Forensic Psych Test #3 Flashcards
How is a death sentence considered
- When a homicide is committed a prosecutor is given some “guided” discretion as to whether or not a murder under “special circumstances” becomes a capital case
- The defense attorney’s job is to convince the prosecutor not to seek the death penalty
Examples of aggravating factors
- Murder of a law enforcement official
- Murder after kidnapping
- Torture
- Defendant is dangerous or a risk to others
- History of violence
- Murder for hire
- Murder of two or more people
Why was the death penalty outlawed
Furman V. Georgia in 1972 outlawed the death penalty because its arbitrary and discriminatory application qualified it as “cruel and unusual punishment”
What is the role of forensic psychologists in death penalty cases
- A competency to stand trial assessment
- Assess pretrial publicity to assess knowledge and bias in the case - could request a change of venue
Death Qualification Procedure
Prior to the trial the prospective jurors are asked if they are so opposed to capitol punishment that they could not vote for the death penalty under any circumstances regardless of the facts
Bifurcated trial
A trial with two phases
What evidence can be introduced in a bifurcated trial and when can it be introduced
Evidence that was not allowed during the guilt determination phase because it would be deemed prejudicial may be allowed during the sentencing phase
Examples of mitigating factors
- No significant prior criminal record
- Youth of defendant
- Duress, coercion, or domination by another
- Extreme emotion
- Limited understanding of the consequences of the act
- Mental retardation
Reasons a defendant can appeal his or her sentence
- If a defendant feels he or she was inadequately represented
- If exculpatory evidence was uncovered after the trial
Describe the law regarding the execution of mentally retarded individuals
- 18 states did not allow it as of 2002 (12 of them do not have a death penalty)
- Atkins V. Virginia stated that it was cruel and unusual punishment
Know the research on the deterrent effects of the death penalty
-States with the death penalty have the highest homicide rates
Brutilization effect: Human life is held less sacred
Most often used means of excecution in the US
- Lethal injection (36 states)
- Electrocution (10 states)
- Gas Chamber (5 states)
Know the reasons that can be used in some states to excuse criminal behavior
- Legal insanity
- Duress
Legal insanity
-A person who is unaware of the meaning of his or her act and should not be held criminally responsible for them
-Duress
-An individual acted under duress when a person threatened him or her with death or serious bodily harm
Mens rea
- “Guilty mind”
- Is only possible if there was free will and intent to do harm
GBMI
- Guilty but mentally ill
- “attempts” to provide treatment within a correctional setting for defendants with psychiatric disorders
NGRI
Not guilty by reason of insanity
-Usually committed to a psychiatric hospital and will stay until they no longer have psychiatric problems
Malingering
The conscious fabrication or gross exaggeration of physical or psychological symptoms done in order to achieve external goals such as avoiding prison
Earliest Insanity Defense
- 13th century England
- “Wild beast test” - based on the belief that individuals who had no more control over their behavior than a wild beast should not be held responsible for their behavior
M’Naghten Rule
- 1843
- Person was suffering from “a defect of reason, arising from a disease of the mind”
- Cognitive test of insanity : emphasizes the quality of the person’s thought processes and perceptions at the time of the crime
- Criticized for its narrow focus on people’s cognitive knowledge
- Used in about half of the U.S.
Irresistible Impulse Standard
- Temporary supplement to the M’Naghten rule
- Stated that even if the person know right from wrong, his or her free will was so destroyed or overruled that the person lost power to choose between right and wrong