Free Speech (1st) Flashcards
Speech Laws - General
Content Based (SM or VP): SS unless less protected
Content Neutral: T/P/M reg. narrowly tailored to important gov’t int + adq. alt’s left open
Less Protected Speech
PICOG Profane Incite Illegal Act Commercial Obscene Gov't EEE on job
Less Protected Speech - Profane
protected, but not in schools or free broadcast media
Less Protected Speech - Incite Illegal Act
not protected
sub. likelihood of immediate illegal act + speech directed at causing it
Less Protected Speech - Commercial
false/deceptive/illegal not protected
can also ban professionals from trade names and in person attorney solicitation for profit
Less Protected Speech - Obscene
not protected (1) appeal to prurient interest (community) + (2) patently offensive under law + (3) no redeeming value (national)
- Kid porn banned regardless of obscenity
- Can regulate location of adult stores
- Can seize biz assets after obscenity conviction
- Can’t ban private ownership of obscene material except kid porn
Less Protected Speech - Gov’t EEE on Job
Not protected (but can’t challenge gov’t speech)
Protected Speech
Reporters truthful, legally obtained reporting (+ illegal if public interest and media didn’t participate)
Anonymous
Prior Constraints on Speech
SS (most comply w/ order to challenge)
License ok if (1) imp. reason, (2) clear criteria, (3) procedural safeguards and (4) no discretion
Vague/Overbroad Speech Regulation
Can’t tell what is prohibited / regulates more than allowed (unconstitutional: fighting words laws)
Symbolic Speech Regulation
OK if (1) important interest unrelated to suppression + (2) impact no greater than necessary to achieve
- flag burn ok, draft card not
- cross burn ok unless threat intent
- cont limits ok, exp limits not
Speech Forums
Public (open to speech) Designated Public (chooses to open) Limited Public (open to some groups/topics) Non-Public (closed) Private
Speech - Public and Designated Public
Normal (Content: SS, Neutral: TPM narrowly tailored to imp. gov’t int. + adq. alt’s open)
Speech - Limited Public and Non-Public
Viewpoint neutral and RBR
Private
No 1st Amd. Rights