Hubbard Brook Flashcards
How can evapotranspiration be calculated from HB field data of forested watersheds?
P = S + ET
ET = P - S
where ET = evapotranspiration
P = precipitation (input)
S = streamflow (output)
What is considered nutrient input in a forested ecosystem like HB, according to Likens and Boorman?
precipitation (P) carrying chemicals
What is considered nutrient output in a forested ecosystem like HB, according to Likens and Boorman?
streamflow chemicals (S)
What is the mathematical relationship between precipitation and streamflow at HB?
P = ET + S
as P increases, S also increases (linear)
ET will not change over time because the buffer is maintained, the amount retained remains stable
What is the main source of silica at HB?
weathering of rocks
What is the fate of nitrate (NO3-) from precipitation during summer at HB?
Are nutrients lost evenly throughout the year in the streamflow at HB? explain
no
there’s a peak in the spring with the snowmelt (S > P) and a decline in the summer when there’s more water taken up by plants (S decreases)
What is the impact of clear cutting on mineral nitrogen?
huge loss of NO3- from leaching
How does Douglas-fir vary in nutrient budgets for Ca, Mg, K? explain
define mixotrophy
when organisms are both photosynthesizers and hetertrophs
Is mixotrophy important in Mirror Lake? where, why?
yes!! because they can photosynthesize and consume other organisms
common at surface in summer when lots of light
common throughout water column when less light
What kind(s) of cyanobacteria are found in Mirror Lake?
anabaena
chroococcus
merismopedia
Why are the cyanobacteria(s) found at Mirror Lake important?
because they are mixotrophs
Anabaena and Chroococcus can also fix N2
Who were the major authors from the HB models?
Likens and Bormann
What years did the HB study run?
1963-2013
What were the major papers published from the HB study?
Likens, G.E. (2013). Biogeochemistry of a Forested Ecosystem
Bormann, F.H., Likens, G.E. (1979). Pattern and process in a forested ecosystem
Likens, G.E. (1985). An ecosystem approach to aquatic ecology: Mirror Lake and its environment
What was the main lake involved in the HB model ecosystem study?
Mirror Lake
According to Likens and Bormann, what moves the inputs and outputs of ecosystems?
meteorlogic (atmospheric), geologic, and biologic drivers
in the conceptual model for HB, what are the inputs to an ecosystem?
meteorlogic (atmospheric) inputs
particulates in the air and gaseous particles
in the conceptual model for HB, what components are part of the intrasystem cycle of an ecosystem?
nutrients that have no prominent gaseous phase and cannot leave the boundaries of the ecosystem
organic compartment:
- living plant mass
- animal biomass (herbivore, carnivore, detritivore, omnivore)
- dead biomass (litter, dead animals)
available nutrients:
- on exchange sites
- in soil
primary and secondary minerals:
- mineral (rocks)
- precipitation
How are atmospheric inputs connected with the organic component of an ecosystem in the conceptual model?
atmospheric inputs are taken up by living organisms
and organisms release gases into the atmosphere
How are atmospheric inputs connected with the available nutrients of an ecosystem in the conceptual model?
atmospheric inputs are either wet or dry
wet: precipitation (snow, rain)
dry: ash, dust
are deposited onto plants or soil surfaces
organisms and soil release gases into the atmosphere
How are minerals connected with the available nutrients of an ecosystem in the conceptual model?
minerals can be released and become available through weathering of rocks
available nutrients can form secondary minerals and add to the mineral component
How are the organic components connected with the available nutrients of an ecosystem in the conceptual model?
living organisms can immobilize (uptake) forms of nutrients
living organisms can mineralize nutrients in the soil, leaching of nutrients, throughfall, streamflow, exudation of nutrients to enter soil
In the conceptual model, what represents P in a watershed ecosystem?
P = precipitation (inputs)
the atmospheric (wet and dry deposition/precipitation), geologic, and biologic inputs
majorly precipitation
In the conceptual model, what represents S in a watershed ecosystem?
S = streamflow (outputs)
the atmospheric, geologic, and biologic outputs
In the conceptual model, what represents ET in a watershed ecosystem?
ET = evapotranspiration
the biological release of gases
Where is the HB watershed?
New Hampshire, USA
How many watersheds are in the HB?
6
Describe the geographic region surrounding the HB watershed experiment
In New Hampshire, USA
the watershed is proximal to Mt Cushman (977m) and Mt Kineo (1015m) all with rivers/streams running down to Mirror Lake (213m)
Which watershed at HB was clearcut? when?
in 1966-67, watershed 2 was clearcut
Which watershed at HB was the control?
watershed 6
What was the unit of study for the HB?
watersheds
What was the scientific approach to studying the hydrology of HB?
small watershed approach
devices (buckets, funnels) in multiple locations used to measure the inputs (precipitation in mm/yr) and concentrations of chemicals sampled
and weirs at independent streams were used to measure the outputs (streamflow in mm/yr) and concentrations of chemicals sampled
ET = P - S
Generally, how will the volume of water delivered through streamflow vary?
daily, seasonally, annually
describe the average hydrologic budget (water volume for P, S, ET) for watershed 6 measured from 1963-2009
P was highest at 1400 mm/yr
S was mid btw 800-1000 mm/yr
ET was lowest ~500 mm/yr
P was measured at 1400 mm/yr in watershed 6, how does this compare to volume of input in Victoria? Kamloops? Tofino?
pretty high
Victoria ~
Kamloops very low
Tofino very high ~3000 mm/yr
What part of Vancouver Island does watershed 6’s P compare to?
