Fourth Amendment Flashcards
What does the Fourth Amendment protect citizens from?
Unreasonable searches and seizures
When does a seizure occur?
When, under the totality of circumstances, a RP would not feel free to decline officer’s request or to terminate the encounter
An arrest must be based on…
Probable cause
What is probable cause?
trustworthy facts or knowledge sufficient for RP to believe suspect committed or is committing crime
When is an arrest W required?
NOT for arresting someone in public place
But for non-emergency arrest of an individual in his home
What do police need to arrest you and compel you to come to the police station either for finger printing or interrogation (station house detention)?
probable cause
but don’t need PC to ASK to come to station
Another word for Terry stop?
Investigatory detentions
To briefly detain a person, what must police have?
- reasonable suspicion of
- supported by articulable facts
- of criminal activity
(hunch is never enough)
PC not necessary
Whether the police have reasonable suspicion depends on….
the totality of circumstances
When may police stop an automobile?
when they have at least reasonable suspicion that the law has been violated
Who has standing to sue for wrongful SEIZURE when car is STOPPED (but not for SEARCH)?
driver AND passengers
When is reasonable suspicion NOT needed to stop a car? (the exception)
checkpoint roadblocks:
- OK so long as neutrally applied (stop every car or every 4th car)
- OK for DUI (but not to check for only drugs) and border crossing
Traffic stops and police dogs: during routine traffic stops, is a sniff by dog a search?
No, so long as police do not extend the stop beyond the time needed to issue a ticket or conduct normal inquiries
Traffic stop and police dogs: What if during a traffic stop, dog alerts to presence of drugs?
Can form basis for PC for a search
What’s needed to search?
PC
Can police use drug sniffing dog directly outside home of suspected drug dealer?
Not w/o PC
Model for search & seizure Q (5 steps)
1) gov’t conduct?
2) REP (as to place searched or item seized)? (this gives you STANDING)
3) police have valid search W?
4) if W invalid, officer have good faith defense to save defective search W?
5) if W invalid AND no good faith defense OR police never had any W at all, EXCEPTIONS to W req?
STEP 1: Gov’t conduct: Whose actions count?
- publicly paid police- on OR off duty
- any private individual acting at direction of public police
- NOT privately paid police unless deputized w/ power to arrest (e.g. of privately paid police: store security guards, subdivision police, campus police)
STEP 2: REP (standing): automatic categories of standing
1) OWN premises searched
2) LIVE on premises searched, regardless of ownership interest (e.g. grandchild living at gparents’ home)
**3) OVERNIGHT GUESTS of owner of place searched
STEP 2: REP (standing): important “sometimes” category
OWN PROPERTY seized (e.g. backpack, purse)
standing ONLY IF D has REP in item or area searched (e.g. you don’t have REP in another person’s person)
STEP 2: REP (standing): no standing categories (5)
No REP and therefore no standing for anything you HOLD OUT TO THE PUBLIC (seizure of these things implicates no right of privacy)
1) sound of VOICE
2) style of HANDWRITING
3) PAINT on outside of car
4) ACCOUNT RECORDS held by bank
5) LOCATION OF YOUR CAR on public street or in driveway (police CAN tail your car)
BUT installation of GPS device on suspect’s car is a search, so need PC and W
6) anything that can be seen across the OPEN FIELDS (anything NOT curtilage, like rural property)
7) anything that can be seen from flying over in PUBLIC AIRSPACE
8) ODORS emanating from luggage or car
9) GARBAGE set out on CURB for collection
(leaning against house - REP)
STEP 3: Police have VALID search W? 2 reqs
PC and particularity
STEP 3: Police have VALID search W? PC standard
fair probability that contraband or evidence of crime will be found in area searched
STEP 3: Police have VALID search W? Particularity standard
W must state w/ particularity
- the place to be searched AND
- the things to be seized
STEP 3: Police have VALID search W? Warrants and use of informants: If officer’s affidavit or PC is based on informant info, its sufficiency is determined by…
And what are relevant factors?
the totality of circumstances
STEP 3: Police have VALID search W? Warrants and use of informants: factors relevant to determining sufficiency
informant’s credibility AND basis of knowledge
STEP 3: Police have VALID search W? Warrants and use of informants: Can valid W be based on anonymous informant’s tip?
yes, IN PART, but can’t be ONLY based on the anonymous tip