Final Macroeconomic Flashcards
Value of Each Growth Theory
1. Classical theory reminds us that our physical resources are limited, and we need technological advances to grow.
1. Neoclassical theory emphasizes diminishing returns to capital which means we need technological advances to grow.
1. Endogenous growth theory tries to explain productivity or technological growth within the model (endogenously).
1. New growth theory emphasizes the capacity of human resources to innovate at a pace that offsets diminishing returns.
Classical Growth Theory: Assumptions+Implications+Limitations
Main Idea: subsistence level contains population growth
Assumptions
- diminishing marginal returns to inputs
- population growth responds to income levels ( IE, increased output leads to increased population growth )
- fixed nature of natural resources, subsistence level of real GDP & wage
Predictions:
- When real GDP per capita rises above subsistence level a population explosion will bring it back down to subsistence level
- As population grows real wage falls until it hits subsistence level where population+economic growth stop
Implications
- we will always return to a subsisting ( just being able to survive) level of living as the population will grow in response to increases in GDP till GDP per capita returns to subsistence, must contain population
Limitations
- doesn’t take into account the increase in technology, which minimizes DMR, allows the rate of output to outstrip population growth and allow for higher stadnerds of living
- Importance of Labor: Mathluthisan-labor is beneficial up to a limit → (China’s Growth didn’t drive incomes back down to subsistence levels) → Solow-refute
- Inaccurate determination of total wages, didn’t consider how trade unions & demand impacts wages
Neoclassical Growth Theory: Assumptions+Implications+Limitations
Basic Idea: tech advance as key driver of growing long-term living standards, savings & investment super important, eventually output growth will only be driven by population growth until a shock occurs, c k y are constants determined by kSS
assumptions
- A,n,s,d is exogenous
- the economy is closed, and there are no government expenses
- tech affects economic growth+k growth not vice versa
- output produced annually is invest in new capital or in replacing depreciated capital (It), uninvested part of output is consumed by population (Ct)
- there are diminishing marginal returns to facts of production& constant returns to scale
limitations
- A is exogenous when it is affected by human & physical capital, wealth orR&D or technology
- not all forms of capital exhibit diminishing marginal returns
Implications
- there is a conditional convergence of K/L ratio amongst state. Rich countries will grow K slower than poor countries until, eventually, every country will reach a steady state with similar levels of K/L. The condition is that these countries demonstrate similar Saving rate
- factors affecting long-run standard of living, how rate of economic growth evolves over time
Endogenous Growth Theory: Assumptions+Implications+Limitations
Key Difference b/w Solow:
- economic growth is generated internally through endogenous forces (A is endogenous derived from model in terms of s,H, R&D not given or constant) & attacks assumption of diminishing marginal return of capital as capital used properly will increasingly increasing return k
- No steady state if graphs never intersect
Derivation:
1. Sn=sAK=sY
2. K_t+1=K_t+I-dK
I=K+K net investment+depreciation
3. sAK=K+K
k=changeK/K=changeY/Y=sA-d since gy=gk
assumptions
- technology (A) generated from within the economyso production function is not diminishing but constant (alpha>=1) y=Ak, MPK=A, dA/dk=Constant Marginal Return
- number of workers remains constantso growth in output/capital per labor equal
- closed economyimplications
- The growth of a country depends on rates of savings and investmentsg_Kss=g_A=g_RD+g_I=S
- the growth rate of output per worker = growth rate of output. Therefore, there are no diminishing returns to capital. Instead, MPK depends on technology levels, not K stock
- there are increased returns to scale in investments in human capital and private sector R$D ( this lasts because the private sector is motivated by growth)
Implication:
- Constant Determinants of Economic growth rate depends on savings rate, investment (R&D-generated by increasing K & offsets any tendency for MPK to decrease), Human capital not only exogenous productivity growth
Increasing returns to scale from capital investment in knowledge industries (edu, health, telecomm.)
