Forensic ⚠️ Flashcards
what a person should have to make the appropriate and best decision regarding his health?
To make any appropriate and best decision, the person should have mental capacity
what is Mental Capacity?
Ability to use & understand information to:
1) Make decision
2) Communicate any decision
Who is considered capacious or competent?
A person with normal healthy mind and brain function who can generally understand what decision he/she needs to make and its comnsequnces is consisted capacious or competent
Who should assess a doubtful capacity?
A psychiatrist or psychologist examine:
- Does the person have an impairment of the mind or brain? (It doesn’t matter whether this impairment is temporary or permanent at the time of decision)
__________
- Does the person have a general understanding of:
a) What decision they need to make and why they need to make it?
b) Consequences of making, or not making, this decision?
____________
- Is the person able to understand, retain, use and weigh up information relevant to this decision?
____________
- Can the person communicate their decision (by talking, using sign language or any other means)?
what is the definition of Incapacious Person (A person lacks capacity)?
A person whose mind is impaired & unable to give a decision
what are examples of Incapacious Person?
- Mental health conditions e.g. schizophrenia & bipolar disorder & dementia
- Severe learning disabilities
- Brain damage from a stroke or other brain injury
- Physical or mental conditions that cause confusion, drowsiness & consciousness loss
- Intoxication caused by drugs or alcohol misuse
what are the charachters of Incapacious Person?
Someone with such impairment is unable to make a decision if he/she cannot:
- Understand information about the decision
- Remember that information
- Use that information to make a decision
- Communicate their decision by talking, using sign language or any other means
Who can give or refuse consent in case of lack of capacity?
In case of lack of capacity, adult partner, legal custodian or adult family member who is responsible for the incompetent patient can give or refuse consent
what is the definition of Consent?
It is voluntary agreement, compliance or permission
autonomy of consent
Is the patient’s right to decide whether to agree (consent) or to refuse (refusal) of certain clinical examination or treatment
Importance of consent
- To examine, treat or operate upon a patient without consent is assault (battery) in law, even if it is beneficial and done in good faith
- If a doctor fails to give the required information to the patient before taking consent to a particular operation/treatment, he may be charged for negligence
Elements of Consent
1) Competence (Capacity)
2) Voluntariness
3) Disclosure (Informed)
what is the consenting age? and how gives consent for those who are under this age?
- more than or equal to 21 years (age of full civil rights in Egyptian law)
- For a child, or patient of unsound mind, guardian or local authority designated to care for the child can give consent
what are the types of consent?
Implied & Expressed
Implied consent
- When patient presents himself at doctor’s clinic, this implies agreement to be examined
- This does not imply to procedures more complex than inspection, palpation, percussion and auscultation
what do further examinations like rectal, vaginal examinations require?
Further examinations:
a) Rectal
b) Vaginal
c) Withdrawal of blood
- Need expressed permission
Expressed consent
It is specifically stated by the patient in distinct and explicit language
what are the types of expressed consent?
Oral/verbal consent:
- For minor examinations or therapeutic procedures, in presence of disinterested party (a nursee.g. blood collection & ECG
Written consent
- For:
a) All major diagnostic procedures:endoscopy, bone marrow aspiration
b) General anesthesia
c) Operations
what are the charachters of Informed valid Consent?
Charachters of informed refusal
- The patient should be informed that he has right to refuse examination and that the result may go against him. If he refuses, he cannot be examined
- The doctor must inform the patient about the risks of refusing a particular operation, test, medication, or other medical intervention
- To be legally valid, such informed refusal must be reduced to writing with signatures of patient, doctor and witness
what makes a consent invalid?
- Not an informed consent
- Given for committing a crime or an illegal act, such as criminal abortion
- Obtained by misrepresentation or fraud
- Given by one who had no legal capacity to give it:
a) A minor
b) Insane person or under the influence of drugs or intoxication
Therapeutic Privilege
- The doctor withhold (Hide) from patient the information (as to risk), if the disclosure would cause serious psychological threat to the patient (malignancy or unavoidable total results)
- However, he should disclose full information to a competent relative
Blanket (open) Consent
- The consent practiced in most hospitals that cover almost everything a doctor might do to a patient
- Without mentioning anything specific
what are Exceptions to Informed Consent?
- Emergencies (e.g. danger to life or limb)
- Medico-legal postmortem examination
- Examination of an arrested accused
- Treatment of patient suffering from notifiable diseases
- Psychiatric examination or treatment by court order
- Prisoners (new entrants)
what is assent?
