INTERNAL GOVERNANCE Flashcards
What is corporate governance?
- Corporate governance may be viewed as being about the management of business enterprises organized in corporate form – and the mechanisms by which managers are supervised
- Usually corporate governance is a topic that includes examining corporate governance rules, the organizational structure of the company, and the duties of those involved in its management
- Corporate mangers hold immense power in being able to deal with other people’s money; funds provided by shareholders, creditors and other stakeholders in the company
- With that power comes responsibility and also legal obligations through various duties placed on directors and managers
Internal Stakeholders
› Employees
› Manager
› Owners
External Stakeholders
› Suppliers
› Society
› Government
› Creditors
› Shareholders
› Customers
INTERNAL MANAGEMENT PRIOR TO JULY 1998
- Prior to July 1998, every company was required to have a memorandum of association and articles of association
› These documents were developed in the UK from 1844 and explained to the outside world the company’s purpose and objectives:
Memorandum of association was the external document
Articles of association was the internal document
CHANGES IN 1998
- The Company Law Review Act 1998 (Cth) amended legislation to simplify and modernise company law
› Separate documents dispensed with; memorandum of association and articles of association formed into a ‘corporate constitution’
› Alternatively, a company could rely on Replaceable Rules that have been included in the Corporations Act - What Changed in 1998?
› For companies that existed (incorporated) Prior to 1 July 1998
3 choices: - Do nothing. In that existing memorandum and articles are consolidated and become the Corporate Constitution;
- choose to repeal their corporate constitution and accept the replaceable rules of the Corporations Act; or
- adopt a Corporate Constitution by passing a special resolution. The Constitution adopted may include replaceable rules and/or their own draft individual provisions
Types of companies to whom general rules automatically apply differently
- No liability companies – these must have a corporate constitution as there is still a requirement for a mining purposes objects clause: s 112(2)
- Sole member/director proprietary companies – if the same person is both a director and member of the company, then the replaceable rules do not apply: s 135(1) (these types of companies have their own specific provisions in the Corporations Act, such as ss 198E, 201F and 202C)
- Listed companies – ASX Listing Rules (LR 15.11) require certain provisions to be in a corporate constitution, these companies cannot rely solely on the replaceable rules
- Further, there are mandatory provisions in the Corporations Act which cannot be excluded, modified or replaced by the company making a different provision, for instance the right of a member to inspect free of charge certain registers kept by the company: s 173
Objects Clauses
- The only remnant from the previous memorandum of association that may continue today is the objects clause
- An objects clause (known as a scope of business clause) was part of the memorandum which described a long list of business activities in which the company might engage
- The Corporations Act makes an object clause mandatory for No Liability companies, but any company is able to place such a clause into its corporate constitution: s 125
- The objects clause had two purposes:
1. to protect investors who would know their money would be invested; and
2. to protect creditors so that the company’s capital was not spent in unauthorized activities - The object clause suffered a number of problems due to the common law concept of ultra vires
- The legal meaning of ultra vires is exceeding the powers of the entity
- If a company exceeded its contractual powers as stated in the object clause, the resultant contract was void; this meant that the company could only carry on the business activities that were stated in the objects clause in the memorandum
- Through statutory amendments in 1984, the object clause is now optional
› S 124 of the Corporations Act, the company has full legal capacity of an individual; this effectively removes the the whole concept of ultra vires for corporations and gives the company full contractual capacity
Internal Governance Rules
- Regulation of a company’s internal management may be done by the replaceable rules that apply to a company, by a constitution, or by a combination of both
- The internal governance rules have effect as contractual obligations on the company, its members and officers; changes generally require a special resolution of members
- However, regulation of a company’s internal management is not limited to the corporate governance rules; can include eg. a separate agreement among the company’s shareholders: Elders Forestry Ltd v Bosi Security Services Ltd (2010) 80 ACSR 122
- Replaceable Rules and Constitution: Part 2B.4 Corporations Act
› Replaceable Rules are listed in a convenient summary table found in s 141 of the Corporations Act
WHAT INTERNAL GOVERNANCE DEAL WITH
› the appointment, removal and powers of the company’s officers (directors and secretary) (ss 201G and 203C);
› The procedure for convening and conducting directors’ meetings (ss 248A-G);
› The procedure for convening and conducting members’ meetings (including voting rights) (ss 249C and 250J);
› Any special rights attaching to classes of shares;
› Rules relating to dividends (s 254U);
› Rules relating to the transfer and transmission of shares (ss 1072A-B, 1072D, 1072F-G).
