Gender Flashcards
Kohlbergs theory of gender development
Kohlberg’s theory of gender development is based on Piaget model, arguing that gender development occurs alongside general development in thinking that comes with age.
Kohlberg- Gender identityStage
- 18 months – 3 years
- The child identifies themself as male or female and can categorise others as male or female.
- can apply gender labels
- However, the child does not recognise the stability of gender, * I’m going to be a daddy when I’m older”.
Kohlberg - Gender Stability
- 3 – 5 years
- The child realises that their gender is stable, i.e. that they will remain the same gender for life.
- However, they may not apply this same stability to others.
- For example, if a woman does some typically male activity or cuts her hair short, the child may think she is now a man.
Kolhberg- Gender Constancy
- 6 years
- The child realises that theirs and other people’s gender is permanent and constant over time and in different situations despite superficial changes.
- For example, if a woman cuts her hair short, the child understands that she is still a woman.
- They seek out and imitate role models who match their gender. For example, a boy may take an interest in football if he identifies with his father who is also interested in football.
Define sex
biological differences between males and females
chromosomes, hormones and anatomy- innate via nature
define gender
persons psychological status
attitudes, roles and behavior associate with being male or female- influenced by society
nurture
development of sex role stereotypes
majority of people view their sex and gender in accordance
expectations and perceptions that individuals that society have to what is appropriate behavior for each sex
results in a justification of discriminatory practices on the basis of sex
Studies can be used to support the social learning theory of gender
AGENTS OF SOCIALISATION- parents of media - support and sustain sterotypes
define gender dysphoria
biologically prescribed sex does not reflect feelings inside and the gender they identity
define androgyny
describes someone who displays a balance of both masculine and feminine characteristics
viewed from personality and appearance
measuring androgyny
Bems Sex Role Inventory
scale presents 20 characteristics that would be commonly identified as masculine (competitive and aggressive)
20 that would be typically feminine (tender and gentle)
20 neutral traits
required to rate them self on a seven point scale 1-7
strength of BSRI
valid and reliable
developed asking 50 men and women to rate 200 traits in terms of desirability for men and women
highest scores in each category became the 20
study piloted with over 1000 students and results corresponded with the participants own description of gender identity = validity
follow up study found similar results =test retest reliability
weakness of androgyny
well being
Bems emphasis on individuals that androgynous individuals are more psychologically healthy
assumption has been challenged
people that show greater proportion of masculine traits are better adjusted as these are more highly valued in some societies
= Bems research may not take account of social and cultural context
weakness of androgyny
questionnaires
BSRI questionaire relied on understanding of their personality and behaviour that may not necessarily have
gender is hypohetical construct which is open to interpretation
scoring is subjective and interpretation may differ
social desirability
biological explanations of gender dyphoria
BST Kruijver study
- studied male to female transgerders
- studied bed nucleus of stria terminalis
- found number of neurones in male to female transgenders were similar to biological women
- (men have half as women )
biological explanations of gender dyphoria
BST Zhoi
- study male to female transgenders
- studied the volume of the bed nucleus of stria terminalis
- (40% larger in males)
- post mortem study showed the size of the male to female transgenders was similar to be similar to biological female
genetic factors for gender dysphoria
Coolidge
- studied 157 pairs of twins for evidence of GD using DSM-4
- 2.3% prevalence rate
- 62% due to genetic variance - suggests its heritable
genetic factors for gender dysphoria
Heylens
- studied 23 MZ twins and 21 DZ
- one of each pair had GD
- 39% concordance rate of MZ twins
- no conconrodance rate for DZ twins
- suggests of genetic factor
Biological theory of gender dysphoria -evaluation
cause and effect
- Chung et al. (2002) stated that the differences in sexes of the BSCt did not appear until adulthood.
- So the BSCt differences could be the result of gender development, not the cause.
biological theory of gender dysphoria- evaluation
twins studies
- twins studies did not hold a high concordance rate
- difficult to seperate the effects of nature and nurture
- twins may influence each other and environmental condtions experienced will be very similar
- twin studies sample are very small - limiting effectiveness of making generalisations to wider population
biological theory of gender dysphoria
a03
reductionsim
- reduced complex conditons into simple genetics
- contributing factors such as psychodynamic and socail factors may be obscured or ignored
- interactionalist approach may be more relevant
cogntive explanation of gender dysphoria
- acknowledges indidivdual differences
- dual pathwat theory
1. acknowledge development of gender schemas- direct appropriate attitufdes and behaviour as part of normal development
2. how childs gender and attitudes are affected by own activity, persoanl interests may become more dominant than gender identity- turns gender schema (results in a non sex- typed schema) - results in androgynous behaviour and more flexible attiutides to gender - possible formational of opposite identification
psychoanalytical approach for gender dysphoria
A03
gender bias
- only offers an explanation for development of GID in males
- females do not feel same pressure to take on role of mother in absence of father
- subjective nature- reduces scientific credibility
- beta bias
role of chromosomes
- born with 23 chromosomes
- 23rd chromosomes determine sex
- Male XY
- Female XX
- Y chromosome of males develop testes by androgens (male sex hormones)
role of hormones
tesosterone
- male sex hormone
- development of of testes at 8 foetal weeks
- links to agression
- Poll et al - inject female rats with testosterone - become more physically and sexually aggresssive
AO3 - contradictory evidence
* double blind study by Tricker et al
* 43 men given weekly injections of tesosterone or placebo
* no significant differences in agression post 10 weeks
+
* animals limit extent of generalisability
role of hormones oestrogeon
- female sex hormone that determines sexual characteristics and menustration
- experience heightned emotionality and irritability during menstrual cycle PMS
A03
* questions effect of oestrogeon levels on woman moods and that PMS sterotypes female experience and emotions
* femminists say that it is a social construct and no biological fact
* makes men seems more superior (alpha bias)
*
a03
evidence supporting role of chromosomes and hormones
Dabbs et al
* in prison population male offenders with highest levels of testosterone were more likely ot commit violent or sexually motivated crimes
Goozen et al
* transgender individuals having hormone treatment
* injected with hormones of opposite sex
* male to female showed decreased sign of afression
* female to male showed opposite
= exert some influence on gender related behaviour
role of hormone
oxcytocin
- women produce large quantities during labour - sitmulates lactation
- reduces stress hormone cortisol
- facilitates bonding
- women produce more than men - popular sterotype that men are less interested in initmaacy
- sexes produce equal amount in kissing and sexual intercourse