Knowledge Circulations Flashcards
What are the functions of money for economic research?
- Circulates as a valuable commodity and makes it possible for other commodities to circulate
- Conveys knowledge about economies –> abstract accounting unit for comparison
- Performs culturally/symbolically –> exclusion, inclusion, resistance…
What are the classic functions of money in modern capitalism?
- Medium of exchange: ‘universal commodity’
- Store of value: holds value over time
- Unit of account: represent and measure prices of many different items
How is money a geographical phenomenon?
- Challenge social theorists that modern money forms are disembedded from place
- “Money is itself a geography” – money as a circulation is always on the move but also rooted in specific places; new geography of money via dematerialisation and trans-national circulation
Gilbert and Helleiner (1999)
How is money a political phenomenon?
- Money as an instrument of power
- States relation to national currencies
- Alternative currency arrangements for power and legitimacy for statements
What are money’s multiple origin points?
- Territorial state-backed currencies
- Minted under state supervision
- Bitcoin circumvent this as an individual can produce money
- Cosmopolitan ‘credit monies’
- Bank checking accounts
- Financial derivatives
- More recently: cryptocurrencies
Why is there a discomfort with paper and digital currencies ?
- Now floating
- Not backed by gold
How is bitcoin reliant on energy?
- Consumption of energy for bitcoin mining
- Reliance on the state
- Every individual Bitcoin transaction eats up 275kWh of electricity
How does money’s functions work in contradictory ways in modern capitalism?
- Act as a medium of exchange while remaining a store of value
- Challenge for capitalist states
- Problem of inflation: currency loses value, anyone holding it has lost purchasing power
What are special monies?
- Value of money decided in social relations they are used for
- Domestic money set apart from real money by ideas of family life
- Shaped by gender, class and age
- Distinct from rules of the market
- Domestic money remains hidden in dominant economic paradigm of rationalizing market money
Zelizer (1989)
How does special monies challenge neoclassical economic theory?
- Develop sociological model of multiple monies as a challenge to neoclassic economic theory
- Not only to study of money but other aspects of economic life, including the market
Zeilzer (1989)
How does money permit the separation of sales and purchases of other commodities in space and time?
- As seller of one commodity under no obligation to buy another (Harvey, 1982)
- Money enables the veiling of a commodity’s social and spatial background
What is Mann’s (2008) idea about money in relation to capitalism?
The stitch of capitalism’s space-time
What are the cases for following the money?
- God of commodities
- Culmination of fetishisms
- Embeddedness in the social
- Financialisation
Christophers (2011)
What is the god of commodities case for following the money?
- Marx regards money as “the commodity par excellence”
- Money is both universal medium of exchange and universal measure of value
- Commodity circulation in capitalist economy depends on exchange of money
Christophers (2011)
What is the culmination of fetishisms case for following the money?
- Money form conceals our social relations with others but also social meaning of value itself
- Money as the indispensible ingredient in commodity fetishism under capitalism
Christophers (2011)
What is the embededness in the social case for following the money?
- Creation and circulation of money, e.g. traditional forms of money
- Modern monies are not empty or abstract but are dependent on re-embedding in social relations
Christophers (2011)