Law & Ethics Flashcards
Trade Area: Two Calculations
What are they? Which is best?
Drive time and Radius Ring.
Drive time is best.
Bailment - what is the definition?
Who is the bailor and bailee with a DVM and Client Owner?
Bailment is delivery of something personal to be held according to purpose and then returned.
Client is Bailor, DVM is Bailee
What 2 elements are essential for the creation of Bailment?
What is primary duty of Bailee?
Can Bailment be oral vs written?
1) physical property delivery from Bailor to Bailee
2) there must be knowing acceptance of possession of property by Bailee
To return animal as received
Yes it can be oral vs written
The law of negligence requires proof of four essential elements, what are they?
- Establish duty to prevent an injury/duty of care
- Establish that duty was violated by failing to act in accordance with the standard of care of other DVMs in similar circumstances
- Show a reasonable close causation connection (proximate cause)
- Prove actual harm or damage occurred
Privacy Act of 1974
Requires a written consent from client to release medical records
When a veterinarian accepts custody of a client’s pet; which party is the Bailor and which is the Bailee?
What 2 elements are essential for the creation of a bailment?
What is the primary duty of the Bailee in our veterinary example?
Can a bailment be oral as opposed to written?
Client is Bailor, Hospital Bailee
- Property Transfer 2. Knowledge of transfer
To return it in as good of condition as received
Yes can be oral
The law of negligence requires proof of four essential elements, what are they?
1 – Establishing that the defendant had a duty to prevent an injury from occurring to the plaintiff or the plaintiff’s property.
2 - Establishing that the defendant violated that duty by failing to act in accordance with the standard of care expected of other DVMs under the same or similar circumstances.
3 – Showing that a reasonably close causal connection existed between the defendant’s DVMs conduct or lack of conduct and the resulting injury (doctrine of proximate cause).
4 – Proving that the actual damage or harm occurred to the interests of another person.
The Sherman Antitrust Act was enacted in 1890 and the goal of the act is to guarantee the freedom to compete.
Who is responsible for the interpretation and application of the competitive objectives of the anti-trust laws?
What 3 things must you prove?
The courts, the Department of Justice, and the Federal Trade Commission.
Proof of contract to do or not do an act that will restrain interstate commerce and there is proof of intent.
There are two rules the courts will use when making a ruling regarding Antitrust Laws, what are they?
A - The Per Se Rule and the Rule of Reason.
Rule of Reason: courts evaluate the legality of a restraint and consider a variety of market factors. It can unreasonably restrain trade.
Per Se Rule: illegality is limited to those practices that lack any redeeming virtue and have no purpose but to stifle competition.
Veterinary Medical Records are governed by which bodies and are kept for how long?
Mandated by Veterinary Practice Act of each state.
AVMA Principles of Veterinary Medical Ethics spells out minimum requirement.
AAHA hospitals have to abide by their guidelines as well.
Kept for 3-5 years depending on state.
Define At Will Employment
Form of employment in which the employee is serving the employer at the will of both parties. Employer can terminate employees with or without cause.
Define the ideal witness to a termination
- Same Gender
- Supervisory role
- Not direct peer
What are 8 Express Exceptions to At-Will Employment:
- Collective Bargaining Agreements
- Specific contracts that indicate a time period for employment
- Dismissals based on race, sex, color, gender, by Civil Rights Act
- Dismissals based on age if over 40 (ADEA)
- Dismissals based on pregnancy
- Dismissals based on employees not wanting to work in a hazardous environment (OSHA)
- Dismissals if employee files bankruptcy
- Dismissals if employee served on federal jury.
Confidentiality of patient records must be kept unless one of these 7 situations arises:
- The client or client’s agent agrees
- The law requires disclosure
- The animal’s health is at stake
- Negligence is a concern
- Subpeona or court order
- There is a state board issue
- Legal dispute
Who can employees discuss patient information with?
- Client
- Veterinarian
- Other employees treating the case
- The client’s agent
When a court considers the reasonableness of a non-compete, they assess what five items:
- Relationship between employer and employee
- Scope of activity restricted
- Time limitation
- Geographic constraints
- Adequacy of consideration
Veterinarians working at more than one location must do what when it comes to prescribing/administering/dispensing controlled substances? (2 things)
- They can prescribe controlled drugs if they are registered at some principal place of business
- They can administer/dispense but they have to be classified as a any employee of a registrant or they must register at each facility where they are employed.
What are the 4 provisions of administering controlled substances by non-veterinary staff? What can they never do legally?
They can never legally prescribe ANY medication under state practice act laws.
They can administer if:
1. If they are agents or employees of the registrant.
2. They are acting in the normal course of business
3. They are acting under the direction of a licensed veterinarian
4. They are under the direct supervision of a licensed veterinarian.
Completing DEA 222 Forms
Copies 1 and 2 are submitted to the supplier.
Copy 3 is retained by registrant.
The supplier keeps copy 1 and sends copy 2 to the DEA.
When the shipment arrives, the date of receipt, the number of containers of each drug should be documented on Copy 3 of the original order form that was retained.
Record Keeping of Controlled Substances (3 things).
Have to have a record of all transactions.
Schedule 2 must be stored away from medical record.
Schedule 3-5 can be stored in medical record but has to be readily retrievable thus it is not recommended and should be stored separate with Schedule 2.
Lending Controlled Substances to other DVMS. What is the process for Schedule 3-5 and Schedule 2?
Schedule 3-5:
- Transfer the quantity of drug to another registration and obtain a receipt signed by the DVM who received the drug. Store the invoice in the record keeping system.
- the receiving DVM should keep copies of receipts showing the drug was received from another DVM instead of supplier.
- Drugs can be returned to the DVM from whom they were borrowed, using the same method.
Schedule 2: Same as DEA-222 form, but the supplying DVM keeps Copy 1, sends copy 2 to DEA, and Copy 3 goes to DVM receiving the drugs.
Explain transferring of drugs when a DVM acquires a new practice: (5 steps)
- An initial inventory must be taken
- The DVM transferring the drugs should prepare an invoice of all the drugs and it should be date and signed by BOTH giver and receiver.
- The paperwork should say if inventory was taken at beginning or end of day.
- Schedule 2 has to be hard count
- Schedule 3-5 can be estimated unless it is over 1000ct bottle. These records must be maintained with all the receipts from distributors.
After the initial inventory is taken, how long until the next inventory and how long do records have to be retained for?
Bi-annual inventories, and records maintained for 2 years.
Storing Controlled Drugs - 4 Thoughts
- Must be stored in securely locked substantially constructed cabinet or safe
- Drug stocks should be at a minimum
- Access to storage area should be restricted to a minimum
- Schedule 3-5 can be stored with non controlled drugs but has to be in substantial container