Government Involvement Flashcards

1
Q

Coverage Restrictions for High-Risk Drivers

In addition to higher premiums

A
  • higher deducibles
  • lower limits
  • exclusion of certain coverages
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

Assigned Risk Plan (ARP) / Auto Insurance Plan (AIP)

Process

A
  • Driver applies to and gets rejected by the voluntary market
  • Driver applies to assigned risk plan (ARP)
  • Driver is assigned to an insurer based on market share (by WP)
    • Regulator set uniform rates
    • Insurer fully services policy as if it was voluntarily written
  • Insurer retains P/L
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

Ineligible for Assigned Risk Plan (ARP)

Reasons

A
  • no valid driver’s license
  • crime conviction within the past 36 months
  • has a habit of breaking the law
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

Joint UW Association (JUA) / Reinsurance Facility (RF)

General process

A
  • Driver applies for insurance in voluntary market
  • Forwards to JUA serving center / RF
  • Insurer shares P/L/expenses in proportion to their market share
  • All insurer in state must share P/L/expenses even if they have not been assigned any risks
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

Joint UW Association (JUA) vs. Reinsurance Facility (RF)

A
  • policy is serviced by the JUA servicing center vs being serviced by the insurer (RF)
  • JUA sets the rates vs insurer sets the rates (RF)
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

Fair Access to Insurance Requirements (FAIR) Plans

Risks, rationale, operation, eligibility

A

Risks
- properties in areas susceptible to crime/riots
- insureds with high # of prior claims

Rationale
- property owners in urban areas couldn’t find coverage due to crime/riot risk

Operation
- policies serviced by a syndicate or private company
- P/L shared by all property insurers in state

Eligibility
- must have been denied by the private market
- not be vacant
- not be damaged/poorly maintained
- meet building codes

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

Reasons for Government Involvement in Insurance

A

FCC(ES):
- Filing needs that is not met by private insurance (ex. TRIA)
- When insurance is compulsory but not offered by the private market (ex. WC)
- Convenience (ex. NFIP) - when government may already have necessary structures in place
- Efficiency - agents commission removed –> lower ER –> lower premium
- Social purposes (ex. Medicare) - since private market is driven by profits, sometimes at the expense of social purposes

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

Levels of Government Involvement in Insurance

A
  1. Government as sole provider (social security, unemployment insurance)
  2. Government as provider in partnership with private insurance (NFIP)
  3. Government as a provider in competition with private insurance (WC competitive state fund)
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

Critera for Evaluating Government Insurance Programs

A
  1. Is the program welfare or insurance?
  2. Does it achieve social purposes?
  3. Is it efficient?
  4. Public acceptance?
  5. Is it necessary?
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

Crop Insurance (Partnership)

Process, coverage, pro/cons, mitigate cons

A
  • government sets rates, acts as reinsurer, reimburses insurer expenses, subsidize premiums
  • coverage: protect farmers against low yields and low prices
  • pro:
    • provide stability to important sector of economy
  • con:
    • encourages over-production and farming in risky areas
    • private insurers make money while taxpayers subsidize the loss
  • mitigate shortcomings:
    • limit coverage
    • shift loss-sharing more towards private insurers (less taxpayer burden)
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

Federal WC Programs

Programs, insureds, motivation

A

Federal Employees Compensation Act (FECA)
- For non-military government employees
- Costs are controlled because there is no litigation

Longshore & Harbor WC Act
- For non-seaman workers injured on or near naviagable waters
- Created because it wasn’t clear which state’s WC program would apply

Black Lung Benefit Act (BLBA)
- Wage replacement and medical benefits for totally disabled coal miners
- Created because of inadequate state compensation

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

State Government Involvement in WC Insurance

Mechanisms, benefits

A
  • Partnership: state defines benefits but private insurers write policies
    • More choice for consumer but still assured of minimum benefits
  • Exclusive State Fund: state is sole provider, no private WC allowed
    • No advertising or agent commissions –> pass savings to consumer
  • Competitive State Fund: state competes with private insurers
    • Competition help keeps costs down
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

Pros/Cons of State Funds

A

Advantages:
- No ads or commissions for state funds –> lower cost to consumers
- Provide coverage for high-risk customers

Disadvantages:
- Private markets are more innovative - competition drives prices down
- Private markets can operate more efficiently

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

State Mechanisms for Residual Markets

Motivation, mechanisms

A

Context: WC is mandatory but some states have no state fund or state fund is not an insurer of last resort
1. State assigns applicants to carriers based on WC market share
2. State uses a reinsurance pool (P&L shared among all insurers in proportion to market share)
3. State authorizes a joint U/W association (JUA) (P&L shared among all insurers in proportion to market share)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

WC: State Funds vs Residual market

A

Similarities:
- Markets of last resort
- Lower expenses vs. private insurers (no commissions)w

Differences:
- Residual markets insures high risks rejected by voluntary market vs. state fund insurers all risks
- Residual markets requires proof of denial from voluntary market

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP)

Administration, purpose, government involvement

A
  • Administered by the federal emergency management agency (FEMA)
  • Main provider of primary residential flood coverage
  • Flood coverage is unaffordable if private insurer charges actuarially sound rates –> NFIP fills a unmet need in the marketplace
  • Partnership with government –> private insurer services policies
17
Q

NFIP Policy Goals

A
  • Provide access to primary flood insurance (by transfering some financial risk to federal government)
  • Mitigate and reduce flood risk through floodplain management standards
18
Q

NFIP Objectives

A

RASH
- Risk-based premiums
- Affordability
- Sustainability (premiums covering claims+expenses)
- High participation rate

19
Q

NFIP vs Traditional Private Insurance

Including non-insurance goals

A

Social goals - provides coverage to high-risk customers who cannot find affordable coverage in the private market
Non insurance goals:
- provide flood risk information via flood plain
- require that communities follow land use and building standards for participation in order to NFIP
- reduce the need for post flood aid
- protect lenders against mortgage defaults due to uninsured flood losses

20
Q

Where is Flood Insurance Mandatory?

