Grant of a Lease Flashcards
What are the advantages of a lease for a commercial tenant?
- No need to spend capital
- Not a permanent investment (flexibility)
- Some premises only available as a leasehold (e.g. in shopping centre)
Who are commercial landlords?
- Private investors - individuals/companies making a business from letting premises
- Institutional investors - financial insitutions investing in property as a safe and valuable investment providing income (rent) and long term capital growth (rise in property prices)
What type of lease would an institutional investor prefer? What does this require from the tenant?
An FRI lease (full repairing and insuring lease) = tenants pick up costs associated with property and landlord receives clear rent
What is covenant strength?
To what extent the tenant has the means to comply with obligations and the assets the landlord can recover should they breach them
Long established company = good, new company = bad
If a tenant does not have good covenant strength, what are their options?
- Guarantor (e.g. director of company)
- Rent deposit
What does asset(/property) management involve for a commercial property solicitor?
- Granting lease to a tenant
- Considering applications by tenant to lease (e.g. alter premises)
- Advising on breaches of lease (rent failure, disrepair)
What is a lease?
The grant of a right to exclusive possession of land for a determinate term less than that which grantor has in the land
Freeholder has interest in perpetuity (fixed term will always be less)
What are the essential ingredients of a lease?
- Exclusive possession - tenant must be able to exclude strangers/landlord
- Fixed term of periodic tenancy - must not be for an indeterminate time (e.g. as long as tenant is an employee) bar exceptions
- Formalities
- The reversion - interest landlord holds is subject to lease - at end of lease term the property reverts to landlord
When must a legal lease be created by a deed?
If the term is over 3 years
Can be created in writing/orally if tenancy is 3 years or under
What is a (physical) lease?
The document that creates a leasehold interest. States contractual terms, respective obligations and rent payable
Will be a deed if it has to be
What are the landlord’s objectives when negotiating lease terms?
- FRI lease (rent paid by tenants clear of deduction)
- Lease ensuring premises insured, kept in repair and used only for permitted use
- Increase rent in line with market through rent review
- Have a say on how premises altered by tenant
- Control whom may occupy premises
What are the tenant’s objectives when negotiating lease terms?
- Use premises for intended purpose
- Contractual lease suitable for business purposes
- Flexibility if circumstances change
What does the tenant not want in a lease?
- Onerous restrictions on using premises/passing lease on to third party
- Provisions allowing for steep rise in rent
- Excessively unfair provisions that favour landlord
Should a determinate lease term be fixed term (6 months, 5 years) or periodic tenancy (monthly, yearly)?
Either! FRI leases generally for fixed term
A lease where tenant can give notice is less valuable
What is the term commencement date?
The date on which the lease term (e.g. 5 years) begins
Will the term commencement date be the same as completion (dated and legally binding) of lease?
Can be before (not expected to pay for unused period) or after (reversionary lease - parties want to extend letting in advance of expirty of current lease)
Landlord may want all leases to start at same time for simplicity
What is the difference when the term of a lease is “from and including” 5 January and from 5 January?
From and including 5 Jan = term expires on the day before the day of the next year (expires 4 Jan next year)
From 5 Jan = term expires on that day in following year as 5 Jan not included (expires 5 Jan next year)
From and including is most common
When is a break clause used?
Tenant unsure about commitment and landlord unwilling to grant a shorter term
Can be a landlord break, tenant break (common) or mutual break
Can specify a date (e.g. fifth anniversary of term commencement date) or a rolling date (e.g. any time after fifth anniversary)
What if a break clause is not included?
Neither landlord nor tenant can bring lease to an end before end of fixed term without agreement
Why would a landlord offer a 10 year lease with a 5 year break clause but not a 5 year lease?
Tenant might change mind and onerous to exercise
What are the two types of rent for leases?
Commercial and residential
Commercial leases = short leases with market rent (e.g. £20,000 per annum)
Residential leases = long leases (99-999 years) with a ground rent (peppercorn-£150) - first person to buy pays a premium to landlord
How will rent appear in an FRI lease?
- Expressed as a yearly figure (but payable 1/4ly)
- Payable in advance of quarter day (e.g. on 25 March for period running up to 23 June)
- How rent is to be paid is set out (usually as a standing order) and whether VAT payable
- Other payments (contributions to insurance, service charged) also described as ‘rent’
Rent proper often referred to as annual/yearly rent
Does the landlord have an implied right to increase rent?
No - FRI lease of 10 years + will usually contain one rent review clause
What are 4 types of rent review clause and which is most common in an FRI?
- Stepped rent (£25k for 2 years, then £30k for next 2 years etc.)
- Turnover rent (rent based on tenant’s turnover)
- Index-linked rent (rent based on agreed measure of inflation e.g. RPI)
- Open market rent review (ascertains rent based on comparable rpemises) - most common for FRI!!
Will commercial rents ever go down? If not, why?
Commercial leases almost always have an upwards only rent review (rent can only increase)
If market rents have fallen, rent will stay the same
If a landlord/tenant cannot agree new rent between themselves at a rent review, what 2 things will a specialist valuer consider when determining the new rent?
- The rent payable for comparable premises (of similar size/location)
- Terms of a hypothetical lease
What is a hypothetical lease?
An imaginary lease based on actual lease but assuming certain matters and disregarding others
What are assumptions of the hypothetical lease?
- Tenant has complied with all covenants under lease
- Landlord has complied with all covenants under lease (unfair!)
- On terms of actual lease (bar rent) including term remaining
- Premises has been repaired/rebuilt if damaged/destroyed
Unfair because rent will only go up - so to reward a landlord who has not complied with covenants with a higher rent is unfair
What are 3 disregards in a hypothetical lease?
- The effect of the tenant’s occupation on the rent
- Goodwill attached to tenant’s business
- Tenant’s improvements (other than obligations under lease)
Rationale: tenant should not be penalised with higehr rent for improvements to property or its footfall
Where is the new rent documented?
Rent review memorandum (short documen t signed by both parties)
When would a tenant have to pay further SDLT/LTT?
If the rent review is before 5th anniversary of the term commencement date
None to pay if after
What happens when the new rent is agreed some time after rent review date set out in lease?
The new rent is backdated to the rent review date
Tenant has to pay additional sum plus interest at rate set out in lease
What are the 2 aims of the Code for Leasing Business Premises (the Code)?
- Improve the quality and fairness of negotiations on lease terms
- Promote the issue of comprehensive heads of terms that should make the legal drafting process more efficient
To address unequal bargaining power of parties