Law, Freedom, and Moral Acts Flashcards
why is quarreling specifically a human quality
because it means trying to prove that someone else is wrong. This means that we have an agreed upon sense of right and wrong, and a standard of behavior which we hold each other to.
What is quarreling trying to do
prove the other wrong, expect other to know standard of right and wrong
what is the law of human nature
the law of right and wrong
what is the difference between the law of nature for people and things
things cannot choose to obey laws, they just do. It is a description of how they always behave. For humans we have a choice and it describes what we should do, but do not always do.
why does lewis say we are forced to believe in real right and wrong
because we all adhere to it and have throughout history.
how does lewis say our use of excuses show that all men believe in the law of nature
we know that we have fallen short of the understood standard of behavior and we want to shift the blame. There would be no point in shifting the blame if we did not feel guilty.
what are the two points he wants to make in this chapter
humans believe they should behave in a certain way and cannot get rid of this belief, yet they do not behave in this way. They know the law and break it.
why cant we say that following moral law is useful to us
a war prisoner can be useful to us, but being a nazi is very bad. Cheating can be useful, but it is not morally correct. Good behvior like telling the truth is not always convinient or helpful. If this was man made we would make it useful and convinient.
ESSAY QUESTION
How is Lewis able to conclude that the law of nature is not manmade
- we feel natural law pressing in on us by quarelling (trying to show other is in the wrong, and expecting other to know right and wrong and follow a standard of behavior) and making excuses (we know that we have fallen short of standard and are trying to shift the blame)
- it is not a matter of taste or preference it is universal (applies to all people at all times. There has never been a society that praises selfishness)
- it is not useful or convinient (many times bad behavior is useful and good behavior is not)
natural law does not come from man, it is written on his heart urging him to do good and avoid evil. This proves the existence of a law which implies the existence of a
law giver/maker
The law helps bring us to our ultimate end in heaven, meaning that it does not keep us from happiness but
brings happiness
what is law
An obligatory, resonable, and useful rule given to benefit the community (lead them towards God) which is made known to the people by someone with legitiment authority over them.
Eternal law
plan of divine wisdom directing all acts and movements
cosmos means -, while chaos means
order, confusion
properties of eternal law
primordial and universal
primordial
foundational, the starting point for all laws
universal
applies to every creature
natural law
rational creature’s participation in eternal law; written on the heart of every human being
natural law states that we can understand right and wrong through
reason
natural law recognizes order both
within the universe and within the individual
natural law properties
immutable, universal
immutible
unchanging
laws of nature
descriptions of behavior of the material universe; describes how things work
since man has -, he can chose to follow natural law or reject it
free will
positive law
a law which has been formally laid down or imposed; made known to us by external sign
divine positive law
legistlated by god (decaloug or 10 commandments)
ecclesiastical law
legistlated by church
what is a positivist
someone who claims we must just follow written law without thinking abt if it is unjust
civil positive law
legistlated by the government
evangelical law
from the gospel, to shape your life according to christ, beautittudes and sacraments
human laws should correspond to
god’s will
moral good and evil procede from the
nature of things; things are not good or evil because you want them to be or anyone says they are
foundation of good and evil is
truth
just laws correspond to
natural law
because just laws correspond to natural law, they have the power to bind us in conciounse making disobeying them
a sin
laws which do not correspond to natural law are
unresonable, unjust, and need not be obeyed