Forensic Psychology Flashcards
what does profiling usually involve?
careful scrutiny of a crime scene and analysis to generate hypotheses about the probable characteristics of the offender
what is the top down approach also known as?
the american approach
when and where did profiling orignate from?
FBI’s Behavioural Science Unit in the 1970s
how did the FBI develop profiling?
the BSU drew upon data gathered from in-depth interviews with 36 sexually-motivated murderes including Ted Bundy and Charles Mason - concluded that the data could be catagorised into organised and disorganised crimes/murders
what does modus operandi mean?
a signiture
what is a signiture?
a particular set of social and psychological characteristics that relate to the individual
what are the characteristics of organised offenders?
show evidence of pre planning the crime
victim targetted
high degree of control
may operate with surgical percision
little evidence left
tend to have above average IQ
skilled, proffessional occupation
socially and sexually competent
usually married, maybe children
what are the characteristics of disorganised offenders?
little evidence of planning
may be spontaneous
crime scene tends to reflect impulsive nature of the attack
body usually left at scene
little control
tend to have lower than average IQ
unskilled work or unemployed
often have history of sexual dysfunction and failed relationships
tend to live alone
often live relatively close to crime scene
what are the characteristics of an organised crime scene?
planned
victim targeted
control including restraints
aggression before death
body hidden or moved
weapon and evidence absent
what are the chracteristics of a disorganised crime?
spontaneous
victim usually known by the offender
little control
sexual acts before death
body not hidden/left at the crime scene
evidence present
what are the 4 stages of constructing an FBI profile?
- Data Assimilation
- Crime Scene Classification
- Crime Reconstruction
- Profile Generation
what is Data Assimilation?
reviewing evidence
what is Crime Scene Classification?
deciding whether crime is organised or disorganised
what is Crime reconstruction?
hyptheses in terms of sequence of events, behavious of the victim etc
what are the strengths of the top down approach?
research support = some validity
David Canter et al (2004)
can be adapted to other crimes, e.g., burglary
Tina Meketa (2017)
what did David Canter et al (2004) do regarding the top-down approach?
conducted analysis of 100 different US murders each committed by a different serial killer
used ‘smallest space analysis’ technique that indentifies correlations across different samples of behaviour. used to assess to co-occurance of 39 aspects of serial killings (torture, restraints, attempt to conceal body etc)
revealed that there does seem to be a subset of features of many serial killings which matched FBI’s typology
what did Tina Meketa (2017) do regarding the top-down approach?
reported that top-down profiling led to an 85%increase in unsolved burglary’s across 3 different US states
added 2 new categories alongside organised & disorganised : interpersonal and opportunistic
suggests that top down profiling has wider application than originally assumed
what is the interpersonal category?
offender usually knows their victim and steals something of significance
what is the opportunistic category?
offender is young and inexperienced
what are the limitations of the top-down approach?
variety of combinations of both organised and disorganised offenders can occur at ay given murder scene
Maurice Godwin (2002)
flawed evidence
based on the principle of behavioural consistency that serial offenders have characteristic ways of working
Walter Mischel (1968)
what did Maurice Godwin (2002) do regarding the top-down approach?
argues that is is difficult to classify killers as one type
a killer may have multiple contrasting characteristics such as high intelligence and sexual competence but commits a spontaneous muder leaving the victims body
typology is probably more of a continuum