WHEN DO THE REPLACEABLE RULES APPLY
- A company may choose to have its internal management governed by the replaceable rules as et out in the Corporations Act
- If a company was formed on or after 1 July 1998, it may make the election for the replaceable rules to govern simply by not adopting a constitution
- If a company was formed prior to 1 July 1998, it can invoke the replaceable rules by repealing its existing memorandum and articles of association: s 135
- The replaceable rules apply to a company unless displaced or modified in accordance with s 135(2) by operation of s 135(1) (the way in which replaceable rules may be displaced/modified by company constitution is discussed below)
- If the replaceable rules are amended by parliament, those amendments apply automatically to the company
WHEN IS IT APPROPRIATE TO USE THE REPLACEABLE RULES
- Its important for the company, its participants and their advisors to look closely at each replaceable rule to determine whether, in the individual circumstances of the company, that rule is appropriate for the particular company
- Potential advantages of Replaceable Rules:
› Rules are located in relevant sections of the Act;
› Reduction or elimination of expenses in keeping corporate constitutions up-to-date;
› Replaceable rules will always be up-to-date on statutory change;
› Replaceable rules provide basic standards required for a company to function
DISADVANTAGES OF REPLACEABLE RULES
- No flexibility
- Not exhaustive
› Many companies will need to add additional provisions to the RR.
› i.e. companies that wish to have partially paid shares. - May not be commercially desirable i.e. s 254D
COMPANY CONSTITUTIONS
- Instead of relying on the replaceable rules, a company may choose to adopt a different set of rules in the form of a ‘constitution’
- Members of public companies that have adopted a constitution can obtain a copy of that constitution from company: s 139
- Because public companies must lodge their constitutions and any amendments with ASIC, any person can obtain a public company’s constitution by conducting a search of ASIC’s records
WHY AND HOW TO ADOPT A CONSTITUTION
- A company may want to substitute different rules for some or all of the replaceable rules; to supplement the replaceable rules, to address matters not covered by them
- Collect internal governance matters into a single document; meet the requirements of ASX Listing Rules (for public companies); to ensure that if parliament amends a replaceable rule that it does not affect the company unless specifically adopted, etc
- A company can choose to adopt a constitution on registration; each person who is becoming a member must agree in writing to the terms of the proposed constitution before the application is lodged: s 136(1)(a)
- In passing a resolution to adopt a constitution the members of the company will be bound by the rules that govern the exercise of their voting rights
AMENDING OR REPEALING A CONSTITUTION
- If a company has a constitution, it may wish to amend it from time to time (s 136); alternatively, it may wish to repeal that constitution and rely on the replaceable rules (s 137)
- Generally, amending or repealing a company’s constitution requires a special resolution of its members (and may make further requirements to be satisfied before the special resolution takes place, such as requiring the written consent of all members: s 136(3))
› The corporate constitution can be legally altered by passing a special resolution, which requires 75% majority vote by the members and following a basic procedure
› Additional requirements could be needing approval of members (i.e. for a sml company). - If a company has passed a resolution to amend or repeal a constitution, that resolution will take effect on the day it is passed or on a later date specified in the resolution
HOW DOES A CONSTITUTION OPERATE TO DISPLAY OR MODIFY REPLACEABLE RULES
- s 135(2) of the Corporations Act states that:
› ‘a provision of a section or subsection [of the Corporations Act] that applies to a company as a replaceable rule can be displaced or modified by the company’s constitution’ - The constitution should make clear the company’s intention to displace or modify one or more of the replaceable rules
- For example, a difficulty may be created where a company’s constitution does not expressly exclude a particular replaceable rule but deals with a matter covered by a replaceable rule, in a manner that is inconsistent with that rule
ADVANATAGES OF CONSTITUTION
- Wide range of companies
- Tailored
- Flexible
- Shareholders can amend (special resolution of shareholders)
- Single document
DISADVANTAGES OF CONSTITUTION
- Expensive to draft and maintain
› i.e. legislative changes - Disagreements over clauses
- Special resolution to make changes
LEGAL EFFECT OF INTERNAL GOVERNANCE RULES
S 140 - Statutory Contract:
- A company’s internal governance rules operate as a contract
- This contract is created, not by all parties signing it, but by statute
› Each person involved is taken to have accepted the contract.
- s 140 is important in determining the manner in which the internal governance rules are to be interpreted, the rights of the company, its members and officers to require compliance with the rules and the consequences of failure by some who are bound to comply with them