Judiciary Flashcards
What kind of court is the SCOTUS?
Appellate Court
What is their constitutional role?
Settle conflicts between states
When was Marbury v Madison?
1803
What did Marbury v Madison establish?
Judicial Review
Does the SCOTUS have power?
Not really - they can stop other people doing stuff but not to push forward their own agenda
What is the first step in the appointments process?
A vacancy must arise - only when someone dies, retires or is impeached
Who draws up the recruitment pool?
President’s team draws up a list of possible nominees
What factors must be considered?
Judicial experience, legal knowledge, professional standing and reputation, personal history and integrity
What do they look at if the nominee is a judge?
Look at rulings on previous cases to see how they vote in the future
What is a president’s aim?
Appoint judges who will share their vie of how the Constitution should be interpreted
Who does the background check on the candidates?
WH lawyers and FBI - find things against them
What happened to Justice Kennedy?
Interviewed for 10 hours by the FBI on a range of topics
Who interviews the final candidates?
The President
What happens after the presidential nomination is announced?
Media Scrutiny - sometimes uncovers issues that spark controversy
Who had to be withdrawn for smoking weed as a professor?
Douglas Ginsburg in 1987
What does the Senate Judiciary committee do?
Considers the nominee - questionnaire needs to be completed.
How many of the justices in 2021 sat on the CoA?
8/9
Who had never been a judge and was previously a solicitor general?
Elena Kagan
What helps the committee to assess the suitability of candidates?
Witnesses
Where are nominees interviewed?
On a televised interview
What tends to suggest how easy it is going to be to pass the nominee?
The Committee Vote
What was RBG’s committee vote?
Unanimous yes - passed by 96-3 senators
What was Clarence Thomas’ committee vote?
Partisan divide - approved by 52-48 in the Senate
How much did a nominee need from the Senate?
60/100 - allowed senators to filibuster a nomination
When did the rule change?
2013 - Dem changed the cloture rules for nominations to the exec branch and the federal judiciary but not the SCOTUS
What was the nuclear option?
Allowed cloture to be invoked by a simple majority
When was the nuclear option extended to the SCOTUS?
2017 - stop the Dems from filibustering Gorsuch - result of partisanship
Who didn’t receive a single minority party vote?
Amy Coney Barrett
When was the last defeat?
1987 - Robert Bork
When was the last time a nominee was withdrawn?
2005 - Harriet Miers - ABA rating as unqualified
Who is the only SC to be appointed with a below well qualified rating?
Clarence Thomas
How long is the longest term for a SCOTUS justice?
36 years
How long has Thomas been on the bench?
31 years
Who was blocked from having a hearing in 2016?
Merrick Garland
Who became a more liberal judge?
John Paul Stevens
Who became more liberal and worked as a swing vote?
Roberts - Moore v Texas 2017
What was Roberts’ appointment like?
Bush - 2005 - 13-5 in Committee, 78-22 in Senate
What was Thomas’ appointment like?
Bush - 1991 - 13-1 in Committee - 52-48 in Senate
What was Alito’s appointment like?
Bush - 2006 - 10-8 in Committee - 58-42 in Senate
What was Sotomayor’s appointment like?
Obama - 2009 - Senate 67-29
What was Kagan’s appointment like?
Obama - 2010 - Committee = 13-6, 63-37 in the Senate
What was Gorsuch’s appointment like?
Trump, 2017, 11-9 Committee, 54-45 in Senate
What was Kavanaugh’s appointment like?
Trump, 2018, Committee = 11-10 - 54-50 Senate
What was Coney Barrett’s appointment like?
Trump, 2020 - Committee - 12-0 - all Dems boycott - 52-48 Senate
What was Brown Jackson’s appointment like?
Biden - 2022 - Committee = 11-11 - 53-47 Senate
What do strict constructionists believe?
Should be read literally and narrowly - judges would twist actual meaning to support own views - as the FFI.
What do originalists believe?
Should be interpreted based on its original meaning - Antonio Scalia - restraint - accept precedents.
Who do loose constructionists believe?
Meaning should evolve to reflect changes in society, reflect modern standards - RBG - legislating from the bench = criticism. Activism
Who is a textualist?
Clarence Thomas
What act was passed in 1933?
National Industry Recovery Act
What did the National Industry Recovery Act do?
National Recovery Administration to set new regulations and codes established. Minimum wage, prices, working standards
What was Schechter Poultry Corp v US?
SCOTUS rules act exceeded powers under commerce clause - wages and standards did not count as commerce despite being tied to it.