Final Exam MUE Flashcards
Pornography vs. Obscenity
Pornography is protected under the first Amendment, but obscenity is not.
Individual films or items MUST meet all 3 standards of 1973 Miller vs. California obscenity test to be considered obscene.
- Violates contemporary community standards.
- Patently offensive–will most of people agree that they are offended by it?
- Lacking serious artistic, literary, political or scientific value.
Does pornography cause sexual violence?
There is anecdotal evidence that it does…But we need scientific evidence.
▪There is a correlation between rape and pornography consumption.
▪There is a logical association.
▪However, there is no constant time order or ruling out third variables to indicate cause and effect.
▪Experiments are the only method that determines causality
What is anecdotal evidence?
Anecdotal evidence means that one person or a few people report the effects, but there is not scientific evidence to generalize these effects to society
Confirmation Bias
People tend to seek, interpret, and remember information in a way that confirms their prior beliefs.
- Investigating sexual content in the media using social science theories and methods minimizes the effects of our biases and expectations.
Two Theories on the Effects of Pornography:
- Trigger Hypothesis
2. Safety Valve Theory
Trigger hypothesis
Exposure to pornography will cause a response in some individuals that will provoke them to commit a sex crime.
Safety Valve Theory
Exposure to pornography will satisfy whatever urges might cause a person to commit a sex crime
What past theories are the Trigger Hypothesis and the Safety Valve Theory similar to?
Trigger Hypothesis - ?
Safety Valve Theory - catharsis
Priming
Associations between concepts get stronger every time they are reinforced.
- Pornography associates youth with sex
- 21.8% of adult film covers featured “youth-sexualized imagery”
- Imagery has increased over time - Pornography associates sex with violence
- Amount of violence depends on how “violence” is defined
Effects of Pornography on Behavior
In experiments, viewing pornography lowers the inhibition to commit violent acts and increases hostility toward women.
•For example, administering electric shocks to women
Effects of pornography on Beliefs and Attitudes
In experiments, viewing pornography associated with:
- Increased belief that the crime of rape is not as serious
- Less satisfaction with sexual relationships
- Less trust in sexual partners
- Less belief in the testimony of a sexual assault victim
- Increased belief in rape myths, such as “no” means “yes”
Meta-Analysis: Definition
type of research study that analyzes findings from studies that have already been completed; averages results across many studies to understand research trends
How to measure responses (i.e., how to measure the effects of pornography)?
Psychophysiological measures.
Psychophysiological measures: Definition/examples
Measurements of physical response that assess emotional states
Facial muscles = positive emotion, smiling
Heart rate, sweating = physiological arousal
Penile tumescence = sexual arousal
Limitations of Experiments (for porn)
Usually conducted on college-age men; Ecological Validity; Social desirability bias
Sexual Content in Mainstream Media/Desensitizing Effect: Definition
Viewing violence in media makes us numb to violence in real life.
The Desensitizing Effect is also the explanation for the increasing amount of explicit sexual content or sexualized violence in media over time.
Disinhibitory Effects
Seeing “bad” behavior rewarded in media makes us more likely to model it.
Sexual Uncertainty Hypothesis
Adolescents are taught by family and schools that consensual sexual activity is part of love and long-term commitment
But, sex in media is not depicted this way; inconsistent messages lead to confusion.
Erotic Media
Materials that features explicit sexual content in the absence of violence and without the overt power dynamics that appear in pornography.
National Commission on Obscenity and Pornography
Formed under Lyndon B. Johnson, the commission was put in place because of growing concern about the role of pornography in crime and juvenile delinquency
Rape Myth
The idea that women enjoy being raped.
Electric Shock Paradigm
goes back to the electric shock experiment to test the obedience theory - learned about this last unit and in psychology. (144)
Meese Commission
Did not become involved in the conduct of new scientific research on the topic [of pornography]. Instead, it relied on existing studies and anecdotal data gathered from interviews and examinations of the commercial market for pornography.