Is the deal enforceable by courts? Flashcards
Consideration
Bargained-for legal value
What is consideration in bilateral contract?
Promise for promise
What is consideration in unilateral contract?
Promise for act or forbearance
What are four types of invalid consideration?
- Nominal consideration
- Past consideration
- Illusory promise
- Pre-existing legal duty
What are two types of nominal consideration?
- Gift promise
2. Conditional gift
Material benefit rule
Promise made in recognition of benefit previous received is binding to extent necessary to prevent injustice unless
- Promisor had not been unjustly enriched/conferred benefit as a gift OR
- Promise’s value is disproportionate to its benefits
Illusory promise
Promise that by its terms makes performance entirely optional for the promisor
Pre-existing legal duty
Modified contract with no new consideration
When is pre-existing legal duty not invalid consideration?
- New or different consideration
- Honest dispute over what consideration actually was
- Unforeseen circumstances
When is charitable subscription valid consideration?
Binding with proof that promisee induced action or forbearance
When is marriage settlement valid consideration?
Binding with proof that promisee induced action or forbearance
When is loan commitment (lend money/extend credit) valid consideration (binding)?
If promise is in writing or signed by lender
Under UCC, when is unspecified buyer’s requirements/seller’s output binding?
Actual output/requirement as may occur in good faith
UNLESS quantity is unreasonably disproportionate to
1. Any stated estimate
2. If no stated estimate, any normal or comparable prior output
Under UCC, when is unspecified buyer’s requirement/seller’s output not binding?
Quantity is unreasonably disproportionate to
- Any stated estimate or
- If no stated estimate, any normal or comparable prior output
Is inadequate consideration invalid?
No, courts cannot consider inadequacy
When is exclusive agency valid consideration?
Valid in good faith with best efforts
When is promissory estoppel a valid substitute for consideration?
- Promise that promisor should reasonably expect to induce action or forbearance on part of promisee and
- Which does induce such action or forbearance
- Is binding if injustice can only be avoided by enforcement of promise
Promissory estoppel
- Promise that promisor should reasonably expect to induce action or forbearance on part of the promisee and
- Which does induce such action or forbearance
- Is binding if injustice can only be avoided by enforcement of promise
When is promise for past material benefit a valid consideration substitute?
Promise to repay past material benefit is binding unless
- Promisee conferred benefit as gift or promisor has not been unjustly enriched or
- To the extent that its value is disproportionate to the benefit
What are the defenses against enforcing a contract?
- Statute of frauds
- Mistake/misunderstanding
- Fraud
- Duress
- Undue Influence
- Unconscionability
- Incapacity
- Illegality
Statute of frauds acronym
MYLEGS
How is the statute of frauds satisfied?
- Contract is in writing
- With signature of charged party and
- Including subject matter and
- Material terms of the contract
What is subject to statute of frauds?
- Marriage as consideration
- Year-long+ (cannot be performed in one year)
- Land
- Executor/administrator
- Goods of 500+
- Suretyship
Marriage as consideration
Promise for which all or part of consideration is marriage or promise to marry
Exception to SOF for marriage as consideration
Agreement which consists only of mutual promises of two people to marry each other
Exceptions to SOF for year-long+
- Lifetime commitments
2. Tasks that do not note specific-years+ dates
Exception to SOF for land
Short-term leases
Exception to SOF for goods of $500+
- Omitted/incorrectly stated term
2. Seller’s output/buyer’s requirement
When a term is ommitted/incorrectly stated, to what extent is it enforced?
Not beyond quantity shown in writing
Suretyship
Promise of credit to answer for debt of another
Exception to SOF for suretyship
Primary purpose of promise was to benefit surety
What are exceptions to SOF?
- Merchant’s exception
- Admission
- Performance
- Promissory estoppel
Merchant’s exception
- Both parties are merchants
- Buyer sends confirmation of sale
- Seller receives memo
- Seller has reason to know its contents
- Seller doesn’t respond in 10 days
Admission (exception to SOF)
Charged party admits in court that contract was made
To what extent is admission enforceable?
Not beyond quantity of goods admitted
Under common law, when is performance an exception to SOF? (2 elements)
Contract for transfer of land is enforceable if:
- Buyer makes full payment and either
a. Takes possession of land or
b. Makes substantial improvement theron