How to think about weird things Flashcards
Remote Viewing
The alleged ability to acurately perceive information about distant geographical locations without using any sense
Precognitive Dream
A dream that seems to foretell the future
Who is remote viewing said to be available to?
Anyone, as it needs no special training
Who do some people look to to obtain predictions about the future?
Psychics
Astrologers
Tarot Card Readers
Homeopathy
Alternative medicine
Built on 2 main doctrines
2 Main doctrines of homeopathy
“Like cures like” - symptoms of a sick person can be cured by substances that actually produce the same symptoms in healthy people
The smaller the dose of this substance, the mightier the healing effect
The Hundreth-Monkey Phenomenon
“With the hundreth monkey, a kind of critical mass had been reached, forcing a kind of group mind - It was bullshit/lies
What is the trouble with paranormal phenomena?
They’re not just normal. It’s not simply that they’re rare and unusual (which they are); it’s that they seem to violate the natural order of things.
Paradigm
A theoretical framework that determines what questions are worth asking and what methods should be used
All scientific investigation takes place within a paradigm
Science only advances how?
By recognizing and dealing with anomalies
Paradigm Shift
WHen no satisfactory account of a phenomena is forthcoming, the scientific community is forced to abandon the old paradigm and adopt a new one = shift
Paradigm shift examples
Geocentric view of solar system to heliocentic
Creationism to evolution
Necessary Truths
A claim that can’t possibly be false
Ex. 2+2 = 4, Red is a color
Necessary Falsehoods
A claim that can’t possibly be true
Ex. 2+2=5, Red is not a color
Laws of Thought
Made by aristotle
Systematizes our knowledge of necessary truths
- Law of Noncontradiction
- Law of Identity
- Law of Excluded Middle
The Law of Noncontradiction
Nothing can both have a property and lack it at the same time
The Law of Identity
Everything is identical to itself
The Law of Exluded Middle
For any particular property, everything either has it or lacks it
Reducio Ad Absurdum (Reduction to Absurdity)
One of the most effective techniques of refuting a position
If you can show that a position has absurd consequences, you’ve provided a powerful reason for rejecting it
Logically Impossible
Anything that violates the Laws of Thought
Anything that is logically impossible can’t exist
Self-Contradictory
Something that violates the law of noncontradiction
SOmething that attributes both a property and its negation to a thing
Physically Impossible
Anything that violates the laws of physics/laws of science
Anything that’s inconsistent with the laws of nature
Whatever is physically impossible is?
Logically possible
Not everything that’s logically possible is?
Physically possible
Technological Possibility
Something is technologically impossible if it is currently beyond our capabilities to accomplish
Ex. Galactic travel
Not physically impossible
Just because something is logically or physically possible doesn’t mean that…
It is, or ever will be, actual
Just because you can’t explain something doesn’t mean that…
It’s supernatural
When faced with something you don’t understand, the most rational course of action is…
To seek a natural explanation
It isn’t the phenomena themselves that contradict physical law, but rather…
Our theories about them
Fallacy of Composition
Believing that what is true of the parts is true of the whole
Precognition
Seeing into the future
Not only seems to be physically impossible, but also logically impossible
Goes against the principle of causality “An effect cannot precede its cause”
Commits us to an existing nonexistent, which is logically impossible
Tachyons
Particles that can travel faster than the speed of light
Theoretically travel backwards in time because they travel faster than light
Carrying negative energy backwards in time or positive energy forwards in time
The price of knowledge is…
Freedom
If someone knows that something is going to happen, it must happen. But if it must happen, then no one is free to prevent it from happening
The “Many Worlds Interpretation” of Quantum Mechanics
The view that everything that can happen does happen in a parallel universe
Physically impossible
A Medium
A person said to contact spirits
Just because something seems/feels/appears real…
Doesn’t mean that it is
Part of the task of critically evaluating an unusual claim is to…
Control our tendency to believe or disbelieve without good reason
We usually assume that what we see is reality. We are generally at great risk of being dead-wrong with such assumptions when…
1) Our experience is uncorroborated (no one else has shared our experience)
2) Our conclusions are at odds with all known previous experience
3) Any of the peculiarities of our minds could be at work
Which is correct?