limitations
- technological advancement is limitless ( exponential). This is not necessarily true
- does not take into account market failures generated by externalities. ( growth of technology leads to pollution, leads to a decrease in productivity)
New Growth Theory: Assumptions+Implications+Limitations
Basic Idea: Long run growth (y=real GDP per capita) grow because of choices that people make in the pursuit of profit and growth can persist indefinitely a perpetual motion machine
Assumptions
- Knowledge is not subject to diminishing returns
- Discovery result from choices, brings profit if patented or else is a public capital good, competition destroys profit & knowledge is not subject to DMR as increasing its stock makes L & K more productive (increases MPK+MPL)t
- Graph + Sala Table
implication
- real GDP per person grows because of choices that people make in the pursuit of profit, and that growth can persist indefinitely
- growth is a perpetual motion machine. Innovation -> new and better products and techniques -> better jobs and more leisure time -> higher standard of living -> want for an even higher standard of living ( choices in pursuit of self-interest) -> innovation
limitations
- New growth theory assumes that knowledge and innovation generate increasing or constant returns to scale, meaning that the more an economy invests in R&D or human capital, the higher the returns. However, in reality, diminishing returns to knowledge and innovation might occur. Not all investments in education or R&D lead to groundbreaking innovations, and knowledge may not always spill over efficiently to the entire economy.
- it is challenging to measure knowledge, human capital, or the effects of innovation.
- there are so many different things you could quantify as the determinants of growth, including (the environment, politics, civil liberties, etc)
How does an open economy change the IS-LM-FE
Open Economy: intl. Trade of g+s & world integration of financial mkts (capital flow) & currency appreciation/depreciation
- IS gets impacted by C+I+G+Nx from intl trade of g+s
- Currency appreciation/depreciation occurs from integration of financial markets
Nominal v. Real Exchange Rate + Formulas
Nominal Exchange Rate enom=# Foreign Currency/1 Base Currency: number of units of foreign currency can be purchased with a unit of domestic current
Real Exchange Rate: e=(enomxP_Domestic in Nominal Currency)/P_Foreign in Foreign Currency
price has an effect on currency (higher→ depreciates, lower → appreciates), number of foreign goods someone gets in exchange for one domestic good based on CPI/Price indexes of “baskets of goods assuming each country produces a single good
* Law of 1 Price: g+s priced same everywhere
* Affect’s nation’s net export, represents rate at which domestic goods can be traded for foreign goods → higher e means lower Nx, lower e means higher Nx
* Indicator of a country’s productivity relative to other
Calculate real exchange rate given e_nom=78Y/$ hamburger. Price of domestic $3 hamburger, Price of foreign 312Y hamburger.
0.75Y hamburger per $ hamburger
Exchange Rate Systems Differences
Exchange Rate Systems - Who Determines Exchange Rates
Flexible/Floating: no gov role, continuously adjusted by conditions of supply & demand in foreign exchange mkt
- Appreciation: enominal falls, buys less units of foreign currency, becomes “weaker”
Real Appreciation: incr in real exchange rate, same quantity of domestic goods can be traded for more foreign goods
- Depreciation: enominal rises, buys more units of foreign currency, becomes “stronger”
Real Depreciation: decr in real exchange rate, same quantity of domestic goods can be traded for less foreign goods
Depreciation: enominal rises, buys more units of foreign currency, becomes “stronger”
Fixed: set at officially determined levels maintained by commitment of nations’ central banks to buy & sell their own currencies at fixed rate
- Revaluation=appreciation: D>S
- Devaluation=depreciation: S>D
Purchasing Power Parity (PPP) + Derivation
