Family Law Flashcards
Marriage - NY Formal Reqs
1) license: age rules (14/15: parental consent & ct approval, 16/17: parental consent) + waiting period (1-60 days) + testing (sickle cell)
2) solemnization: 1+ witness and judge/politician/clergy must officiate
No marriage license
1) preexisting marriage
2) co-sanguinity (1st cousins and adopted siblings OK)
3) sham marriage
4) incompetence/inebriation
Annulment - void marriages
Void marriage - Not legally recognized except afterward for purposes of legitimacy
1) Bigamy
2) Incest
3) Married while serving life sentence
4) “Enoch Arden” statute = spouse believed dead b/c of absence for 5 years + newspaper publication for 3 weeks. Ct then annuls.
Annulment - voidable marriages
Voidable marraige - valid until one spouse seeks to void it by ct decree. *6 yr SoL.
1) Age: only minor spouse or her parents can use this, and only before reaching 18 if still together
2) Mental incapacity: by mentally ill spouse or their relatives, or by normal spouse iff incapacity wasn’t obvious at marriage time
3) Physical incapacity: one party unable to procreate at time of marriage, and moving party didn’t know (5 yr SoL + no jury)
4) Fraud/coercion/misrepresentation: must go to essence of marriage (3 yr SoL)
Legal separation - formalities
1) in writing, 2) signed, 3) notarized
- Cannot expressly req parties to divorce.
- Parties must actually separate to get conversion divorce.
- Grounds = same as divorce + “failure to support” if spouse possess means to do so and supported spouse needs it.
Effect of separation agreement on divorce
Merger = agreement merged into divorce decree, which then governs.
- Incorporation = sep. agreement continues as independent K and can be sued on. NY presumes this one if parties silent.
- NB: Ct can only modify sep. agree. w/ consent of parties UNLESS supported spouse is receiving so little she’s in danger of becoming a public charge.
Divorce - grounds
1) No-fault
2) Conversion
3) Fault:
a. Adultery
b. Cruel/inhumane treatment
c. Abandonment
d. Imprisonment
No-fault divorce
One spouses testifies under oath that marriage is “IRRETRIEVABLY BROKEN” and has been for at least SIX MONTHS.
- NB: All economic & child-related issues must be resolved before ct will grant divorce.
Conversion divorce
On request to ct, after parties have lived apart for ONE YEAR w/out material breach.
Adultery - basics
Def: voluntary sexual intercourse w/out someone besides spouse.
- Circ evidence OK iff party had opportunity and inclination. PI or prostitue’s testimony must be corroborated.
- SoL = 5 yrs
Fault-based divorce - defenses
- Recrimination: π was also engaged in adultery
- Connivance: π knew of and benefited from adultery
- Condonation: π forgave misconduct & resumed marriage
- Provocation: misconduct provoked by π
- Collusion: parties colluding to get divorce
- Consent: defense to abandonment or adultery
- Justification: defense to abandonment.
Cruel & inhumane treatment
Def: π shows course of conduct by ∆ that is harmful to π’s health and makes continued cohabitation unsafe.
- 5 yr SoL
Abandonment
1) ∆ voluntarily leaves marital home,
2) w/out cause or consent,
3) w/ intent to remain apart permanently,
4) and does so for 1 yr.
“Constructive abandonment” = spouse unjustifiably forces other to leave the house.
Imprisonment
For 3+ consecutive years after marriage. Only spouse of prisoner has grounds for divorce.
Equitable distribution
Def: NY divides MARITAL PROPERTY on basis of fair distribution, considering totality of circs.
- NB: Marital fault not considered in distrib. unless it is EGREGIOUS.
- Party may ask ct for equit. distr. as part of divorce proceedings.
- Cf: community property = equal division of assets.