Forensics Flashcards
What is the top down approach?
When profilers have pre-existing conceptual categories of offenders in their minds.
How does the top down approach work?
- There are pre-existing categories of organised and disorganised offenders
- Analysis of the crime, and the data is put into patterns.
- Categorisation of offender as organised/disorganised (crime assessment) and creation of hypothesis of the probable characteristics of the offender
What are the steps of top-down profiling?
- profiling inputs (description of the crime scene, info about victim, details of crime)
- decision process models (puts the data into patterns, e.g. location +time factors, type of murder)
- crime assessment (organised vs disorganised offender)
- criminal profile (hypothesis about the background of criminal, how the criminal may respond to investigative efforts)
- crime assessment (report is given to the investigators and people matching this are evaluated. If no suspect is identified then goes back to step 2)
- apprehension (effectively an evaluation to make sure everything was valid)
What significant thing did top-down profilers do?
Drew upon data gathered from in depth interviews with 36 sexually motivated serial killers e.g. ted bundy, Richard Ramirez
Give a brief overview of the bottom-up approach to profiling
The UK method involves using the objective evidence to predict things about the criminal (s), rather than using subjective methods like the FBI. It was developed by Canter who caught the ‘railway rapist’; his model is known as the five factor model.
What is Canter’s bottom up profiling method called?
The five factor model
What are the 5 steps of Canter’s five factor model?
Interpersonal coherence Time and place Criminal characteristics Criminal career Forensic awareness
What is interpersonal coherence? (bottom up)
Consistency between the way offenders interact with their victims and others in every day life
What is time and place? (bottom up)
The time and location of an offender’s crime will communicate something about their own place of residence/employment
What are criminal characteristics? (bottom up)
Characteristics about the offenders can help to classify them which helps investigations
What is criminal career? (bottom up)
Crimes tend to be committed in similar fashion by offenders and can provide indication of how their criminal activity will develop
What is forensic awareness? (bottom up)
Offenders who show an understanding of a police investigation are likely to have had previous encounters with the criminal justice system
What is the difference between a marauder criminal and a commuter criminal?
Marauder does local crime, commuter travels to commit their crime
What is the ativistic form theory?
An early biological explanation which proposed that criminals are a subspecies of genetic throwbacks that can conform to the rules of modern society. Such individuals are distinguishable by particular facial and cranial characteristics
What 2 criminologists are important when we consider the atavistic form?
Franz Gall proposed phreonology (the shape of your head corresponds to personality)
Cesare Lombroso- criminals are genetic throwbacks with atavistic features
What characteristics are criminals supposed to have?
Strong, prominent jaws
High cheekbones
Dark skin
Extra toes/nipples/figures
What characteristics are sexual deviants supposed to have?
Glinting eyes
Swollen, fleshy lips
What did Cesare Lombroso study and what were his findings?
He did a study of facial and cranial features of almost 4000 living and dead criminals in Italy which supported his theory. However, a lot of Africans were in Italian prisons because they migrated there and their characteristics fitted his e.g. dark skin
What was the idea of eugenics?
That genetically ‘unfit’ people should be prevented from breeding
What is an organised offender?
Planned and targeted victim, violent fantasies may be acted out. The offender is usually intelligent, and socially and sexually competent.
What is a disorganised offender?
Unplanned and random selection of the victim. The offender usually leaves evidence at the crime scene like blood, semen, fingerprints or the weapon.
What is geographical profiling?
Analyses locations and connections between crime scenes
What is circle theory?
Cantern proposed that most offenders have a spatial mindset, committing crimes within an imaginary circle. This explains marauders.
What is criminal geographic targeting?
A computerised system developed that has a formula which uses data about time, distance and movement and produces a map called a ‘jeopardy surface’ which shows likely closeness to the residence of the offender
What were the three types of criminals according to Lombroso?
- Born criminals, who were the atavistic type
- Insane criminals, who are mentally ill
- Criminaloids, offenders whose mental characteristics predisposed them to criminal behaviour under the right circumstances
How does brain damage correlate to personality change within crime?
Brain damage can be related to offending behaviour.
- 60% of US prisoners have a brain injury, in comparison with around 8% of the general population
- Phineas Gage had catastrophic damage to his prefrontal cortex and recovered physically, but his personality changed from a family man to a violent drunk- this shows the importance of PFC in our personalities
What did Raine study and what did he find?
He compared 27 psychopaths with 32 non psychopaths and found that there was an 18% volume reduction in the amygdala (with a thinning of the cortex) and an 11% reduction of grey matter of the PFC in people with APD
Why are Raine’s findings significant?
He proved that the PFC is related to our personalities
The amydala is responsible for emotions (empathy, remorse guilt) so the fact that APD people had a smaller amygdala highlights how it is involved with the disorder
What are the 2 genes that have been identified to relate to crime?
MAOA and CDH13
How is CDH13 linked to criminality?
It is believed that a high activity of CDH13 interrupts the building and strengthening of some neural networks during their development. Abnormal form of this gene is linked to offending
What is the monamine hypothesis?
The monamines (seratonin, dopamine, noradrenaline) are received and broken down by enzyme MAOA which is controlled by the gene MAOA.
If you lack MAOA gene you’ll be unable to reduce levels of monamines at the normal rate.
Lower activity of MAOA leads to increased levels of monamines, supported by Virkunen’s research
What did Brunner research and what were his findings?
He studied a Dutch family in relation to violence and genetic abnormality. He found that the violent males had a faulty MAOA gene, and they also had a borderline mental retardation syndrome.
What did Virkunen et al. find?
That criminals whose crime was compulsive had lower levels of seratonin then violent criminals whose crime was planned.
What did Mendrick research?
He was responsible for looking at adoption studies. He compared if they were criminal with different types of parent.
How are biological explanations deterministic, and how is this used?
They are deterministic because it implies that the individual does not have the capacity to control their innate criminal urges; this was used in the court to defend crime. It was used by a criminals defence called Stanley Waldrop but they had to also show history of an abusive childhood to be considered less responsible. This supports the idea of diathesis stress, a more holistic approach. It is hard for some people with a genetic
How are there real world applications of the biological explanation?
Now we understand that an unnusual amount of neurotransmitter levels play a role, we can treat these with drug interventions. SSRI can increase seratonin levels, which could also have good impacts on the individuals mental health. Although, it is reductionist, as childhood experiences could have caused this, so we could help people by investing in counselling as well, which would have long term economical impacts.
What is Eysenck’s theory based on?
Social and psychological life experiences. He believes offending is due to a criminal personality which is biological in origin (innate biological basis) due to what type of nervous system we inherit
What are the three levels of Eysenck’s theory that he believed led to offending?
Biological- type of nervous system we inherit
Psychological- criminal personality type
Social- responses to socialisation (reward and punishment)
These collectively lead to offending behaviour
What are the three dimensions of personality proposed by Eysenck?
Extraversion to Introversion
Neuroticism to stability
Psychoticism to normality
What is the criminal personality type?
Neurotic extravert