Insolvency Flashcards
What is insolvency, and how is it categorized?
Insolvency refers to the inability to pay debts.
- Corporate insolvency: A company cannot pay its debts.
- Personal insolvency: An individual cannot pay their debts.
What are the objectives of corporate insolvency law?
- Rescuing financially distressed companies.
- Controlling directors’ conduct to ensure they act responsibly during insolvency.
- Protecting creditors to maximize debt recovery.
What are the aims of personal insolvency law?
- Protect creditors from further losses.
- Encourage entrepreneurship by allowing honest bankrupt individuals to be discharged from bankruptcy after one year.
What laws primarily govern corporate and personal insolvency in the UK?
- Insolvency Act 1986 (IA 1986): Establishes the legal framework for insolvency processes.
- Insolvency Rules 2016: Provides procedural rules for implementing insolvency laws.
What are the four legal tests for determining corporate insolvency under Sections 122 and 123 of the IA 1986?
- Statutory demand: A debt of £750 or more remains unpaid 21 days after demand is issued.
- Unpaid judgment debt: A creditor has obtained a judgment but cannot enforce payment.
- Cash flow test: The company cannot pay debts as they fall due.
- Balance sheet test: The company’s liabilities exceed its assets.
Why is it important to determine if a company is insolvent?
- Initiation of insolvency proceedings: Insolvency is usually a prerequisite for creditors to start processes like liquidation.
- Director accountability: Insolvency status determines if directors may face personal liability for wrongful or fraudulent trading.
What options are available for an insolvent company, and what is the significance of the Corporate Insolvency and Governance Act 2020 (CIGA 2020)?
- Liquidation: Selling assets and ceasing operations.
- Administration: Attempting to rescue the company as a going concern.
- Company Voluntary Arrangement (CVA): An agreement to restructure debts.
- CIGA 2020: Introduced two new regimes:
* Moratorium: Temporary protection from creditors to allow for rescue.
* Restructuring plan: A court-approved restructuring process for company survival.
What is liquidation, and what are its key steps?
Liquidation (or winding up) involves:
- Ceasing business operations.
- Appointing a liquidator to take over the company.
- Selling the company’s assets.
- Distributing proceeds to creditors according to statutory priorities.
- Dissolving the company in the official registry.
What are the three types of liquidation, and how are they initiated?
- Compulsory liquidation: A third party (often a creditor) petitions the court to wind up the company.
- Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation (CVL): Initiated by the company in response to creditor pressure due to insolvency.
- Members’ Voluntary Liquidation (MVL): Used by a solvent company, typically for orderly closure or dormancy.
What happens in compulsory liquidation, and what role does the Official Receiver (OR) play?
- A creditor petitions the court using grounds under Sections 122-123 IA 1986 (e.g., inability to pay debts).
- If granted, the court orders the company to be wound up.
- The Official Receiver (OR):
* Automatically becomes liquidator.
* May appoint a private insolvency practitioner if assets cover their fees.
* Manages asset distribution and creditor payment.
What powers does a liquidator have during the liquidation process?
- Carry on the company’s business to realize assets.
- Commence or defend lawsuits.
- Investigate past transactions and directors’ conduct.
- Collect and distribute the company’s assets to creditors.
- Take necessary steps to complete the winding-up process.
What is the avoidance of floating charges under Section 245 IA 1986?
- A floating charge can be automatically void if it was created:
- Without fresh consideration (new value) being provided to the company.
- Within the relevant time before the onset of insolvency:
* Two years for charges in favor of a connected person.
* One year for charges in favor of an unconnected person, and the company must have been insolvent at the time of granting the charge or become insolvent as a result.
What is the relevant time for floating charges to be voidable, and how is “connected person” defined?
- Relevant time:
- Two years for charges benefiting a connected person.
- One year for charges benefiting unconnected persons.
- Connected person: Defined under Sections 249 and 435 IA 1986 and includes:
1. A director or shadow director.
2. Close relatives or business associates of directors.
3. Associated companies, such as those in the same group or controlled by a director.
What are preferences under Section 239 IA 1986?
- A preference occurs when a company, before insolvency, does something to put a creditor or third party in a better position than others in the event of liquidation.
- Requirements for a preference:
1. Relevant time: - Two years for connected persons.
- Six months for others.
