism. The humanities also became a central resource for critical and interpretive theory. The blurred genres phase gave rise to
- The crisis of representation (1986-1990): where researchers struggled with how to locate themselves and their subjects in reflexive texts
- The postmodern or present (1990-today): a new sensibility that doubts all previous paradigms