IR MIDTERM 2 Flashcards
Feminist Critique
What is the Liberal Stance on The Sexual Economy of US military bases?
The Sexual Economy of US military bases
* Prosititution arranged informally by US military commander, local government officials, and “businessmen” (foten with organized crime connections) around US military bases. Ignored as an issue until the 1930s.
“Comfort Women” –Sexual Slavery and the Imperial Japanese Army during WWII –long neglected in Korea until the 1990s
* Beginning in 1990s uncovering of the issue, taking to the victims/survivors and confronting the issue of sexual violence
* Role of Civil Society Activists raising awareness of the issue
–>Raise awareness and activate change
Highlighting Sexual Violence in War– The International Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia
* During teh Bosnian War Serb leader– Radko Lladic and Radovan Karadzic– allowed systematic rape to intimidate the Bosniak and Croat populations
* Charged for the first time after the war in the 2000s –Karadzic faces charges in the Hague, Netherlands
What is the Radical Feminist Theory of IR
-J. Anne Ticknor (and Haywood Alker)
-The very language of IR is gendered
-Supports a particular view of politics based on an understanding of traditional gender roles
Retelling IR through Constrictivist Lenses
Retelling IR through Constructivist Lenses:
-After 1648 the unifying force of Christendom collapsed in Europe
-The Sovereign State acting on the basis of state interest takes over
-Hyper Realist view of international relations
18th-19th century transformation
- Nationalism gradually displaces the aristocratic order
- National interest– the interest of the people– becomes central
- Reflects the class, race, and gendered understandings of European states at the time
- Promote an IR liberal view of international relations
Liberalism challenged by alternate visions of social solidarity- Marxism & Fascism
Glorification of the state and the nation
-Visions of Mussolini, mobilized ppl
Socialist Class Solidarity and Mass Line
-Focused upon class
International Security
What is it that we want to defend? What is the Federent Object of Security?
- State interest
- The absence of threat?
- Human lives in general?
- Fundamental value?
International Security
What is the classical definition of International Security?
(More realist view)
* Historically– the interest of the Ruler
-Niccolo Machiavelli
* In modern times– the states as an institution which exercises control over a particular territory
* Struggle against other rulers and states
International Security
The absence of threats in the International System
- Liberals believe that security is a collective good (Collective Security)
- The idea behind the League of Nations
- Multilateral Security institutions buttressed by interdependence dampens the threat of violence
- Preserving that system is vital to achieving security
International Security
What is Human Security?
- Many liberals and Constructivists (thick and thin) argue for a broader definition–Protecting human lives
- This includes defining a broader range of threats
International Security
Many possible threats beyond the classical threat of interstate conflict
- Environmental
- Economic (development and protection from poverty)
- Food (protection from hunger)
- Personal security (protection of human rights from state and non-state violence)
Securitization
What is Securitization?
Secutitization=The creation of security sssues
Three types:
-Non-politicized
-Politicized
-Securitized
Securitization
What is Non-Politicized?
- The state does not recognize the issue
- The issue is not included in the public debate
Securitization
What is Politicized?
- The issue is managed with the standard political system
- It is “part” of public policy. Requiring governmental decision and resource allocations or more rarely, some form of communal governance.
Securitization
What is Securitized?
