Kaplan Evidence Foundation Slides Flashcards
Presentation of Evidence - Coverage Areas
Presentation of Evidence
- Preliminary Questions of Admissibility
- First Hand Knowledge
- Burdens of Persuasion and Presumption
- Habit Evidence
- Subsequent Remedial Measures
- Settlement Offers
- Offers to Pay Medical Expenses
Approach to Evidence Questions
- Underline the Cause of Action
- Civil or Criminal
- Situate the Proceeding
- Direct or Redirect
- Party or Witness
- Purpose for Evidence
- Substantive use
- Impeachment use
Relevant Evidence is
Relevant Evidence is evidence having any tendency to make the existence of any fact that is of consequence to the determination of the action more or less probable than it would be without the evidence
Admissions are
- Statement of a party
- Oral or Written Assertion / Conduct
- Used against them by their opponent
- Can be anything (words, letters, documents)
FRE 1002: Best Evidence Rule is
- To prove the contents of a writing (recording, photograph, X ray) the original must be produced unless shown to be available
- Rule applies where contents are in issue: i.e., where the testimony is reliant on the writing, not on personal knowledge
- The person testifying has personal knowledge ONLY because of the original writing
Preliminary Questions of Admissibility include
Questions concerning qualification of a person to be a witness (FRE 601, 602, 603, 401), existence of a privilege, or admissibility of evidence shall be determined by the court
Burdens in a Civil Action
- Burden of proof on the Plaintiff
- Burden of persuasion - preponderance of the Evidence
Burdens in a Criminal Action
- Burden of proof on Prosecution
- Burden of persuasion - beyond a reasonable doubt of every element
Habit Evidence
Habit Evidence is evidence of the habit of a person, or the routine practice of an organization is admissible to prove conduct.
Corroboration is not required
Subsequent Remedial Measures
Evidence of subsequent remedial measures is inadmissible to prove negligence
Subsequent Remedial Measures, Exceptions are:
Is evidence to prove (1) Ownership, (2) Control
Settlement offers that are not admissible are
Offers to settle claims in “dispute” are inadmissible. Admission are NOT severed and are inadmissible
Offers to Pay Medical Expenses
Offers to pay medical expenses of another are inadmissible. Admission ARE severable and admissible
Checkpoint Items for Character Evidence
- Character is tricky, watch for state distinctions as trap answers as they are generally opposite rules
- Impeachment is a good answer when someone does not come in substantively for its truth
- Have to follow and approach,
- where are you in the case
- what kind of case is it
- purpose of the evidence
Character Evidence in Criminal Cases- Character of Defendant
Defendant may open the door with “reputation or opinion” evidence (not specific acts) of his good character to prove his innocence and the prosecution may so rebut
Character Evidence in Criminal Cases- Character of Victim
Where evidence of a pertinent trait of character of the alleged victim is offered by the accused, the prosecution may rebut the same way
Character Approach in Criminal Cases
Door opened? Trait? Reputation / Opinion
4 Ways to Impeach
- Bias / Prejudice; Prior Inconsistent Statement; Sensory Defects; Character to Impeach