A child’s agreement to medical interventions and research
Assent in children
- Children under 18 & adolescent below 21 can agree to treatment if they’re intelligent, competent
- Doctors should listen to opinions and wishes of children who aren’t able to give full consent and should try to obtain their assent
- Children should receive information in easy way to give their assent or dissent
- Assent must protect the dignity, privacy and confidentiality of the child and his or her family
How should doctors act when treatment is necessary to save life or prevent serious harm?
- The doctor has the duty to act in the best interest of the child
- If parents refuse to consent, national laws and legal mechanisms may be used
- The courts can make a decision if treatment is thought to be in the best interests of the child
How should doctors act when n an emergency, where treatment is vital and waiting for parental consent would place the child at risk?
- In an emergency, where treatment is vital and waiting for parental consent would place the child at risk, treatment can proceed without consent
what should a consent be?
Consent should be free, voluntary, clear, intelligent, informed, direct and personal
what a consent shouldn’t be?
There should be no undue influence, fraud, misrepresentation of facts, compulsion, coercion or other consequences
In what type of language should a consent be?
- The knowledge regarding the intervention should be in understandable language and format so that decision can be made by the patient
- A doctor should present reasonable information considering best practices
What form should the consent be?
- Should be in a proper form and suitably drafted for the circumstances
- The more specific the consent, the less likely it will be construed against the doctor or hospital in court
what is considered one of the most important terms of written consent?
- The written consent should be witnessed by another person, present at the signing
- To prevent any allegation that the consent was obtained under pressure
Recieving consent in case of no nearest relative
When there is no nearest relative a physician may provide necessary treatment if:
a) He believes that the proposed treatment is essential
b) another treatment provider agrees in writing that the proposed treatment is essential
Consent in criminal cases
- The victim cannot be examined without consent
- The court cannot force a person to be medically examined
- Accused person can be examined by a doctor using reasonable force, if requested by a police officer, if examination may provide evidence
- Arrested person may be examined by a doctor at his request to detect evidence in his favor
Consent in female examination
- Better made by or under supervision of a female medical practitioner
- Such an examination by a male doctor must be carried out in the presence of a female nurse
- In rape cases, the victim should not be examined without her written consent
- In medico-legal cases of pregnancy, delivery and abortion, the woman should not be examined without her consent
Consent for Sterilization and artificial insemination
consent of both husband & wife should be obtained
Consent for Mass immunization
law provides the consent
Consent in prenatal diagnostic procedures
informed written consent of pregnant woman is obtained and a copy of the consent is given to the woman
Postmortem consent
General Guidelines of Consent
what is the definition of professionalism?
1. A set of values, behaviors, and relationships that underpins the trust the public has in doctors.
2. A set of values, attitudes, behaviors that sets client’s self-interest before ➔ self-interest of the professional.
3.It is a habitual & judicious use of .(CK SFERV)….
- communication
- knowledge
- technical skills
- clinical reasoning
- emotions
- values
- reflection
in daily practice for the benefit of the individual & community.
4. Professionalism is also the moral understanding among medical practitioners that gives reality to what is commonly referred to as the social convention between medicine and society.
what is a mark of excellence for dctors?
Professionalism
what happens when a doctor becomes aware of the fact that the people have certain expectations & certain standards for judging the competence of doctors?
- the sense of responsibility increases and improves the patient care
what does professionalism has to do with?
❶ effective communication skills
❷ achieving excellence in skills plus ethics.
Professional competence
- Professional competence that should be practiced spontaneously regarding
❶ upgrading your knowledge
❷ improving your skills
❸ better communication
❹ showing your commitments and sympathy
❺ giving good explanation to your judgment armed with values in all aspects that at the end of the day ensure safe patient with full satisfaction for all parties looking after the patient.
Who defined medical profrssionalism?
Medical professionalism was defined by many organizations such as
- the American college of physicians
- the European federation of internal medicine
- American College of surgeons
- American Medical Association
- Association of American Medical Colleges
Definition of medical professionalism
- an impressive catalogue of virtues in an era when physician autonomy and self- regulation are increasingly challenged by third-party payers, patients and their families, and external critics.
Fair SERI
what are physicians expected to do?
Physicians are expected, among other things, to
❶ subordinate their own Interests to the interests of patient (and to assume risk when doing so)
❷ Strive for excellence, knowledge, and competence
❸ work for Fair allocation of health care resources
❹ treat patients, physician colleagues, and other health care professionals with Respect
❺ avoid conflicts of Interest
❻ demonstrate Sensitivity to other cultures.
what are the principles of professionalism?
Principles are built upon the establishment of
❶ clinical competence
❷ communication skills
❸ ethical and legal understanding.
what must happen to show professionalism?