- The issue is framed as a security question through an act of securitization
- A securitizing actor articulates an already politicized issue as an existential threat to a referent object
Securitization
Example: Environmental Security
- Global population has been growing for centuries
- Concern over its implication dates back to the early 19th century
-Thomas Robert Malthus - Population Growth leads to increased demand for scarce resources
- Knock on effects of economic development
-Evidence has accumulated for over 100 years of rising warming
-Growing frequency of potentially climate related disasters:
–Bangladesh Cyclone
–Desertification Eastern Africa
–Indian Ocean Tsunami
–Pakistan Flood - Politicization: Since 1970s growing environmental movement
-Attention towards climate change
-Environmental movements
-Green parties (gov parties growing over Europe) - Articulating the issue as a security issue
Dixon - Prof at University of Toronto
Securitization
Example: Migration as a Security Threat
- International migration has been increasing over the past half century
- Approximately 10% of OECD countries now foreign born
Series of high-profile migration crisis - Creates a range of security related fears
-Threat to jobs
-Crime
-Terrorism
-Values - Politicizing the issue from the Right
-Current debates on immingration - Getting Political Representation
-Political Party rises
-Ex: Italy– next prime minister against immingration
Defining War
- “Open and declared armed hostile conflict between states or nations”
- “Any Conflict between rival groups by force of arms or other means,… recognized as a legal conflict” (Preston and Wise)
- “An act of force to compel the enemy to do our will” (Clausewitz)
Defining War
Capturing the Essence of Warefare
- Carl von Clausewitz (1790-1831)
-At 13 joined in the first war against France (1792-1797)
-1806- Captured a Jena when Napoleon Conquered Prussia
-Joined the Russian army and fought against Napoleon at Borodino - Fought in the Napoleonic wars, later a military educator
- Author of “On War” (Vom Kriege)
- “War is the extension of politics by other means”
Defining War
The Towering Figure of the Time- Napoleon Bonaparte
- The “God of War”
- Victorious on the battlefield
- Conquered most of Europe
- An era of mass mobilization– La Grande Armee reached 400,000
- Completely failed strategically
- Napoleon crowns himself Emperor
- An Era of “Total War” and mass mobilization
Nationalism
Defining War
Lesson 1: The Passions of total war must be tamed
- War is continuation of politics by other means
- Never lose sight of the larger objective – war cannot be its own end
Defining War
Lesson 2: The Fog of War
- War is inherently full of confusion and error – “friction”
- Every plan falls apart with the first contact with the enemy
- Careful preparation, training and flexibility is key to military success
Defining War
Lesson 3: Clausewitz’s Trinity
- War involves every aspect of society: The key is finding the right balance between these different factors
1-Government (politics, reason, intelligence)
2-The People (hate, enmity, primal violence, passion)
3-The Armed Forces (calculation game of change, odds, values)
Defining War
Lesson 4: Morale is crutial
- Clausewitz – military force is material capabilities times the spiritual element
- No military can succeed without the support of society and a viable strategy
–>Example: The US and Vietnam:
-Huge military apparatus, enormous economic resources
-5000,000 troops at height
-US loses the war on the home front
-American Public opinion against mobilization
-1975 Final ignominious defeat (US helicopters evacuate US embassy in saigon)
Defining War
War always Changes
- Evolves in response to changes in technology, state and society
- First half of 20th Century saw a return to “Total War”
- The “Cold War” - Brinksmanship
- Since 1945 most conflicts are internal
-Level of violence is quite severe
Defining war
For + Waves of Internal War
- Decolonization Process –India/Pakistan, Chinese civil war, Independence movements in South East Asia, the Middle East and Africa (1945-1965)
- Cold War- proxy war- East versus West – Wietnam, Indonesia, Nigeria, Afganistan, Angola
What is Economy?
Economy- The way in which societies work together to meet their needs under conditions of scarcity
What is Political Economy?
Political Economy- The impact of the political system on the economy, and of the economy on politics
What is International Political Economy?
International Political Economy- Political economy on the international level
Trade
Multiple related issues
- International Trade
- International investment
- Foreign direct investment (FDI)
- Stocks and Bonds
- International Regulations (How countries internationally agree on standards)
- International Monetary Cooperation
- Management of Economic Crises
- Etc.
Trade
Ancient Origins of Trade
(The Silk Road)
- Long distance trade across Eurasia
- Towns and Guilds flourish
- Trade proved resources for large European armies
- Fall of Constantinople 1453
- Spices (most important commodity)
-Interruption of trade routes
-War between Ottoman and Christian Countries
-Major incentive for European explorers to move across the atlantic to find alternate routes - Leds the creation of colonial empires
**First Truly Global trade system - 16th Century
**