Ham Themes Flashcards
What is the fundamental nature of power?
trying to get away with getting more while doing less
The admin state is trying to escape ____ through ___
constitutional pathways, extralegal methods
How does Constitution handle justice?
doesn’t define it, leaves us to seek in myriad of ways
What are two fundamental differing views on the nature of the Consti?
fear of injustice (hard edge protections and limits that can’t be adjusted in response to public opinion) OR hope of greater justice (malleable protections)
What are the three modes of governance Ham identifies?
Leg, Admin, Conditions
What is Ham’s fundamental take on rights?
less is more
Ham thinks that as rights expand __
they bump into practical realities that restrict rights
Mathews makes due process ___
flexible contextual standard
Why are rights turned interests more easily curtailed?
subject to compelling govt interest
How does Goldberg restrict rights?
say right to hearing before deprived of benefits but untenable to have jury trial everytime so not what you get
what happens to the balancing test in Hamdi?
now applies to constraints not just benefits
What are powers restricting rights?
compelling govt interest, public right, police power
Case about admin state as public right
Atlas Roofing
Mathews turns rights into ____
interests rather than limits on govt
How does Madison letter to Jefferson characterize purpose of BoR
for people to internalize rights as norms
When court says rights are contingent on compelling govt interest ___
people will come to accept it and further weaken rights (Korematsu)
How has freedom of religion been watered down?
freedom from constraints (prohibition on discrim) –> freedom to benefit equally from govt/from law (now subject to govt interest)
How has freedom speech been watered down?
freedom from ex ante constraints _–> freedom from ex post punishment so opens space for govt to limit ex post and then ex ante
What are the solutions to watering down rights?
Don’t make new rights OR distinguish between old and new
Problems with distinguishing between old vs new rights
would have to be candid about judicial activism, progressive judges couldn’t expand rights as much as they wish
How does Const structure protect liberty?
authority to act + affirmative prohibitions (BoR)
How does Const authority to act protect liberty?
enumerated, SoP, certain rights (jury, due process)