To show professionalism you must be:
❶ Competent in your field
❷ Good communication skills
❸ Ethical oriented
Definition of professionalism according to ABIM
- The American Board of Internal Medicine (ABIM), who is leader and has explicitly, addressed the definition of professionalism in the 1990s
- Their widely adopted definition was broad and inclusive and is composed of:
❶ 3 commitments
❷ 6 elements
Commitments of professionalism according to ABIM
❶ To maintain the highest standards of excellence in the practice of medicine
❷ To sustain the interests & welfare of patients
❸ To be responsive to the health needs of society.
Elements of professionalism according to ABIM
- Alturism
- Accountability
- Excellence
- Honors
- Integrity
- Respect for others
Profession —> Commitment to professional ethics —-> Make evidence based decisions —-> Life long learner
Professionalism pyramid
what is Culture competence?
Having a defined set of values & principles that allow to demonstrate others’ behaviors & attitudes that enable them to work effectively cross culturally.
what is Culture sensitivity?
- Awareness that cultural differences & similarities exist, without assigning values (better/ worse, right/ wrong) to those cultural differences
what is Culture knowledge?
- Familiarization with the selected cultural characteristics, history, value, belief systems, & behaviors of members of another ethnic group.
what is language barrier?
حاجز في التواصل يظهر بين مجموعة لا تستطيع ان نتحدث نفس اللغة
what are the Pillars of professionalism?
- Probity
- Alturism
- Honesty & Integrity
- Respect
- Responsibility & accountability
- Standards
- Expertise
- Commitment to excellence
- Care & compassion
what does Probity mean?
The word “probity” is taken from the Latin for good, honest and upright.
According to Probity, A professional person should be ….
A professional person should be all these things, as well as Fair & law-abiding and of general good character.
what is Probity considered?
Probity is central to the public trust, so medical workers should, through their actions, uphold this reputation.
Give examples for Altrusim
- Pursue to serve patients and their families with perfect clinical care, with their needs first
- Assists colleagues/ learners to address personal issues and enhance knowledge and skills required in a clinical or educational setting
- Actively support the educational mission
- Recognizes that the time and energy specified to performing these functions should not interfere with time for caring for self and family.
what is this? “Pursue to serve patients and their families with perfect clinical care, with their needs first
Alturism
Examples of Honesty & Integrity
- One must uphold the highest standards of behavior and refrain from words and actions that would violate one’s personal or professional codes.
- In learning and study, demonstrating honesty and trustworthiness by referencing sources for intellectual material.
- Openly identifies personal conflicts that interfere with patient’s care.
- Make sure the patient can easily understand the provided information and respects patients’ confidentiality
which pillar of professionalism is this?
“In learning and study, demonstrating honesty and trustworthiness by referencing sources for intellectual material”
Honesty & Integrity
Respect in medicine
- There are expectations that a professional will work and behave in a manner that is appropriate to the nature of their particular profession.
- In medicine, these expectations are unique
❶ good standards of personal appearance and dress
❷ appropriate standards of speech and personal conduct - such attributes (1,2) will confirm to a patient an acceptable standard of respectability
Respect Is good-natured in daily interactions with classmates, teacher’s health care professionals, patients, and families
…
what does it mean to respect others?and who does this apply to?
- hold and acknowledge in high regard feelings, opinions, and values of the members of the larger medical community whether at school, or in clinical environments.
This should apply to:
❶ individual patients and their families
❷ other health care professionals
❸ colleagues, co-workers
❹ others with whom they come in contact.
- One must respect the dignity and autonomy of individual patients, take their beliefs and values into consideration, and maintain their confidentiality at all times.
what does responsinility focus on?
focuses on what one can do and should do
what is the definition of responsibility?
it defines the duty and moral obligation and responsibilities to:
❖ to individual patients
❖ to health care professionals
❖ to society
❖ to the profession.
what does accountability mean?
- is often used interchangeably with responsibility, yet the terms are different.
- Accountability measures one’s behavior against established rules or norms.
what does placing emphasis on accountability risk?
- Placing emphasis on accountability risks that too much attention may be focused on the rules, with both agent and overseer losing sight of what is ultimately important.
- By contrast, responsibility implies duty and moral obligation.
- Hence, the responsibility relationship is one of trust.
what are the doctor responsibilities?
Mnemonic: Fair Chef QR IK
❶ Maintain professional competence and be committed to evaluating and upgrading scientific knowledge
❷ Seeks clarity on roles and responsibilities and managing conflicts of interest from colleagues, teachers, staff and preceptors.
❸ Attends to own personal health through nutrition and physical activity and seeks help when physically or mentally ill
❹ Commits to excellence in health care, improving access to care, and optimizing the health of the community
❺ Seeks and gives feedback to colleagues, teachers, staff and preceptors.
