Final Flashcards
Qualitative interviewing is
- More likely to reflect natural conversation
- Often in the form of participants narrating their personal experiences
- Unstructured or semi-structured
What are qualitative interviews compared to structured interviews?
- More open-minded
- Going off on tangents is encouraged
- Flexible
- Greater interest in the interviewee’s concerns
- Rich, detailed answers
- Interviewee is often interviewed multiple times
What are unstructured interviews?
The researcher only briefly introduces topics
What are semi-structured interviews?
The researcher has a list of topics to be covered
Things to consider when preparing an interview guide
- What is interesting about the topic?
- Always be open to new issues that may arise
- Establish loose order of questions
- Use language that the participants can understand
- No leading questions
- Prompts to ensure sufficient personal information
Introduction questions
“When did your interest in X begin?”
Follow up questions
“What did you mean by that?”
Probing questions
“How so?”
Specifying, factual questions
“What did you do then?”
Direct, interviewee perceptions questions
“Do you find it difficult to keep smiling when serving customers?”
- best kept until the end of the interview to avoid direction
Indirect, perceptions of others questions
“How do you feel about so and so?”
Structuring questions
“Now I would like to move on to another topic”
Silence
A pause will allow the interviewee to reflect and amplify their answer (but don’t pause for too long it’s awkward)
Interpreting questions
“Did you mean that..?”
What are focus groups?
An interview with 4+ people who can interact with each other as well as the interviewer
What are the advantages of focus groups?
- Allow access to the meanings that develop during interaction with others rather than in isolation
- May bring out a variety of perspectives
What do modulators/facilitators do?
- Makes sure the discussion remains on topic without direction too much
- Makes sure everyone participates
What about focus groups is naturalistic?
- Bring out how individuals collectively make decisions and interpretations
- Interviewees may show conformity or be argumentative
What is a good size for a focus group?
Depends on the topic and goals of research but 6 typically
How many focus groups are needed?
- Usually 10-15
- Enough for theoretical saturation
What are natural focus groups?
- People who already know each other
- Useful if the research is about social interaction
What are the disadvantages of natural focus groups?
- Pre-existing styles of interaction or hierarchies may affect discussion
- The group may have taken-for-granted assumptions are not challenged
Limitations of focus groups
- Less control over discussion than in interviews
- Too much data to analyze sometimes
- Personality traits interfere
- Difficulties with sensitive issues, social hierarchies and strongly opposed positions
Focus groups as a feminist method
- Less artificial
- Studies the individual in a social context
- Less control by participants
Advantages of interviewing over ethnography
- Sometimes issues are not observable
- Can reconstruct past events and future plans
- Less intrusive
- Longitudinal research is easier
- Greater breadth of topics can be covered
- Addresses specific issues
What does Chilisa suggest in Decolonizing the Interview Method
- Alternative interview strategies that reflect postcolonial indigenous worldviews
- Researchers should use indigenous knowledge to guide the research
- The researched should have access to the research
What does Chilisa say about the current interview method?
- There are power imbalances between the interviewer and interviewee
- The vocabulary and analysis is informed by Western academia
- It ignores the postcolonial value system
What is happening in Islam’s “Research as an Act of Betrayal”?
- The ethical issue of exposing a group she is falsely representative of (insider vs outsider)
- To academia she is the voice of Bangladeshi immigrants, to Bangladeshi immigrants, she is not
- Should she expose the Bangladeshi immigrants for their bigotries or not?