Purchasing Power Parity (PPP): similar foreign & domestic goods should have same price in terms of the same currency (e=1) ignoring transpo & transaction costs. Very weak as assumes e=1 occurs only in very long run
enom=P_Foreign/P_Domestic
Derivation: incr in real exchange rate, same quantity of domestic goods can be traded for more foreign goods
e=enomP/PForeign Growth Accountingee=enomenom+PP-PForeignPForeign
enomenom=ee+foreign-=relative PPP is enomenom=foreign-
4%=6%(JAP)-2%(CAN), which country has more depreciation & appreciation
Countries with more inflation has higher depreciation/weaker, while the other with less inflation appreciates/stronger currency
Nominal & Real Expected Gross of Return on Foreign Bond (EGNR) + Derivation
Expected Gross of Return on Foreign Bond (EGNR) determines investment decisions in open financial asset mkt, assumes e=0
- Nominal: enominalfuture=enom(1+iforeign)(1+idomestic)
- Real: erealfuture=e(1+rforeign)(1+rdomestic)
i-nominal interest rates in foreign relative to domestic
Expected changes to exchange rate
- Derivation:
Interest Rate Parity: difference in returns don’t last long as i equalizes
Nominal: equilibrium for intl. asset mkt enomefnom(1+ifor)=1+i
Not Changing/Same Nominal Exchange Rate iDomestic=iForeign
Real: eefuture(1+rForeign)=1+r
Not Changing/Same Real Exchange Rate (e=efuture)rDomestic=rForeign
Given info solve for real exchange rate and solve for nominal exchange rate assuming PPP holds
CPICAN=125
CPICHINA=475
enom=5.5Y/$
CAn=2%
CHINA=8%
- Solve for real exchange rate:
e=enomPPforeign=5.5125475=1.45 - Solve for nominal exchange rate assuming PPP holds: e=1 %enom=foreign-
6%=8%-2%
New enom=(1+%enom)old enom=(1+6%)5.5=5.83
Which country like which exchange system?
Fixed: large benefits from incr. Trade & integration, monetary policy coordinated closely
* Neutralizes: effects of fiscal policy & shocks to IS curve,
* Magnifies: monetary policy+shocks to LM curvef
* Currency Unions: share common currency by a group of countries reduces cost of trending, prevents speculative attacks on currencies, however monetary policies cannot be independent
Flexible: specific macroecon. shocks reduced by monetary policy
* Sensitivity to shocks increases for small open economy, allows correcting mechanisms of price level & e adjustment,
* Neutralizes: monetary shocks
* Magnifies: fiscal policy
Open Economy Mundell-Fleming Trilemma + Example
Only ⅔ features can be manipulated:
1. Fixed exchange rate to promote trade
1. Open capital marketsFree intl. movement of capital
1. Autonomy of monetary policy domestically.
Fixing currency and stabilization require opposing monetary policy.
For example, if a country pegs its exchange rate to another country and capital is free to move, the domestic interest rate will be forced to equal the interest rate in the base country
3 Policies to Fix Overvalued & Undervalued Currency
Fixed/Goal: 1USD/1CAD
Current: 0.8USD/1CAD undervalued/depreciated, worth less than wanted enom<efixed
1. Buy back/gatekeep domestic:MDdom>MSdom=enom
1. Float/Sell Foreign currency: MDforeign<MSforeign=foreign enom=domesticenom
1. Restrict intl trade
Current: 1.2USD/1CAD overvalued/appreciated, worth more than wanted enom>efixed
1. Float/Sell Domestic: MDdom<MSdom depreciate enom
1. Stop transactions
1. Buy/Gate Keep Foreign Currency: MDfor>MSfor appreciate foreign currency so domestic currency falls enom
1. Restrict intl trade
Overvalued v. Undervalued Exchange Rate
Overvalued e:
enom>efixed appreciated, worth more than fixed/wanted/mkt determined, support by
Undervalued e:
enom<efixed/mkt depreciated worth less than wanted/mkt determined, maintained forever if nation’s trading partners don’t lose reserves
Speculative Run
ending support for overvalued run by investors who sell assets denominated in overvalued currency to avoid losses (
S)
Fiscal Expansion in Flexible v. Fixed Exchange System
Flexible - Ineffective: fails Immediate Crowds out Nx, Y P rd=rf stays constant
ADIS shift right
rd>rfore appreciatescrowds out NxIS shift left until
rd=rfor, no change in Y & P
Fixed - Effective: Classical: Immediately P & e incr. & Nx crowded out, Keynesians say works in SR not in LR