❻ Be honest with patients
❼ Respect patient confidentiality
❽ Avoid inappropriate relations with patients
❾ Advance scientific knowledge
❿ Improve quality and access of care
⓫ Promote the just distribution of resources
Standards of a professional
A professional person is expected to have the ability and dedication to achieve a set of standards in their duties that their peers find acceptable
Expertise of a professional
- A professional person is expected to have a particular set of skills in their chosen field, at a level that can be considered expert.
A professional person is expected to have a particular set of skills in their chosen field, at a level that can be considered expert, This will have been acquired through:
❶ Learning
❷ Knowledge
❸ training and practice of the relevant skills
How is the level of expertise demonestrated?
by qualifications or accreditation of some kind.
How is the validity of expertise maintained?
by ongoing training throughout the
course of a medical career.
Commitment to Excellence
Excellence is a conscientious effort to exceed ordinary expectations
what does Commitment to Excellence imply?
- It implies first a commitment to lifelong learning.
- Besides, to continually upgrade yourself with new knowledge that requires a commitment to continued learning:
❶ new studies are published that have a direct impact on patient care
❷ practice guidelines are revised and updated
❸ new drugs emerge, and the efficacy and safety of existing drugs are regularly challenged
❹ advances in technology change the way health care is delivered
❺ new legislation and policies have implications on the practice.
Care & compassion
To care and to be compassionate are at the very center of the fiducial relationship with the patient.
what is caring in the most basic terms?
means to attend to the needs of others and to have personal concern for the well-being of another
What is caring in the professional context?
has been defined as expressing attitudes and actions of concern for patients to support their well-being, alleviate Excessive discomfort, and meet obvious or anticipated needs
what does it mean to be compassionate?
is to recognize and understand the needs of others but, more important, to act on this compassion and desire to help them.
DRS
Professional Vs. Unprofessional
A professional person will
❶ Take pride in doing a job well and pay attention to Detail.
❷ Take personal Responsibility for their actions and the consequences.
❸ Seek to Develop and improve their skills.
❹ Not be Satisfied with a substandard result and will seek to put things right.
❺ Be prepared to Acknowledge mistakes, learn from them and take appropriate steps to prevent recurrence.
❻ Show Respect for those who consult them in a professional capacity.
What does the caring nature of the profession mean?
what are examples of Social responsibity?
❶ Compassion for those suffering pain and hardship
❷ A proper and responsible role in society
❸ A responsible attitude to the environment
❹ Good employment practices
❺ An awareness of social issues where the medical profession is in a position to play an important or central role
❻ Humanity in both professional and personal matters
❼ Adherence to the law
FB RF CM RML
Role of the students
❶ Seek and accept feedback and constructive instruction from teachers, peers, residents and faculty in order to continually improve educational experience, knowledge, and clinical skills.
❷ Commit to the highest standards of competence.
❸ Be mindful of demeanor, language, and appearance in the classroom, in the presence of patients, & in all health care settings.
❹ Admit to and assume responsibility for mistakes in a mature and honest manner and develop productive strategies for correcting them.
❺ Refrain
- from using illicit substances.
- from using alcohol, non-prescription or prescription drugs in a manner that may compromise judgment or ability to contribute to safe and effective
learning.
❻ Be considerate and respectful of others’ (teachers, peers, residents and faculty) time, rights, values, religious, ethnic and socioeconomic backgrounds, lifestyles, opinions, and choices
❼ Meet the expectations for participation and timeliness that are communicated to me by those who teach me.
❽ Recognize limitations and seek help when one’s expertise, knowledge, or level of experience is inadequate to handle a situation in the classroom, hospital, or research setting.
what is the definition of professional secrecy?
It means duty of doctor, pharmacist & other medical personnel to keep secrets they know about patient away from divulge, except in certain conditions.
characteristics of Professional secrecy
Medical journals: Not allowed to publish names or photographs of patient.
Hospitals: Must keep information & investigations concerning any patient away from non-responsible persons.
what is the doctor obligated to do (concerning professional secrecy)?
- He is obliged to maintain secrets that he comes to know concerning patient in course of a professional relationship except when:
- He is required by law to divulge secrets or
- Patient has consented for its disclosure.
- It is mandatory that whatever a doctor sees or hears in life of his patient must be treated as totally confidential.
what does the patient have the right to (concerning professional secrecy)?
- Can sue doctor for damages or face disciplinary action, If disclosure is voluntary & resulted in harm to patient and is not in the interest of public.
- Disclosure would be failure of trust and confidence.
privacy and confidentiality
These terms have been used together in much of teaching we have received; thus, many may think they are synonymous, but they are not
what is the definition of privacy and what is it concerned with?
- Is that right or expectation not to be interfered with, or more generally, a moral right to be left alone
- Concerned with setting within which patient’s medical information is taken. (i.e., patient’s body)