Lecture 12 Flashcards
Mainstream psychology characterization
- Controlled experiments
- Statistics and measurement models
- Objectifying as much as possible
- Quantitative imperative: you cannot know what you cannot measure
Strengths of quantitative research
- Lends itself well for statistical analyses of large datasets
- Can produce precise predictions that can be tested
- Makes comparison easier
- Easier to investigate confounds and validity threats
Weaknesses of quantitative research
- Little interest in the perception of participants
- Research limited by what is measurable
- Better suited to testing general theories than to finding solutions for specific problems
- Not very suitable for generating theories
Positivism in Psychology
- Research focused on discovering reality and causal relationships
- Research is designed nomethetically, which is to say legislative. We search for general laws
- People are considered interchangeable
Thematic analysis
- Form of qualitative research
- Method for systematically identifying, organizing, and offering insight into patterns of meaning across a data set
Phases of TA (Thematic Analysis)
- Becoming familiar with the data
- Generating initial codes
- Searching for themes
- Reviewing themes (quality control)
- Defining and naming themes
- Writing the report
Grounded theory
Systematic analysis to build a theory about a specific problem. Researcher writes a problem analysis based on interviews.
This method is very inductive.
Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA)
Puts more emphasis on the experience of the people studied. Interpretative ability of the researcer acts as a measuring instrument.
Strengths of qualitative research
- Direct involvement in the situation
- Generates theories and enables exploration
- Responsive to the needs of participants
Weaknesses of qualitative research
- Less suitable for demonstrating general laws
- Little room for precise prediction/falsification
- Less suitable for deciding between theories
- Largely based on introspection and subjective evaluation
Qualitative research complementary to quantitative research
- Generating theories
- From general laws to applied cases
- Well suited for quickly mapping out complex situations
Maracek’s misconceptions about qualitative research
- Qualitative and quantitative research provide the same understanding of something
- Qualitative research is a first exploration
- Qualitatitve research is purely inductive
- Qualitative research is the same as quantitative but without numbers
Criteria for quantitative psychology
- Validity
- Reliability
- Replicability
- Transparency
- Generalizability
- Objectivity
Criteria for Qualitative psychology
- Rigour
- Sensitivity to context
- Coherence
- Commitment
- Impact and importance
- Reflexivity
Hermeneutics
Theory and practice of interpretation which involves understanding that can be justified.