Short Run: price & exchange rates fixed, fiscal policy effective for adjusting output
Long Run: P e increases due to fiscal+monetary expansion & crowds out Nx falls
ADIS shift right
rd>rforefixed appreciates>enom undervalued
To enomLM shift right so rd=rf
Monetary Expansion in Flexible v. Fixed Exchange System
Flexible-Effective:
Mundell using Keynesian Model:
LM shift rightrdom<rfore depreciates
NxADIS shift r until rd=rf
Result: effective, Y incr., r same
Classical: money neutrality holds immediately
Keynesian Model Predicts won’t work in long run-further adjustments in long term
ADY>Y potential=inflationary pressure P
LM=MP shift leftrd>rf=e appreciates
Nx=ADIS shifts left until rd=rf
Result: P incr., Y r Nx e same in long run, money neutral
Fixed-Ineffective:
LM=MS^/P shift rightrd<rf
=e depreciate
enom>efixed actual worth more than fixed
Munell-Fleming Model Key Takeways
- Monetary or Fiscal Depends on System: The efficacy of monetary and fiscal policies under different exchange rate regimes. In a fixed exchange rate system, fiscal policy is more effective than monetary policy. An increase in government spending directly impacts aggregate demand and output
- Trillema: A country cannot simultaneously maintain a fixed exchange rate, free capital movement, and an independent monetary policy. This is also known as the “policy trilemma” or “unholy trinity”.
Assumptions: PPP, perfect substitutes, small & open economy
Close+Open Economy IS Curve + Derivation/Slope + Shifts + Graphs
Closed: S=I, shows at every Y & r where the goods mkt is in equilibrium
* Derivation/Downward: as Y/r incr. the goods mkt equilibrium decr., Each Y/r incr. → savings incr. curve shifts right/investment curve decr. shifts left →moving the equilibrium (S=I) r & Y lower and lower
* Shift: at a constant output, anything that impacts AD, reduces desired S relative to I from Y=C+I+G (ex. Temporary incr. in gov expenditure with Y constant decr. SNational shifting curve left → higher equilibrium INT rate → IS curve shifts up)
Open: Good Mkt Equilibrium S^d-I^d=Nx
- As r incr. = S-I upward sloping, Nx downward sloping
- Downward Sloping: same reasons as closed economy (C+I+G) + effects on Nx
rInvestment into currency SMDD>S AppreciationNX=X-M=Y
YTransactions=MD=Nx shift left=SNational=S-I shift rightr equilibrium
- Shifts: factors that change AD=C+I+G & Nx = changes r clearing goods mkt at constant level of output
- Graphs: see doc
Business Cycle + Elements + Importance
- Fluctuation of actual GDP/aggregate economic activity around Normal growth path/potential/full-employment GDP
- Expansions, contractions, trough, peak
- Persistence: beginning of expansion/contraction tends to continue for a period of time
Importance: interpreting data & state of economy, guidance & discipline for developing econ. Theories of BC
Direction in which macro variable moves relative to direction of BC
* Pro: same direction (+)
* Counter: opposite direction (-)
* A: no clear pattern
Timing of variable’s turning points relative to turning points of BC for prediction
* Leading Variable: turns before BC turns
* Coincident Variable: turns same time as BC turns
* Lagging Variable: turns after BC turns
Keynesian v. Classical differences on Business Cycle meaning, speed of econ, monetary policy, money neutrality SR & LR
BC: Reps. disturbances in production & spending driving econ. Away from desirable level of output+employment for long periods of time due to wages & prices adjusting slowly → gov needs to intervene to put back GDP into potential GDP v. Reps. econ.’s natural phenomenon and best response to disturbances in production & spending
Speed: slow sticky P+W v. fast P flexible
Monetary: to slow focus on fiscal v. neutral LM shifts back very quickly from P flexible
Money Neutrality: SR not neutral v. money always neutral. Both agree higher MS=Higher Prices
LM Curve in Closed + Open Economy + Slope/Derivation + Shifts + Graphs
LM Curve: Asset Mkt Equality of Money Demanded & Supplied, relation b/w Y & r that clears the asset mkt, each point of the curve is where MD=MS
Closed
Upward Sloping: higher Y → more transactions → MD demand → equilibrium incr.
