FARMBROUGH- US POLITICS Flashcards
The original US constitution contained how many states?
13
When, where and why was the modern constitution developed ?
- 1787
- Constitutional Convention
- To create a united security system after the American Revolution
What are 3 key features of the original constitution ?
- Rep gov > democracy
- Framework of gov, nothing to do with rights
- Congress first, then president, supreme court (order of the articles)
- Compromises were made e.g unitary vs confederal
- Assumed negotiations instead of competition between institutions
- Assumed evolution of document, meaning a lot of areas left uncovered
- Entrenched
- Sovereign
- Codified
What do you call the attendees/ creators of the constitution ?
- The founding fathers
Give an example to prove the Supreme Court has become more political
- Brown v Board of Education Topeka 1954: Segregation became illegal
What power does the Supreme Court have to check Congress ?
(bonus- give an example of this power in use)
- Declare acts of Congress unconstitutional
- e.g. United States v Windsor, result: the federal government cannot discriminate against married lesbian and gay couples for the purposes of determining federal benefits and protections.
Are the separations of powers significant ? WHY?
(YES)
- Each branch is checked by the other two
- No person can be in multiple branches (other than Vice President)
- Avoids tyranny of one branch
- Preserves idea of independent judiciary
Are the separations of powers significant ? WHY?
(NO)
- Misleading, better seen as shared powers
- Vice president is also senate president and has the casting vote in a 50/50 tie
- A president with the support of either the supreme court or party control of congress is very powerful
- Presidential power of pardon overlaps with judiciary
What powers does the president have to check Congress ?
- Veto legislation
- Threaten veto
- Issue executive order to avoid legislation
- Use commander in chief to deploy troops (without a declaration of war)
What powers do Congress have to check the president ?
- Overturn veto with 2/3 majority, e.g. Bush had 4 out of 12 overturned
- Senate must confirm presidential appointments
- Threat of rejecting a nomination
- Power of the purse
- Refusal to pass legislation e.g. Sandy Hook 2012
- Impeachment
- Block treaties
- Launch investigations
What power does the Supreme Court have to check the President ?
(bonus; give an example)
- Rule presidential actions unconstitutional
- e.g. Hamden v Rumsfeld, result: Supreme Court ruled that the Bush administration’s use of military commissions to try terrorist suspects violated the U.S. Code of Military Justice and Geneva Conventions, and were not specifically authorised by any act of Congress
What powers does the President have to check the Supreme Court ?
- Nominate all federal judges
- Issue pardons e.g. Ford pardoning Nixon
What powers does Congress have to check the Supreme Court ?
- Impeach federal justices
- Initiate constitutional amendments
How are checks and balances significant ?
- Encourages Congress and President to use other factions
- President is subject to the most checks
- Affect the timings of presidential initiatives
- Leads to significant deadlock
- Threats are worth more than actual tools
What are the routes for constitutional amendments ?
- Route 1:
Amendment passes 2/3 of Senate, 2/3 of HoR and 3/4 States
(all successful bills pass in route 1) - Route 2:
constitutional convention called by 2/3 of states, 3/4 states must then ratify
How many successful amendments have been added to the constitution ?
- 27
When were the first 10 amendments passed ?
- 1791, 4 years after the first constitution
What are some key amendments ?
- 1st, freedom of religion and speech
- 2nd, right to bear arms
- 8th, no cruel and unusual punishment
- 13th, abolish slavery
- 27th, minor reform to Congress salaries (1992)
Is the constitution too hard to formally amend ? (YES)
- Few amendments passed
- Much of it is still considered outdated, e.g. electoral college
- Too much informal amendment e.g. Roe v Wade
- No national constitutional convention ever held
Is the constitution too hard to formally amend ? (NO)
- Wide consensus means wide majorities are possible
- Outdated clauses can always be repealed e.g prohibition
- Rights of minorities can still be defended by federal and state law
- Supreme court can update provisions e.g. LGBTQ+ rights
What is an informal amendment ?
- Changing the interpretation instead of the words
Give an example of an informal amendment
- Right to abortion:
Roe v Wade (1973) overturned by Dobbs v Jackson women’s health organisiation
state issue or federal? - Right to private gun ownership:
District of Columbia v Heller 2008
What does the 10th amendment say ?
- All matters not expressly delegated to federal gov are reserved to states