Government Involvement Flashcards
Coverage Restrictions for High-Risk Drivers
In addition to higher premiums
- higher deducibles
- lower limits
- exclusion of certain coverages
Assigned Risk Plan (ARP) / Auto Insurance Plan (AIP)
Process
- Driver applies to and gets rejected by the voluntary market
- Driver applies to assigned risk plan (ARP)
- Driver is assigned to an insurer based on market share (by WP)
- Regulator set uniform rates
- Insurer fully services policy as if it was voluntarily written
- Insurer retains P/L
Ineligible for Assigned Risk Plan (ARP)
Reasons
- no valid driver’s license
- crime conviction within the past 36 months
- has a habit of breaking the law
Joint UW Association (JUA) / Reinsurance Facility (RF)
General process
- Driver applies for insurance in voluntary market
- Forwards to JUA serving center / RF
- Insurer shares P/L/expenses in proportion to their market share
- All insurer in state must share P/L/expenses even if they have not been assigned any risks
Joint UW Association (JUA) vs. Reinsurance Facility (RF)
- policy is serviced by the JUA servicing center vs being serviced by the insurer (RF)
- JUA sets the rates vs insurer sets the rates (RF)
Fair Access to Insurance Requirements (FAIR) Plans
Risks, rationale, operation, eligibility
Risks
- properties in areas susceptible to crime/riots
- insureds with high # of prior claims
Rationale
- property owners in urban areas couldn’t find coverage due to crime/riot risk
Operation
- policies serviced by a syndicate or private company
- P/L shared by all property insurers in state
Eligibility
- must have been denied by the private market
- not be vacant
- not be damaged/poorly maintained
- meet building codes
Reasons for Government Involvement in Insurance
FCC(ES):
- Filing needs that is not met by private insurance (ex. TRIA)
- When insurance is compulsory but not offered by the private market (ex. WC)
- Convenience (ex. NFIP) - when government may already have necessary structures in place
- Efficiency - agents commission removed –> lower ER –> lower premium
- Social purposes (ex. Medicare) - since private market is driven by profits, sometimes at the expense of social purposes
Levels of Government Involvement in Insurance
- Government as sole provider (social security, unemployment insurance)
- Government as provider in partnership with private insurance (NFIP)
- Government as a provider in competition with private insurance (WC competitive state fund)
Critera for Evaluating Government Insurance Programs
- Is the program welfare or insurance?
- Does it achieve social purposes?
- Is it efficient?
- Public acceptance?
- Is it necessary?
Crop Insurance (Partnership)
Process, coverage, pro/cons, mitigate cons
- government sets rates, acts as reinsurer, reimburses insurer expenses, subsidize premiums
- coverage: protect farmers against low yields and low prices
- pro:
- provide stability to important sector of economy
- con:
- encourages over-production and farming in risky areas
- private insurers make money while taxpayers subsidize the loss
- mitigate shortcomings:
- limit coverage
- shift loss-sharing more towards private insurers (less taxpayer burden)
Federal WC Programs
Programs, insureds, motivation
Federal Employees Compensation Act (FECA)
- For non-military government employees
- Costs are controlled because there is no litigation
Longshore & Harbor WC Act
- For non-seaman workers injured on or near naviagable waters
- Created because it wasn’t clear which state’s WC program would apply
Black Lung Benefit Act (BLBA)
- Wage replacement and medical benefits for totally disabled coal miners
- Created because of inadequate state compensation
State Government Involvement in WC Insurance
Mechanisms, benefits
- Partnership: state defines benefits but private insurers write policies
- More choice for consumer but still assured of minimum benefits
- Exclusive State Fund: state is sole provider, no private WC allowed
- No advertising or agent commissions –> pass savings to consumer
- Competitive State Fund: state competes with private insurers
- Competition help keeps costs down
Pros/Cons of State Funds
Advantages:
- No ads or commissions for state funds –> lower cost to consumers
- Provide coverage for high-risk customers
Disadvantages:
- Private markets are more innovative - competition drives prices down
- Private markets can operate more efficiently
State Mechanisms for Residual Markets
Motivation, mechanisms
Context: WC is mandatory but some states have no state fund or state fund is not an insurer of last resort
1. State assigns applicants to carriers based on WC market share
2. State uses a reinsurance pool (P&L shared among all insurers in proportion to market share)
3. State authorizes a joint U/W association (JUA) (P&L shared among all insurers in proportion to market share)
WC: State Funds vs Residual market
Similarities:
- Markets of last resort
- Lower expenses vs. private insurers (no commissions)w
Differences:
- Residual markets insures high risks rejected by voluntary market vs. state fund insurers all risks
- Residual markets requires proof of denial from voluntary market