- Our normal perceptions have a direct, one-to-one correspondence to external reality - that they are like photographs of the outer world
- Perception is constructive, that it’s in part something that our minds manufacture. Thus what we perceive is determined, not only by our sense, but also by what we know, expect, believe, and what our physiological state is.
2.
Perceptual Constancies
Our tendency to have certain perceptual experiences regardless of the relevant input from our senses
Some of the best illustrations of our constructive perception at work
- Color Constany
- Size Constancy
Color Constancy
People often perceive an object as a certain color because they know that the object is supposed to be that color, even if the object is not that color at all
Size Constancy
You perceive the size of familiar objects as rougly constant no matter how far away they are
Our knowledge of size constancy is learned - we are not born with it
What plays the coordinating role in collective hallucinations?
Expectation
What is a pre-requesite of collective hallucinations?
Emotional excitement
The Power of Expectancy
We sometimes perceive exactly what we expect to perceive, regardless of what’s real
If we’re normal, expectancy or suggestion can cause us to perceive what simply isn’t there - this is especially true when the stimulus is vague or ambiguous or when clear observation is difficult
Pareidolia
A type of illusion or misconception
We simply see a vague stimulus as something it’s not; we etch meaning into the meaningless
Ex. face on mars
“Backward Masking” - certain messages are placed on recordings backwards
Backward Masking
The belief that certain messages are placed on a recording backwards to mask their true meaning
“The brain will unconsciously decipher the message and be affected by it”
Macro-PK
An example of beliefs generated in circumstances that are known to create cognitive illusions
Ex. Spoon Bending
Eyewitness accounts are…
Generally unreliable because of the influence of expectancy and belief, the effects of stress, selective attention, memory construction, poor observational conditions, and other factors
What is the main reason scientists do not accept the Bigfoot claim?
It conflicts with what we already know
The Autokinetic Effect
This effect refers to how a small stationary light in the dark will be perceived as moving
UFO sightings are complicated by this
This perception happens even if the person’s head remains still
Caused by involuntary movements of the eye
Can be influenced by the opinion of others
What can the Autokinetic Effect be influenced by?
The opinions of others
No single object has been mistaken as a UFO more often than…
Venus
False Memory Syndrome
When a patient receives false memories that are mislabeled as recovered memories after going through recovered memory therapy (RMT)
How does our brain remember experiences via memory?
Our memories aren’t copies/records
Our brains reach for a representation of an experience, then piece by piece, they reconstruct a memory based on this fragment - it is usually inexact and vulnerable to bias
Cryptomnesia
Hidden memory
Refers to thoughts and ideas that seem new and original, but which are actually memories of things that you’ve forgotten you knew
Our memory of an event can be drastically changed if…
We later encounter new information about the event
Our memories are more than just constructive - they’re also…
Selective
We selectively remember and ignore certain things - this sets up a memory bias
Retrieval Cue
When one can’t remember a dream, but then something happens to them that retreives from long term memory what happened in the dream
Our success as a species is due in large part to…
Our ability to organize things into categories and to recognize patterns in the behavior of things
Forer Effect
The phenomenon of believing that a general personality description is unique to oneself
For the effect to work, people have to be told that the catchall description pinpoints them specifically
A case of subjective validation
What is the Forer Effect a case of?
Subjective validation
Confirmation Bias
The tendency to look for and recognize only evidence that confirms our views
What type of evidence do we tend to look for? Confirming or disconfirming?
Confirming
When evaluating a claim, look for …. as well as confirming evidence
Disconfirming evidence
What is one way to cut down on confirmation bias?
To keep a number of different hypotheses in mind when evaluating a claim
The Availability Error
Occurs when people base their judgements on the evidence that’s vivid or memorable instead of reliable or trustworthy
The confirmation bias can be exacerbated by this
What can exacerbate confirmation bias?
