Freedom of Speech Flashcards
Overbreadth
A law that burdens a substantial amount of speech or other conduct constitutionally protected by the 1st amendment is overbroad and therefore void. “Facially invalid”
Vaugeness
Statute is void for vagueness if it fails to provide a person of ordinary intelligence with fair notice of what is prohibited
Freedom not to speak
Valid i.e. kids right not to recite pledge of allegiance.
Monuments on Public Property
Government Speech even if donated by private person
Specialty License plates
Government speech and state may refuse proposed plates based on content.
Political Campaign Contributions
Statutes limiting campaign contributions are subject to intermediate scrutiny and must be closely drawn.
Contributions to Candidates
Gov may limit contributions to individual candidates b/c excessive contribution may lead to corruption.
Contributions to Political Parties
Gove can limit
Campaign Expenditures
Restrictions on campaign expenditures are subject to SS.
Public Forum
Sidewalks, streets, and parks. Restrictions must be:
1) Content-Neutral on subject and viewpoint
2) Narrowly tailored to serve a significant governmental interest
3) Leave open ample alternative channels for communication
Injunctions
Content Based = SS
Content Neutral = test is whether it burdens no more speech than is necessary to achieve an important gov interest.
Limited Public Forums and Nonpublic Forums
Not historically linked with speech, but opened for specific speech activity (i.e. school gym). Regulations are valid if they are:
1) Viewpoint neutral
2) Reasonably related to a legitimate gov interest
nonpublic forum = airport or military base.
Person’s private Property
Gov regulation will rarely be upheld, even in content-based restrictions.
Obscenity & Child Porn
Neither are protected by 1st Amendment
Obscenity Test
1) Appeals to the prurient interest
2) Depicts sexual conduct in a patently offensive way
3) Lacks serious literary, artistic, political, or scientific value
Prohibited Activities with Obscene Material
Cant sell, distribute, or exhibit obscene material. you CAN have it in your own home due to fundamental right to privacy.
Obscenity and Land Use
can zone to restrict locations of certain adult establishments but you can’t do it to ban them completely.
Child porn
Sale, Distribution, and even private possession of child porn is prohibited, even if the material would not be obscene if it involved adults.
Simulated Child Porn
Using young looking adults to depict kids may not be banned as child porn. If kids are used in it, and then young looking adults are used for the sex scenes, you can be criminalized if it’s presented as actual child porn.
Violence
Can be constitutionally regulated even if its not considered obscene.
Incitement to Violence
State may orbit speech that advocates the use of force or unlawful action if:
1) the speech is directed to inciting or producing imminent lawless action and
2) It is likely to incite or product such action
Fighting Words
Words by their very nature are likely to incite an immediate breach of peace