Human Rights Flashcards
When did Human Rights Act recieve Royal Assent and when did it officially come into force
Royal Assent- Nov 1998
In to force on 2nd Oct 2000
What was the purpose of the Human Rights Act (1998)
To incorporate the articles of the European Convention in to UK law
Potential negative impact of HRA 1998
Creates loopholes for terrorist and criminal to exploit to avoid being extrodited or imprisoned.
What are the 3 stages of trial agenda and why is it important
Stage 1: Evidence
Stage 2: Powers and policy
Stage 3: Decision making
Trial agenda is vital in ensuring police are accountable for their actions. Also shows the process with which we act. We collect all the evidence we can find, irrespective of whether or not it supports our case (we are impartial and want complete truth) and then we decide what powers and policies to use/follow to ensure we act lawfully.
What evidence must be declared in an investigation
All evidence, irrespective of whether or not it supports our case. We must be impartial and declare all evidence found.
If PACE or the HRA are broken then we will act _
Unlawfully
What does PACE state is required in order to stop and search someone
Must have legitimate reason (reasonable grounds) to suspect person is in possession of stolen articles or objects they are searching for (ie murder weapon)
If a murder weapon is found during an unlawful stop and search can thsi evidence be used in court?
No, it becomes admissable and can NOT be used to prosecute
What does PACE stand for
Police and Criminal Evidence Act (1984)
When was PACE intorduced
1984
What is the name of the Convention issued after WW2 that set out various ‘articles’ to protect civil liberties
The European Convention For The Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms
When was The European Convention For The Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms drafted
1950s
What was the aim of The European Convention For The Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms
The convention’s pronciples, set out various ‘articles’, protect most, but not all, civil liberties from unjustified interference by the state
What right did people recieve in 1966 w/ regarded to Human Rights. Why was this flawed
Individuals given right to take alleged breaches to European Convention to European Court in Strassburg.
Location meant trip was far too expensive for majority of population therefore not really able to challenge breaches of their HRs.
Purpose of HRA (1998)
Puts conventions articles into UK law so that breaches can be dealt w/ in UK courts.
Why is there no article 1 or 13 in the HRA act (1998)
By creating the HRA (1998), these articles are achieved.
Is NOT because people think number 13 is unlucky
What is article 2 of The European Convention For The Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms
Right to life
What is article 3 of The European Convention For The Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms
Prohibition of torture
What is article 4 of The European Convention For The Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms
Prohibition of slavery or forced labour
Does article 4 of the HRA act (prohibits slavery and forced labour) refer to community service or unpaid overtime
No! Community service is not forced, there is another option of a prison sentence. Unpaid overtime is also not forced, you can quit the job or leave and risk being sacked.
What is article 5 of The European Convention For The Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms
Right to liberty and security
What is article 6 of The European Convention For The Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms
Right to a fair trial
What is article 7 of The European Convention For The Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms
No punishment without law
What is article 8 of The European Convention For The Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms
Right to a private and family life
What is article 9 of The European Convention For The Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms
Freedom of thought, conscience and religion
What is article 10 of The European Convention For The Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms
Freedom of expression
What is article 11 of The European Convention For The Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms
Freedom of assembly and association
What is article 12 of The European Convention For The Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms
Right to marry
What is article 14 of The European Convention For The Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms
Prohibition of discrimination
What are the 3 categories of Rights
- Absolute
- Limited
- Qualified
Define an absolute right
A right with which the state cannot interfere, even if it is in public interest
Define a limited right
Such rights can be restricted or witheld under explicit or finite circumstances
Define a qualified right:
General public interest can be taken into account, allowing the state to interfere.
State can interfere with these rights when it is in public interest
Which 4 articles are absolute rights
Article 2- right to life
Article 3- prohibition of torture
Article 4- prohibition of slavery and forced labour
Article 7- No punishement without law
Whixh 3 articles define limited rights
Article 5- Right to liberty and security (arrests go against this)
Article 6- Right to a fair trial
Article 12- Right to marry
Which 5 articles define qualified rights
Article 8- right to a private or family life
Article 9- Freedom of thought, consceince and religion
Article 10- Freedom of expression
Article 11- Freedom of assembley or association
Article 14- Prohibiton of discrimination
On average how many ASB incidents are required before a victom makes 1st police call and how many more incidents occur between each call thereafter
30 ASB incidents before 1st police call
30 more incidents between each call.
How does article 2 (right to life) affect the police
Police are onligated to preserve life and can take life to prevent loss of other or own life as long as there is threat of imminent harm/death.
Right to life trumps all, including investigation so can enter crime scene and mess uo evidence if chance to save/protect life
How does article 3 (prhohibtion of torture) affect police
Can be things like incorrect use of cuffs or not allowing toilet use
Definition of torture
Unwarranted, unjustifiable treatment
How does article 7 (no punishment without law) affect police
We are impartial. We present all evidence found and do not allow personal biases to affect our investigation and we do not act on emotions. Only legal system can punish people.
Why is article 12 (right to marry) a limited right
Are restrictions
Eg can’t marry animals, objects, children, immediate family. People already married
Police can not marry criminals
Why is article 6 (right to fair trial) a limited right
Law states wmust be granted a fair trial, BUT do not always have the right to a trial. Appeals can only occur if doubt/scrutiny is cast on original hearing (eg new evidence or faulted policies/procedures)
Why is article 9- Freedom of thought, conscience and religion
Can’t tell people what to think or dictate their religion/beliefs.
Line is drawn at the law.
For example with Islamic extremism- can’t stop someone thinking a certain way or believing a religion.
Whu is article 11 (assmebley and association) qualified
Have right to protest but can stop people protesting if breaking law and can stop them doing it in certaina areas if they are choosing a place to provoke or harm someone/ a group of people. Eg anti-Hilal protest near a mosque.
Why is Article 10 (expression) a qualified right
Public Order Act.
Can’t express self in a disorderly fashion.
Example: Abu Hamzer
Examples of public authorities
- Court or tribunal
- Any person certain of whose functions are function of a public nature (eg police, hospitals, armed forces, transport system, transport system, private contractors carrying out a public function)
Principles of The European Convention For The Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms
Proportionate Legality Accountanility Necessity Scrutiny Ethical
Plan or plans or plane
How can victims use the Convention in court
As a:
- Defence
- Basis of an appeal
- Seek judicial review
- Bring civil proceedings for damages
What can be caused by victims using the Convention in court
- Can see proceedings stalled for abuse of process
- Evidence ruled inadmissable
- Indictments abd convictions quashed
- Compensation awarded (where court is able to do so)