Final Flashcards
Who promoted the concept of recovery
consumer/survivor movement
MHCC task
develop first MH strategy for Canada
Example of person who wrote a book on personal experience with recovery
Pat Deegan
What kind of movement is recovery (Direction)
Bottom-up
Key themes of recovery
- Not the same as symptom remission
- It’s a process not an outcome
- recovery ‘in’ MI not ‘from’
- as a series of short steps
- it involves normative social roles and routines
- emphasis on employment housing, social relationships and community integration (ROUTINE)
- this model involves choice, empowerment and agency in the health system
- stigma as a massive barrier to recovery
(recovery) Model that offers less agency is
paternalistic
Collaborative care (recovery)
when the model is more collaborative, shared decision-making, reaching a consensus
End goal in recovery?
Different definitions
but generally it’s seen as an ongoing process, you never stop
Recovery stand in contrast to notions of
Chronicity Stabilization Paternalism Continuing care Segregation
Chronicity (recovery)
belief that certain illnesses will never improve
Stabilization (recovery)
focus on reducing symptoms
Goal - just to stop being from being a threat to themselves or others
Continuing care (recovery)
CC unit people would visit you to make sure you were stabilized (chronicity idea)
Segregation (recovery)
People with severe MI separated "sheltered workshops" Segregation for 1. Refuge - need refuge from society 2. containment - to stop them from being a threat to society
Stats about recovery/stigma
80% unemployment among people with severe MI
20-50% homeless people have a MI
High hate crime rate
Most budget for MI doesn’t go to recovery (containment …)
Clinician’s role? (recovery)
foster recovery
What do clinicians need? (recovery)
Retraining- adopt respectful + hopeful attitudes
support choice
encourage autonomy
fight stigma around patient’s irrationality and decisional capacity
Recovery oriented interventions
- Supported employment (specialists help make action plan)
- Supported housing
- Illness self-management course (u come up with ur own strategy)
- Psychiatric advance directive (like a will for when you have episodes)
- Peer support
- recovery centres (learn skills)
- Shared decision making as 2 experts (medical + physical/personal)
Stigma etymology
Ancient greek word “mark” or “brand”
According to goffman stigma is perpetuated by
fear, myth, misconception and prejudice
2 types of stigma
External
Internal
External stigma
held by the rest of society to subgroup
becomes problem if held by people of power
Manifests itself in unemployment rate
Internal stigma
when you internalise stigma and start to question yourself
External stigma manifests itself in
Housing (high rate of homelessness)
Education (high drop-out rate, low investment in facilitating needs)
Dating and relationships
Criminal and justice issues (3 strikes you’re out policy, pb for untreated schizophrenia –> “revolving doors”)
in stigma -“revolving doors”
Police just arrest and then kick them out after a few days
what happens psychologically through internal stigma?
Self isolation
Self esteem and confidence drops
shame, guilt, self doubt
Result of internal stigma?
Embarrassed to utilize health services
Substance abuse - “self medication” to fill social/existential vacuum
Suicide and suicidality (thinking or attempting)
Change in stigma over time
Studies have shown no change
People think more and more that MI is chronic and biological
(BBB model)
Bottom-up ways to reduce stigma
Confrontation
Boycott
Media-Monitoring
Public rallies (more of emotional catharsis though)
Top down ways to reduce stigma
PSA (only short term tho, discouraged)
Legislation, courts, policy (prevent discrimination, MHCC)
Contact-based workshops (MOST EFFECTIVE)
Contact based workshops (stigma)
- Someone with MI will go to a target group of people and make a speech
- Collabo with an expert
- Have long term effect
Best way to reduce stigma? (combo)
Legislation (by making things illegal), complemented by targeted contact- based workshops
Ödegaard (immigration)
compared MH - people in noarway with norwegian immigrants with native minnesotans
Competing theories about the high rates of MI among immigrants
Social drift (people who emigrate because they're having problems) Social causation (new country causes problems: racism, language barrier--> stress) Misdiagnosis or social control (stigmatization of immigrants, seen as threats)
3 phases of immigrant mental health
Pre-migration
Migration journey
Post-migration
Pre migration
odegaard attributes elevated risks to this
Many ppl came from war-struck countries, persecution, natural disasters –> risk factors for PTSD
Migration journey
Terrible journey affected mH
Vietnamese boat people
refugee camps - waiting for relocation (high rate of violence and sexual assault)
Post-migration
unemployment, underemployment, discrimination, language barriers
Ethnic density study
Faris and Dunham in the 1930s
Low ethnic density : higher racism, micro aggression
Higher ethnic density: more social support, more networks
culturally relevant community centres
places of worship –> all G for MH
Immigrant study - Cautor- Graae and Jelten
schizophrenia in immigrants 3:1
higher risk among 2nd gen
Adapting to new environment is hard (especially if it’s not a great as you expected)
Use of cannabis - predictor for psychosis (controversial though)
cultural differences interpreted as psychosis- delusions (ex. religious references, talking close to face)
Why higher risk of MI in 2nd gen than first gen?
If you’re first gen: more embedded in your own culture, but 2nd gen - foot in both camps, different norms and values (double bind)
first gen can engage in escapism not second gen
But also can have birth complications if pregnant during immigration
Healthy migrant effect?
- selection process chooses healthier people
- better networks among immigrants
- rely more on alternative mental health services (traditional, religious healing and spirituality)
Statistics about boys and education
40% of undergraduate degrees
77% of dropouts
Lower performance scores
Suicide in men
second leading cause of death (15-34)
Why is men’s MH so bad?
Technology replacing them Women more suited to economy Demasculanization of schools Devaluation of men Internet porn (addiction + loss of drive) Negative rep of young men in media Less likely to get help
Contributing factors to men’s MH
Men’s behaviour
Limitations within healthcare system
Harmful social norms/political ideologies
Men’s health behaviour
- downplay and avoid illness
- cowboy complex
- stigma: contradiction with masculine ideals
- Men’s coping : self medication + isolation
Cowboy complex
- Idea of stoicism, self-reliance
- Not appropriate to seek help (esp. For non-physical issues)
Limitations within healthcare system (men’s)
Lack of MH programs for men
Limit of diagnostically tools
Male unfriendly places - hostile healthcare workers –> barriers to care
Lack of research on men’s MH (gender bias)
Limit of diagnostical tools for men’s MH
M and W have v different expression of emotional trouble
tool’s pick up women’s depression but not men’s
Men’s symptoms are miscategorised (alcoholism, personality disorder)
Media analysis - chivalry hypothesis
Media reflects social paradigms of gender
Women treated in chivalrous way (lighter sentences, etc)
Men with MI portrayed as villains and women with MI portrayed as victims
Men’s double bind
Because they’re advantaged in society - don’t deserve help on the micro level
7% of men get custody of their children
Response to terrible MHS for men
Men’s sheds (australia)- normalcy, integration, contribution, sense of purpose
Movember
Online support groups (sometimes are misogynistic)
Consequences to not addressing men’s MH
Drain on health care system Higher suicide rates Higher drug/alcohol abuse Weaker families and communities Weaker societies