Kimihia Flashcards
J
what’s evidential material
evidence of the offence or other item, tangible or intangible, relevant to the investigation
Reasonable grounds to believe RGB
believe a situation or circumstance exists
e.g. RGB the search will locate evidential material relating to that offence.
Reasonable grounds to suspect
basis for suspecting a situation or circumstance is likely to exist, e.g. RGS an offence has been committed
Unlawfully at large
Person who
W2A / UAL CorP Act / Prsn Bkr / ELCstdy /
SpRsP Es, Fld RL / CR, SC-ID Es FRexL /
YP odr OT Act AC of CE
- wrnt 2 arest is n force
- unlwfuly at large re Corrections or Parole Act
- a prison breaker
- escapee, lawful custody
- special /restricted patient - escaped / failed to
return from leave - care recipient, special care re Intellectual Disability
who escaped - failed to return on expiry of leave - a young person subject to an order made
under OT Act & is absconding custody of CE
Lawfulness and reasonableness
All searches must be lawful and reasonable
Search hierarchy
always obtain a search warrant
If not practicable, use a warrantless search power.
if you want 2 search place, vehicle, other thing, a warrantless search power exists, use that power instead of asking for consent to conduct the search under sections 91 to 96 of the Act.
Decision records
You must record RGS and/or RGB known at time a warrantless power was used. You may need to rely on this record in court
Identification and notice
The owner / occupier / person in charge of place / vehicle / thing being searched has right to know who’s searching, authority to search & reasons 4 search, unless good reasons 4 not providing this info
Force used against property must be reasonable
Any force of entry to any place / vehicle / other thing re carrying out search be reasonable in the circs. (s131(3))
Search or seizure should be witnessed
Police employee, EO from other agency / person assisting with the search be the witness (if practicable)
for any search of place / vehicle / other thing, or removal / seizure of property in the search,
Seized property must be documented
All property removed or seized from a place / vehicle / other thing must be documented and accounted for appropriately.
Lawfulness and reasonableness of searches
Lawful search must:
· exercise a warrantless power, or
· execute a warrant power, or
· conduct search / examination / inspection with the person’s consent.
Use statutory power or rely on consent
use statutory power to search, not rely on a consensual search, as consent may be withdrawn at any time
Inevitable discovery
See R v Williams [2007] 3NLR 207
If Ev obtained thru breach of the NZBORA 1990, wudve been obtained even if breach hadn’t occurred, the fact it wudh’v been discovered shud be taken into account to determin whether it’s admissible under the balancing test in section 30 of the Evidence Act 2006.
The evidence will not be admissible as a matter of course.
Search hierarchy
If you search, or seize evidence w/out a warrant where you had the opportunity to obtain a warrant, any subsequent court proceedings may deem
the search unreasonable, any Ev material obtained as a result of the search or seizure may be deemed inadmissible.
You may also lose any evidence you discover about any other offence.
Ensuring searches are reasonable
Ensure also that the search is reasonable under section 21 of the Bill of Rights Act 1990.
R v Jefries
Lawfulness is not inevitably determinative of reasonableness, or unlawfulness of unreasonableness
If the search is unlawful because it was conducted without a warrant, then it is very likely to be unreasonable as well.
R v Jefferies
“Lawfulness is not inevitably determinative
of reasonableness, or unlawfulness of unreasonableness”.
If particular evidence would still have been discovered if the unlawful search had not been conducted, then the evidence may still be deemed admissible.
RGS a person is unlawfully at large, and believe the person is in a place or vehicle
you may…
enter the place or vehicle without warrant to search for and arrest the person. (s7)
Entry to avoid loss of offender or evidential material
If you have RGS.. a person has committed an offence punishable by imprisonment and for which they may be arrested without warrant, and
· believe that the person is in a place or vehicle, and
· believe that if entry is not effected immediately,
- the person will leave the place/r vehicle to avoid arrest
- evidential material relating to the offence will be destroyed, concealed, altered or damaged
you may…
enter that place / vehicle without warrant, and
· search for and arrest the person you suspect has committed the offence.
Note: You may not search for evidential material unless an arrest is made and a search incidental to that arrest is undertaken under sections 83-88. (s8)
Entry to prevent offence or respond to risk to life or safety
If you have RGS, in relation to a place or vehicle:
· an offence is being, or is about to be committed, that would be likely to cause injury to any person, or serious
loss of or serious damage to any property, or
· there is risk to the life or safety of any person that requires an emergency response
you may…
enter the place or vehicle without a warrant, and take any action you have RGB is necessary to:
- prevent the offending from being committed or
continuing, or
- avert the emergency.
Note: ‘Take any action’ means any action that is reasonable in the circumstances. (s14)
s15
you may…
enter and search the place with/without warrant.
avoid CADD of evidential material.
RGTS 14+ offence.
RGTB evidential material will be CADD without immediate entry.
CADD-concealed, altered, damaged, destroyed
What’s the key to s15 re urgency
Once that urgency has passed & scene is secure (assuming it is not a simple case of seizing an exhibit with no further interest in the scene) a warrant should be obtained. The timing will depend on the circumstances.
What’s the warrant preference rule
The ablty 2 scure a srch scne wen an aplic8n 2 a wrnt s pndg strnthns the ‘warrant preference rule’.
Unless urgency 2 conduct srch or a cncrn the securing of scene my nt b sfcient 2 prsrv evdntial mtrial, it may be aprpri8 2 hve 2 resrt 2 s117 rthr thn xrcse a wrntls pwr.
s16
Search person in public place 4 evidential material for 14+ offence.
RGTB person has evidential material.
My srch w/out wrnt