Family Law Flashcards
Jurisdiction for Divorce
To establish jurisdiction over a divorce action, one of the parties must be a bona fide resident of the jrdx where the divorce action is brought. Plaintiff’s residence alone may be basis for a state’s granting a divorce, regardless of where there is PJ over the defendant.
States may set a minimum durational residency requirement such as 90 days or one year, before the action can be filed.
Jurisdiction for Dividing Marital Property & Determining Alimony
A court cannot determine out-of-state property rights or rights to support unless it has jurisdiction over both parties.
In, an ex-parte divorce (where only Plaintiff is before the court), the court can grant the divorce, but cannot award spousal support or divide out of state property.
No-Fault Divorce
“IBS”
Most states offer “no-fault” divorces that provide for the dissolution of a marriage without regard to marital fault, generally upon a showing that 1) the marriage is irretrievably broken (irreconcilable differences) and that 2) the parties have been living separate and apart for a specified period of time.
Fact that one spouse thinks the marriage should be saved and does not agree that is has broken down is generally insufficient to prevent a divorce judgment if the other spouse believes the marriage cannot be saved and is not interested in continuing the marriage.
Property Division during Divorce: Equitable Division of Marital Property.
Most states follow the equitable division of marital property, where each spouse takes his/her separate property and the marital property is what gets divided at divorce.
Courts will first classify each asset as marital property or separate property. Separate property is property acquired before the marriage that one spouse owns. All assets acquired during marriage are deemed marital property, unless acquired through gift, bequest (by will), devise (real property in will), or descent (inheritance).
ALWAYS: Trial court is then given great discretion as to the division of equitable property. Courts have the authority to order an equitable distribution of all marital property, no matter how title is held. Equitable does not necessarily mean equal.
Separate Property (Divorce)
Separate property refers to the property owned by one party.
1) all real and personal property owned by a spouse before marriage
2) assets included in retirement account
3) property acquired by gift or inheritance
4) property acquired in exchange for separate property
(ex: spouse has bank account w/ funds he acquired before marriage, and he ultimately bought property w/ funds. Property would remain separate bc purchased with separate property).
5) income and appreciation of separate property
6) pain & suffering awards, victim of crime compensation awards, future medical & future loss wages
7) personal damages
8) Property acquired after legal separation where court has made a final division of property
Marital Property (Divorce)
Generally, all property acquired during marriage is marital property unless it is acquired through gift, bequest, devise, or descent.
Some states use date of separation and some use date of filing of divorce as to the date when the marriage ends.
Includes:
1) Property acquired by either or both spouses during marriage
2) Earnings
3) Employment benefits (vested or unvested pension, stock options, retirement, and fringe benefits related to employment that accrues during the period of marriage)
Pensions are marital property. Pensions dollars acquired during the marriage belong to the marital estate.
Even if non-working spouse did not contribute at all to the pension account, it is still considered marital if it was earned during the marriage. Spouses may come into the marriage w/ a pension, but any contributions made to the pension during the marriage, will belong to the marital estate.
4) Lost wages
5) Reimbursement
6) Recovery for damage to marital property
State’s Enforcement of Another State’s Child Support Order
Under the Full Faith and Credit for Child Support Orders Act, full faith and credit must be given to another court’s child support order if: the court had
1) jurisdiction over the matter, and
2) the parties had reasonable notice and
3) an opportunity to be heard.
Under the Uniform Interstate Family Support Act (UIFSA), even if the new state does not have personal jurisdiction over the party, that court may serve as an initiating tribunal to request the court that issued the order, which has continuing and exclusive jurisdiction over the support order, to enforce or modify the order issued in their state.
States Modification of Another States Child Custody Order
Under the Federal Parental Kidnapping Prevention Act (PKPA), a state may not modify a custody order if:
1) one of the parties continues to reside in the issuing state
AND
2) under the state’s laws, the court continues to have and does not decline jurisdiction
Under the Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction and Enforcement Act (UCCJEA), which has been adopted by nearly every state, the court that made the initial custody determination has continuing, exclusive jurisdiction over the matter until that court determines that:
-neither the child nor the parents continue to reside in the state, or
-the child no longer has significant connection with the state and substantial evidence relating to the child’s care, protection, training, and personal relationships is no longer available in the state.