Availability error
The Fallacy of Hasty Generalization/The Failure to Consider Sample Size
Basing a judgement on psychologically available information
To make a judgement about a group of things on the basis of evidence concerning only a few members of that group
When confirming evidence is more psychologically compelling than disconfirming evidence, we are likely to exhibit…
Confirmation bias
When evaluating a claim, look at all the relevant evidence, not just the …
Psychologically available evidence
Superstition
A belief that an action or situation can have an effect on something even though there is no logical relation between the two
The Appeal to Ignorance
“Just because you can’t show that the supernatural or paranormal explanation is false doesn’t mean that it is true” - this reason is logically fallacious
The Representativeness Heuristic
Members of a category should resemble a prototype and that effects should resemble their causes
The Conjunction Fallacy
Linda Problem
Believing that the probability of 2 events occurring together is greater than 1 alone
“The probability of 2 events occurring together can never be greater than the probability of one of them occurring alone”
Out of a group of 23 people, what are the chances that 2 of those 23 have the same birthday?
Contrary to popular belief, there is a 50-50 chance
The Gamber’s Fallacy
The idea that previous events can affect the probabilities in a current random event
It’s reasonable to accept personal experience as reliable evidence only if…
There’s no reason to doubt its reliability
Science tries to remove the element of _____ from the scientific process
Unsystematic personal experience
Realists
People who do not believe that reality depends on our thoughts about it - it exists independantly from us
Relativists
People who believe that the way the world is depends on what we think about it - we create our own realities
Why is relativism so appealing?
Because people assume that realism entails absolutism - there is only one correct way to represent reality
Absolutism is considered morally objectionable because it leads to…
Intolerance
Solipsism
The idea that “I alone exist” and create all of reality
Since the supposition that our beliefs create reality leads to a logical contradiction, we must conclude that…
Reality is independent of our beliefs
Subjectivism
The view that each of us creates our own reality
“Sophists” - greatest = Protagoras
Just because you believe something to be true…
Doesn’t mean that it is
New Agers
People who believe that reality is socially constructed
What we believe is largely a function of…
The society in which we were raised
Just because a group of people believe that something is true…
Doesn’t mean that it is
The Fallacy of Appeal to the Masses
To justify our beliefs by claiming that everyone shares them
We cannot justify this because everyone may be mistaken
Groups are just as/more prone to error as individuals are
A Conceptual Scheme
A set of concepts for classifying objects
Provides categories into which the items of our experience can be placed
The world is a product of a conceptual scheme
Another word for Paradigm
Can paradigms be considered to be objectively better than any other?
No
2 types of observation
Recognition and discrimination
REcognition may involve the use of theory
DEscrimination does not
By keeping these 2 functions separate, the brain allows us to deal with the unexpected
What does translation require?
A common point of reference
What is the most serious flaw of relativism?
It’s self-refuting because its truth implies its falsity
There is no objective evidence, therefore there is no true/false
Truth isn’t relative to…
Individuals, societies, or conceptual schemes
Belief can be relative because…
Individuals, societies, and conceptual schemes often have different beliefs
There is an external reality that is…
Independent of our representations of it
Are personal characteristics relative to persons?
Yes
Are the effects that anything might have on a person relative to that person?
Yes
Are certain states of affairs relative to individuals?
Yes
Is the truth about certain states of affairs relative to individuals?
No
Knowledge is…
Power
Prediction and control are keys to survival, and ___ makes prediction and control possible
Knowledge
Astrology claims…
A causal relationship between the prohetic sign and the events to which they correspond
Propositional Knowledge
A true proposition; factual knowledge
___ is necessary for knowledge because we can’t know something that’s false, and if we know something, we can’t believe that it’s false
True belief
Reasons confer ___ on propositions. The better the reasons…
Probability
The more likely it is that the proposition they support is true
Philosophical Skeptics
People who believe that most of us are deluded about the actual extent of our knowledge
“We can’t know what isn’t certain”