Lecture 5, C 8,12,15 Flashcards
4 reasons why tasks are automated
- 3Ds: dull, dirty, dangerous
- multitasking, difficult or unpleasant tasks
- extention of human capability
- because technology makes it possible
4 stages/levels of automation
- information, acquisition, seleciton and filtering e.g. spelling checkers
- data integration
> pattern recognition, complex warning systems
- advisory systems
> collision avoidance systems
- control, execution of actions
> industrial robots
sheridan, 2002: what are the 8 levels of control
- human is in control
- system suggests different alternatives
- systems selects a single alternative
- system acts after approval of human
- systems provides limited time to stop action
- system acts and informs afterward
- system acts and informs when asked
- system is in control
4 causes of system unreliability
- errors e.g. because of complexity
- use outside of operating range
- wrong settings are entered
- logic of system is not understood by user
> (who thinks it malfunctions)
what is mostly the case for system unreliability?
the user-system combination is unreliable, or the system is imperfect, not unreliable
what are manifestations of mistrust in an automated system?
- high false alarm rate
- failure to understand limitations of system
what are consequences of mistrust in a system?
- slow, inefficient
- errors (because warnings are not taken seriously)
why is overtrust in a system problematic?
actual reliability is hard to judge when few errors occur
what are consequences of overtrust in an automated system?
can be serious
- slow detection of failures
- poor situation awareness because user is not actively involved
what is the problem of “clumsy automation”?
> it makes easy tasks easier and hard tasks harder
> reduces workload in already low-workload tasks
> increases workload in already high-workload tasks
how is level of automation related to situational awareness and workload?
when automation goes up, workload and situation awareness go down
why can sophisticated automation lead to errors?
> complex tasks appear to become easy, leading to less emphasis on training
> lack of trainings leads to not understanding the automation, resulting in error
>>> training should be adapted to level of automation
what is lost when automation is used instead of communication between humans?
> human to human communication contains nonverbal information channels that can be lost with automation
when is implementation of automated systems well received?
when not?
generally
> automation that improves safety and unburdens the operator is well received
> automation introduced merely because technology exists /increases efficiency may not be well received
>>> operators may be skilled and proud
designing automation, what are strong points of human vs strong points of systems
human strong points
- perceiving patterns
- detection in noise
- generalization
- improvisation
- inductive reasoning
system strong points
- working with details
- computation
- deductive reasoning
- repetetive work
- monitoring
- use large databases
6 characteristics of “human centered automation”
human centered automation
- keeping human informed
- keeping human trained
- keeping human in the loop
- selecting appropriate levels and stages when automation is imperfect
- using flexible/adaptive automation
- managing the introduction and use of autiomation
5 relevant influences on the difficulty and speed of response selection
- decision complexity
- expectancy
- compatibility
- speed-accuracy tradeoff
- feedback
speed of the response is influenced by what?
strongly influenced by the amount of possible alternatives that could be selected
>>> complexity of the decision