Modifying Custody Order (Standard & Factors)
ALWAYS: Ultimately, the trial court is vested with a great deal of discretion in modifying child custody orders and always considers the best interest of the child when determining/awarding custody. BIOC always for custody
Factors:
1) Parents’ wishes
2) Child’s preference (children over 12 given great weight, children under 8 not considered mature enough to articulate a preference)
3) Child’s relationship w/ parents, siblings & others involved w/ parents
4) Child’s adjustment to home, school, and community
5) Parties’ mental & physical health
*courts cannot give gender preferences, so can’t give to mom bc she’s mom and primary caregiver
Requirements in order for court to split couple’s property
Couple must have either been married or had a valid cohabitation agreement
General rule: if common law marriage was valid where entered, it will be recognized in other states as well (even if they don’t recognize common law)
Common Law Marriage Requirements
Common law marriage is a valid marriage without a license or ceremony.
1) Capacity to enter into a marriage
2) Consent (exchange of) - have to consent to wed, not just to move in & be partners
3) Cohabitation- couple must actually live together
4) Holding out publicly as spouses- look for legal documents, what the community considers, whether this community considers this couple as married, do they call themselves Mr. & Mrs.?, do they file tax returns as married filing jointly? do they have health insurance together?
Sufficient Holding Out as Spouses for Common Law Marriage
Courts look to:
-conduct such as using a common last name
-opening a joint bank account
-telling others in the community that they consider themselves married, going by Ms. or Mrs.
-filing taxes jointly as married couple
-sharing health insurance
Cohabitation Contracts
Contracts between unmarried cohabitants will be enforced if sexual relations are not the only consideration for the contract.
Adoption
A child may not be adopted without consent from both of the child’s biological parents.
Adoption Consent from Unwed Father
Whether consent must be obtained from an unwed father depends on how involved the father was with the child.
Unwed parents have the right to raise their own children.
If an unwed father is part of the “family unit” that includes the child, the relationship b/w the father and child is protected by due process, provided that the unwed father has demonstrated a full commitment to the responsibilities of parenthood by participating in raising his child.
The court will consider whether the father shouldered any significant responsibility with respect to daily supervision, education, protection, or care of the child.
Adoption: Uninvolved Unwed Father v. Involved Unwed Father
An unwed father who has never attempted to establish a legal or personal relationship with the child has no rights with respect to an adoption.
An involved unwed father, on the other hand, has a right to block an adoption unless the unwed father is found to be an unfit parent.
Factors to Consider When Deciding if Involved Unwed Father Can Veto Adoption
1) whether the father shouldered any significant responsibility with respect to daily supervision, education, protection, or care of the child.
2) whether the parents lived with each other and cared for the child (or if not, whether the unwed father visited regularly)
3) whether the unwed father admitted paternity or paid child support
Wedding Gift Classification as Separate or Marital Property?
When a gift is given to both parties, courts will look at the donor’s intent to determine whether they intended both parties to use the gift. Unless a particular wedding gift is only appropriate for the use of one spouse, wedding gifts should be classified as marital property.
Alimony/Spousal Support Issue Spot Pre-Write
The issues are whether spouse x’s economic dependency has resulted from the marital relationship and whether spouse x has the ability to be self-sustaining.
The trial court is vested with a great deal of discretion in determining the amount of alimony.
Purpose of Spousal Support
The purpose of alimony (spousal support) is to ensure an adequate income stream for the spouse whose economic dependency has resulted, at least in part, from the marital relationship.
Determination of Amount of Spousal Support
Some states will consider marital fault when determining alimony. In others, alimony is not based on marital fault. Alimony is not based on marital fault alone in any jurisdiction. The recent trend is to award less alimony than in the past because of the number of couples where both parties have valuable skills for the workforce.
When determining what type and how much support to award, the court considers:
1) the standard of living during the marriage,
2) the duration of the marriage,
3) the age and physical and emotional conditions of the parties
4) the financial resources of each party (including how marital property was apportioned)
5) the contribution of each party to the marriage (including homemaking, child care, education and career building of the other party)
6) the time needed to obtain education or training to enable either party to find appropriate employment, where applicable; and
7) the ability of the payor spouse to meet his needs while paying spousal support
Permanent Spousal Support
Permanent spousal support is awarded to a spouse who has neither the resources nor the ability to be self-sustaining.
(if spouse has substantial financial resources, in addition to skills & background to reenter the workforce, it is highly unlikely court will award that spouse permanent support)