Judges Advantages

Question 1

P- better selection procedure

Answer 1

DP- judges were previously sleceted by secret soundings. Little opportunity to become a judge

WDP- applications now made to the Judicial Appointments Commission (JAC). Increases diversity within judiciary. Makes selcetion fairer+more transparent

Question 2

P- Increased diversity

Answer 2

DP- little gender bias
1990s = 0 women COA, 2016= 8
1990s = 3 women HC, 2016= 23

WDP-
1990s = 5% CJ and Recorders
2016 = 25% CJ, 17% Recorders

Question 3

P - Training

Answer 3

DP- undergo training, understand law, practice and procedures. Increases trial efficiency.

WDP- better suited to role than lay magistrates (rely on clerk for knowledge)

Question 4

P- Educated to a high level

Answer 4

DP- have extensive knowledge within the law, have previously been a barrister/solicitor for several years. Dealt with complex law

WDP- Penny Darbyshire = concern if not educated to a high level. Results in correct and fairer trials