A
  • for property owners in special flood hazard areas (SFHAs) with a federally backed mortgage
  • when a mortgage lender requires participation (even outside SFHA)
21
Q

NFIP Rates not Risk-Based / Actuarially Sound

A
  1. Pre-FIRM (Flood Insurance Risk Maps): properties built or improved before 12/31/1974 or before first flood insurance risk map (FIRM) for their community
  2. Newly mapped: properties mapped to a special flood hazard area (SFHA) on/after 4/1/2015
  3. Grandfathered: properties originally built in compliance with FIRM (even if they mapped to higher-priced class later)
22
Q

Ways Private Insurer Involvement in Flood Insurance

A
  • Service Policies (marketing, selling, writing, claims management)
  • Assume a portion of risk as a reinsurer
  • Assume full risk as primary insurer
23
Q

Private Insurer Servicing Arrangements within NFIP

A

Direct servicing agent (DSA) (13%)
- Sells NFIP policies (on behalf of FEMA) to property owners that want to buy flood insurance directly from NFIP

Write-your-own (WYO) (87%)
- Private insurer write and service NFIP policies
- Private insurers compensated for their service

24
Q

NFIP Risk Management Tools

A

Private Reinsurance
- purchased from a group of reinsurers with each bearing part of the risk

Capital Markets
- reinsurance backed by catastrophe bonds
- risk transferred to capital market investor who buy the bond
- investors pay a certain percentage of the loss from a large scale event

25
Q

NFIP Pros/Cons of Using Private Reinsurance

A

Advantages:
- Federal emergency management agency (FEMA) will know some of the cost up front
- Reduces volatility of losses

Disadvantages:
- Expected long-term cost will increase becasue reinsurers must be compensated for taking on the risk (profit margin)
- NFIP may have insufficient funds to pay out claims because of paying reinsurance premiums
- NFIP may have insufficient funds to fulfill other goals and objectives after paying reinsurance premiums

26
Q

Why Private Insurer Considers Flood Uninsurable?

A
  • Catastrophic nature of flooding
  • Pricing difficulties – data volatile year to year
  • Adverse selection – only high-risk customers buy flood coverage
  • Affordability – unaffordable for high-risk customers who need it the most
27
Q

Issues / Barriers to Flood Insurance with Solutions

A

Private insurer cannot compete with NFIP subsidized rates
- reform NFIP rate structure so prices match what a private insurer would charge

Private insurer don’t have credible flood data, FEMA cannot release NFIP data
- remove personal information from NFIP data and then make data public

Coverage must be “at least as broad” as NFIP- hard to determine
- replace “at least as broad” with “comply with state regulations” - easier to determine

Low participation rates - insurers need higher participation rates to diversify their portfolio
- require all SFHA properties to buy flood insurance, not just those with a federally-backed mortgage

28
Q

Effect of Private Insurer in Flood Insurance

A

Good for insured:
- insureds have more choices for coverages and higher limits
- low-risk insured may be charged with lower rates vs NFIP

Bad for NFIP
- NFIP will experience adverse selection. Low risk insured will go to private insurers, leaving higher risk insureds to NFIP
- if more insureds choose private insurers, NFIP will have less money to pay for flood mapping or floodplain management

29
Q

Terrorist Risk Insurance Act (TRIA)

Motivations

A
  • Fill unmet need - private insurers/reinsurers withdrew coverage after 9/11
  • Convenience - government can set up program quickly and work with the Treasury regarding compensation
  • Social purpose - lessen economic disruption from lack of terrorism insurance availability (ex. new construction projects couldn’t get require insurance)
30
Q

TRIA Goals

And how they are met

A

Stabilize private markets
- Government provides reinsurance over a certain threshold

Protect consumers by ensuring availability and affordability
- TRIA requires insurers that offer commercial insurance covered by TRIA to provide terrorism coverage

Preserve state regulation of insurance
- States can still regulate rates

31
Q

TRIA Loss Sharing Criteria

A

Certification
- Terrorism must be certified (by the SOT, DOHS, AG)
- Losses 5M or more in the U.S.

Federal Government Threshold
- Aggregate insurance industry losses 200M or more for federal assistance to start

Coverage - only commercial P&C

Deductible - 20% of direct commercial EP

Coinsurance - insurer pays 20% above deductible / government pays 80%

Federal Government Limit - 100B
- Insurer not required to provide coverage above this point

Surcharge
- If aggregate losses 37.5B or less, SOT must add surcharges (% of TRIA premiums) to recoup 140% of federal coverage

32
Q

Elements of Insurable Risk / Insurability of TRIA

A

C-MAC
Credible - need a large # of insureds and events to make losses predictible
- not credible - low # of events, coverage not mandatory
- solution: use a terrorism model (similar to other low-freq high-sev events)

Measurable - losses must be definite & measurable
- yes - terrorism event can be measured in dollars

Accidental - losses must be foruitous (happen by chance) and accidental
- not accidental - terrorist attacks are planned

Catastrophic - losses must not be catastrophic
- depends on how concentrated the insurer is