Lecture 19 / 20 - CBT Flashcards
Why do different therapies often seem to have similar effectiveness? (2 points)
- Differences in effectiveness masked by poor research
2. Similar outcomes could be explained by common factors
Psychotherapy may be damaging as the …
Howarth, 1989
… variance in outcomes is greater in treated clients than in untreated control groups
(Howarth, 1989)
What are 4 reasons for the variance in therapy outcomes?
Lambert, 1992
40% client/extra-therapeutic factors
30% relationship factors
15% placebo hope and expectancy
15% model/technique factors
What 3 factors possessed by therapists positively correlate with patient’s improvement?
The therapist’s level of:
psychological health,
skill,
and interest in helping patients
According to the Department of Health, what is the minimum amount of sessions needed for optimum effectiveness?
8 (for most moderate to severe mental health problems)
The effects of CBT and other psychological treatments for adult depression might be overestimated due to …
… publication bias
2 Key Principles of CBT:
- Perception is not the same as reality
2. Events and situations can be interpreted in various ways
3 elements of the cognitive model
situation or event»_space;> thinking or interpretation»_space;> emotion
Thinking or interpretation in the cognitive model is influenced by…
… rules (I should, I must), assumptions, and beliefs
The 4 basic steps of CBT
- Education (learning about the cognitive approach and relevant aspects e.g. fight/flight response)
- Practicing ideas
- Application (using the ideas to tackle problems, then evaluating and modifying application)
- Monitoring (ensure old, unhelpful thinking and behaviour reoccur)
What are “unhelpful thinking styles”?
- Catastrophising (assuming the worst)
- Jumping to conclusions
- Personalisation (assuming you are directly responsible for a bad event)
- Overgeneralising (thinking a one off bad experience is the norm)
- Ignoring the positive
- All or nothing thinking (seeing either total success or total failure)
What are 9 characteristics of the cognitive approach?
- Collaborative
- Active
- Structured
- Joint responsibility
- Based on genuine, sincere, trusting relationship
- Based on clear model of distress
- Psycho-educational approach
- Client centred
- Experimental/scientific approach
According to cognitive theory, how does depression arise?
Early experience»_space; Formation of unhelpful assumptions and beliefs»_space; critical incident»_space; Assumptions activated»_space; Negative thoughts»_space;> Depression
6 criticisms of cognitive therapy
- Simplicity
- Positive thinking
- Only deals with the present
- Neglects transference
- Incompatible with pharmacotherapy
- Band-aid cure only
What are the assumptions underlying CBT?
- Assumes that an individual’s thoughts that lead to emotional experience
- Assumes that those thoughts can be accessed
- Assumes those thoughts can be challenged and changed
- Assumes a change in thinking will lead to change in emotional experience