* MS Vertical: doesn’t depend on INT fixed
* **MD Downward **Sloping: higher r, attractiveness of money decreases
* Shifts: anything that changes real MS/MD relative to real MD/MS other than Y & r will impact r that clears mkt causing LM shift, usually moves due to price level adjustments to meet general equilibrium point. (ex.incr. MS → excess supply causes purchasing nonmonetary assets —> prices go up → decr. equilibrium r → curve shifts down right)
Upward Sloping LM: YMore transactions=MD → equilibrium r=LM positive sloping
MD Downward for Dollars Curve - Downward Sloping (higher e less buying domestic/more expensive): to to buy CAN goods, real + financial assets
MS Upward of Dollars Curve - Upward Sloping (higher e more buying foreign/cheaper): to buy foreign goods, buy real + financial assets in foreign countries
Shifts: any price adjustments required for new equilibrium
Income, Quality, Real Interest Rate Effects on Exchange Rate
Income Effects:
Domestic Output Rise YDomesticMore transactions=M>X=MDdomestic & MDForeign domestic currency depreciates/exchange rate falls Nx
Foreign Output Rise YForeignM=MDDomestic=MDforeign → domestic currency appreciates/exchange rate rise XDomesticNx
Quality Effects → More Demand for Currency=Rightward Shift of Demand
Real Interest Rate Effects on Exchange Rate:
Domestic r Rises=MD Rise: domestic country’s real & financial assets more attractive for investment, exchange rate appreciates (enom rises) reduces Nx
Foreign r Rises=MD Fall: supply of domestic currency incr., exchange rate depreciates, (enom lowers) incr. Nx
Conversion Formula: Given 3 month interest rate convert into annual
=i3 month domestic/12 months *3 months
Fiscal & Monetary Policy in IS-LM-FE + Graph
Fiscal Policy IS - r incr.: Expansion=G incr or T decr..
Short Run: incr. I or decr. S → r incr. → IS shifts up right → AD rise → P rise
Multiplier Effect & Crowding Out Effect Cancel out
Long Run: P incr. → LM shift left to new general equilibrium
Monetary Policy LM - Shifts back: Expansion=Incr. MS
Short Run: LM=MS/P shift right/incr. (P fixed) → IS-LM-FE equilibrium r decr. → AD rise exceeding full employment production → P incr.
Long Run: P incr. → LM=M/P shifts back decr./left
Result: change in nominal money supply causes the price level to change proportionally
Stabilization Policy
Stabilization Policy: use of fiscal & monetary policy to shift position of IS & LM to offset effects of such shocks
Investment Strategy for Adverse/Positive Supply Shocks
Negative/Adverse Supply Shock: lower GDP & higher prices
* Reduce investment in fixed income securities, most equity securities
* Incr. investment in commodities/based companies as profits likely to rise
Positive Supply Shock: higher GDP & lower prices
* Incr. investment in fixed income securities, most equity securities
* Decr. investment in commodities/based companies as profits likely to rise
Temporary Adverse Supply Shock=FE Line Shifts Left=Stagflation
FE/MPL decr. → Less Supply=P incr. (not IS shift, movement along) → LM=M/P decr. Shift left to general equilibrium point
Graph in doc
Investment Strategy Depending on IS Shift
Rightward Shift = Expansion or Fiscal Policy G incr. or T decr:
* Reduce investments in defensive companies/low risk & fixed-income longer-maturity securities (bonds)
* Incr. investments in cyclical companies, commodities, speculative/junk bonds as decr. in its default risk
Leftward Shift = Contraction or Fiscal Policy G decr. Or T incr.:
* Reduce investments in cyclical companies, commodities, speculative/junk bonds as decr. in its default risk
* Incr. investments in defensive companies/low risk, fixed-income longer-maturity securities (bonds) & investment-grade or government-issued fixed income securities
Higher price of asset the lower its nominal interest rate given the promised schedule of repayments
Price of a Nonmonetary asset (bonds) & r are inversely related for a given rate of inflation