2. The company was insolvent at the time or became insolvent due to the transaction.
3. A desire to prefer the recipient is required, presumed for connected persons but rebuttable.
- Requirements for a preference:
What remedies can the court impose for a preference?
- Order the release of any security granted as part of the preference.
- Require repayment of transferred property or proceeds from the sale of such property.
- Reverse the effect of the preference to ensure equality among creditors.
What is a transaction at an undervalue under Section 238 IA 1986?
- A transaction at an undervalue occurs when a company:
- Makes a gift or transfers an asset for no consideration.
- Transfers an asset for significantly less than its market value.
* Relevant time: Two years before insolvency.
* If the transaction benefits a connected person, insolvency is presumed unless disproven.
What remedies are available for transactions at an undervalue?
The court may:
1. Require the recipient to pay the difference between the market value and the consideration paid.
2. Return the transferred property to the company.
3. Reverse any effects of the undervalued transaction.
What is a transaction defrauding creditors under Section 423 IA 1986?
- A transaction is considered to defraud creditors if it was intended to put assets out of their reach or prejudice their interests.
- Key features:
1. No specific time limit applies, unlike other claims.
2. Requires proof of intent to prejudice creditors.
What are extortionate credit transactions under Section 244 IA 1986?
- Definition: A credit transaction where the terms are unfairly high or the arrangement is oppressive.
- Relevant time: Two years before insolvency.
- The court may:
1. Reduce the payments owed under the credit agreement.
2. Set aside the credit agreement entirely.
What is a “preference” in insolvency law, and how is it proven?
- A preference occurs when a company puts someone in a better position than they would have been if the company went insolvent (§ 239 IA 1986).
- Proof requirements:
- Relevant time: Two years for connected persons; six months for others.
- The company was insolvent at the time or became insolvent as a result.
- Evidence of a desire to prefer, presumed for connected persons.
What is a Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation (CVL), and why might directors feel pressured to initiate it?
A CVL is initiated by the company through discussions between directors, shareholders, and creditors, with creditors taking over the process early.
* Pressure on Directors:
1. Creditors may pressurize directors to start the process.
2. Directors aim to avoid personal liability for misfeasance, fraudulent trading, or wrongful trading if the company continues to trade while insolvent.
What is a Members’ Voluntary Liquidation (MVL), and when is it used?
An MVL is a process available only to solvent companies. If the company is found insolvent during the MVL, it must be converted to a Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation (CVL).
* Common Uses: 1. To wind up dormant companies, such as within a group structure. 2. When directors in an owner-managed company wish to retire or cease trading. * Requirement: Directors must swear a statutory declaration confirming the company’s solvency before the MVL can begin.
What constitutes a transaction at an undervalue under insolvency law?
A transaction at an undervalue occurs when:
- The company makes a gift or transfers assets to another party for no consideration.
- The company receives consideration significantly lower in value than the value of the assets it provides.
Such transactions can be challenged if they occurred during the relevant time before insolvency.
What is the “relevant time” for challenging a transaction at an undervalue, and what conditions apply?
- The relevant time is two years ending with the onset of insolvency.
- The company must have been insolvent at the time of the transaction or became insolvent as a result of the transaction.
- If the transaction was with a connected person, insolvency is presumed, though this presumption can be rebutted.
What defenses are available for a transaction at an undervalue?
A transaction at an undervalue can be defended if:
1. It was entered into in good faith.
2. It was done for the purpose of carrying on the business.
3. There were reasonable grounds for believing the transaction would benefit the company.
Example: Selling property at less than market value to secure immediate cash when no other buyers are available.
What is an extortionate credit transaction, and what is the time frame for challenging it?
- An extortionate credit transaction involves:
1. Payments that are grossly exorbitant.
2. Terms that grossly contravene principles of fair dealing. - The transaction can be challenged if it occurred in the three years ending with the day of the company’s insolvency.
Note: These claims are rare due to the difficulty in proving exorbitant terms or unfairness.
What is a transaction defrauding creditors, and how does it differ from a transaction at an undervalue?
- A transaction defrauding creditors occurs when:
- A transaction at an undervalue is conducted with the intent to put assets beyond creditors’ reach.
- The purpose is to prejudice creditors’ interests.
Key Differences:
* No time limit applies for claims of fraud against creditors.
* Proving intent to defraud is necessary but often difficult.