Lecture 4/5: Media effects Flashcards
What are the 3 dimensions of reputation?
being known
being known for something
generalized favourability
What are the consequences of positive corporate reputation?
Positive:
- Attracting customers
- Attracting employees
- Economic outcomes
- Mergers and acquisitions
- Strategic flexibility
- Benefit of the doubt when new negative
information comes to light
Negative:
- Burden of celebrity: stakeholders hold well-
known and well-liked firms to especially
intense scrutiny
Media reputation | Deephouse, 2000: Business performance is determined by the organization’s resources. In order to make a difference, resources need to be…
o be valuable
o be rare
o have low imitability
o be non-substitutable
Media reputation | Deephouse, 2000: Explain Rare resource
not every company has a good reputation
Media reputation | Deephouse, 2000: Explain Valuable resource
signal for exchange partners, making higher prices and lower costs possible
enhance efficiency or effectiveness
Media reputation | Deephouse, 2000: How are business performance and media reputation linked?
Business performance is determined by a company’s resources, e.g. skills, location, structure, culture, customer loyalty, knowledge, etc.
In order to make a difference, resources need to…
o be valuable: enhance efficiency or effectiveness
o be rare
o have low imitability
o be non-substitutable
Media reputation | Deephouse, 2000: Explain Low imitability resource
media reputation is difficult to imitate due to complex media dynamics
Media reputation | Deephouse, 2000: Explain Non-substitutable resource
it is difficult to find an alternative to media reputation (e.g. real contracts rather than a “psychological contract”)
Measuring reputation: How is reputation often measured?
Fortune’s survey of World’s Most Admired Corporations
What is the starting point of Fortune’s survey?
- reputation comes from interaction with and (specialized) information about the organization
- result of competence (+ noise)
What are the shortcommings of Fortune’s survey?
- High correlation with financial performance. Reputation based on that alone?
- Directors, etc, only
- USA only (until some time ago)
- Intended to sell magazines
Media reputation as alternative way: what is media reputation?
the overall evaluation of a firm presented in the media.
Media are selective and biased, but also a reflection of interest in, knowledge of and opinion on topics/actors by public
Media coverage based on many different sources
Media influence what audience think about, and sometimes how they think about something
Media reputation serves as signal for stakeholders
Media reputation | Deephouse, 2000: What was the research about?
Dependent variable: Relative return on average assets (ROA) for each bank year
- Return on assets
- Relative: compared to other banks
Independent variable: Media reputation in 2 newspapers
Media reputation | Deephouse, 2000: What are the results?
Media reputation predicts change in ROA
Media reputation was indeed a resource. Thus, media reputation may be useful in reputation research and the resource-based view of the firm
- Small but relevant effect
- Simple model, simple measurement of reputation -> too simple?
- Theory: concept difficult to fit into some facets of resource theory
- Time between measurement too long?
- Most posts discussed in discussion
Media reputation 2.0 | Etter et al. 2019: What is media reputation 1.0?
Media coverage of an organization as a proxy for an organization’s reputation
- Homogeneous
- Static
- Factual
- Influence by organization