Campbell River
~1400 mm/yr
Which two components of measuring hydrology in HB are correlated when looking annually?
P and S
with increased P, S increased
but P always higher than S
When looking annually, how does ET compare to P and S in watershed 6? is it correlated/related?
ET is not correlated with P and S and does not follow the same trend
ET remains fairly constant because P - S = ET
when looking monthly, how do P and S trend in watershed 6?
P remains fairly constant with little seasonal variation
S increases in winter months because uptake of water by plants slows down during these months
S significantly increases and surpasses P in the spring because snowmelt
Why is precipitation higher than streamflow in watershed 6 in most months?
most of the year, plants are taking up water and photosynthesis is
Which variables, when annual ppt is plotted against annual streamflow or ET has significant correlation? what does this mean for the ecosystem?
precipitation and streamflow are significantly positively correlated
this means that the ecosystem is limited by precipitation
Based on the standard errors of the mean for the 4 watersheds’ P, S, and ET values, is the small watershed method accurate?
yes, the standard errors were between 0.45-1.30
high confidence in the values
Why is streamflow higher than P in the Spring?
snowmelt increases with warming weather = huge output of water flow in the streams
Why is there a peak in streamflow in the Fall months?
In the Fall, the uptake of water by plants is decreasing, so the amount of water leaving the watershed will be higher
In watershed 6, are the concentrations of Si, Ca, sulfate (SO4^2-) higher in P or S? why?
higher in S because Si, Ca, and Sulfate all have mineral inputs (sedimentary BGC cycles)
they do not enter the system from the precipitation, but from the rocks/minerals
In watershed 6, is nitrate (NO3-) higher in P or S? why?
higher in P
because Nitrogen has a gaseous BGC cycle and the major input of N is from the atmosphere
How do the minerals measured in watershed 6 (Ca, Sulfate, Nitrate, silica) compare to each other in their concentrations in P and S?
Ca, SO4^2-, and Si are in higher concentrations in the streamflow because their inputs are from sedimentary cycles - mineral/rock weathering
whereas,
nitrate (NO3-) is higher in P because its input is from the gaseous cycle - atmospheric input
What did the HB study of H+ ions in precipitation show? how is this related to acid rain?
because acid rain was a huge problem in the 1970s, and was addressed by decreasing/regulating use of sulfur in human activities,
[H+] ions in precipitation decreased over periods of years as precipitation became less acidic
How was the issue of acid rain addressed?
regulating the use of sulfur and NOx for human activities
H+ ions in P decreased over years and the HB study showed this
What was causing the problematic acid rain?
emissions of sulfur (SO2) and nitrogen based chemicals (NOx) from the US
How did HB show ecosystem recovery as sulfur and nitrogen-based chemicals were becoming more regulated in the US?
Watershed 6 showed recovery as the concentration of basic cations increased in the streamwater (S)
base cations have buffering capacities to neutralize acidic ions
How does acid rain harm watershed ecosystems? how can we chemically measure that this is happening?
as H+ ions increase in the P inputs, the watershed system loses it’s capacity to buffer acidic ions = less base ions in S
What did the HB study find about the affect of acid rain on cation concentrations in P and S in watershed 6?
Ca, Mg, K, Na were higher in the stream water than in precipitation, but were all decreasing in [] in the streamflow over years
this means that less cations are present in the streamflow, lowering the capacity of the system to buffer the acidity being inputted
Why are the units to measure concentration of Ca, K, Mg, Na different than for measuring P and S?
the units to measure the nutrients need to account for some nutrients have single charges or double charges
ex. Na+ vs. Ca2+
In watershed 6, why does the H+ ion decrease in P but not in S over time? why does H+ decrease over time in P? (over years)
As NOx and SO2 emissions are regulated and decreased, the amount of H+ ions in the P will decrease
H+ is constant in the streamflow, this means that more is being retained in the system than lost = H+ is buffered within the system
What is the difference between ammonium and nitrate in watershed 6 P and S? why is there a difference? (over years)
Ammonium in P is higher and is stable in S = ammonium is positively charged so it adheres tightly to clay particles within the system is harder to lose in the S
nitrate’s P and S overlap and follow the same decreasing trendline:
nitrate is negatively charged and is repelled by clay particles, so it’s easier to be lost in the S
How does sulfate compare to nitrate and ammonium in terms of P and S for watershed 6 (over years)?
Sulfate is much higher in the stream flow than in the precipitation
this is because S has both a sedimentary and gaseous cycle, whereas N (nitrate and ammonium) are both gaseous only
How can we tell that the system is acting as a buffer for acid rain in watershed 6?
looking monthly
the concentration of H+ is higher in precipitation than in the streamflow which has stable concentration
stable concentration of H+ in the stream flow means that more of the H+ coming in from P is being retained by the system (not lost in S) = the system is buffering the H+ ions
What is throughfall?
precipitation that falls through plant leaves
What is stemflow?
precipitation that falls along plant stems