Extra slides info (IMPORTANT) Flashcards
Solving ill-defined problems carries a greater…
- ‘Cognitive load’
- Cognitive load: the amount of information held in mind at one time
Solving ill-defined problems presents what kind of brain activity?
Shows greater activity in the right lateral prefrontal cortex for ill-defined anagrams (have no constraints -> can you make a word with ZJAZ, instead of the well-defined anagram w/ constraints -> can you make a type of music with ZJAZ)
What’s the brute force approach to problem-solving?
- Systematic algorithm that represents all the possible steps from the problem to goal state
- Guaranteed to find a solution, but inefficient
- Combinatorial explosion: computing too many alternatives
- This approach takes up a lot of time and energy
- This is a close cousin to decision-fatigue
What do the hill climbing strategy and means end analysis approaches use for their methods of problem-solving?
Heuristics
What’s the hill climbing strategy to problem-solving?
- Select the operation that brings you closer to the goal without examining the whole problem space
- This strategy can lead to a false outcome, a ‘local maxima’ (subgoal) is mistaken as the final goal
- Does not always work because some problems require you to move away from the goal in order to solve it
- Ex: dog trying to get a treat across a fence and only using the bumping into the fence and trying to get through approach
Describe the means end strategy approach to problem-solving
- What “means” do I have to make the current state look like the goal state I want to be in?
- Identifying sub-problems to complete the goal
- Includes forward and backward movements and constantly
evaluating the difference between current and goal states - We keep calculating our goal
- More flexible approach than hill-climbing
What’s analogical problem solving?
- Making comparisons between 2 situations; applying the solution from one of the situations to the other situation
- Target: the situations the person is currently in (The Tumor Problem)
- Source: the situation that shares similarity with the target (the Fortress Story)
- Ex: the percentage of participants who correctly solved the tumor problem after reading a similar problem and solution grey much more than without a similar problem story
- People aren’t very good at using analogies unless they are ”reminded”
- Without the hint, a person must look beyond surface details, and consider the general structure (the gist)
- Most success when a source and target share surface and structure
- E.g., Using a past school-related problem to solve a current school-related problem vs a current relationship-related problem
What’s the Einstellung effect?
- The bias to use familiar methods to solve a problem
Ex: “I always do it this way” - Can result in an inability to seek and use a better method to solve a given problem
- Leads to rigid thinking and blocks in problem solving
- Ex: Functional and Mental Fixedness
What’s a classic test of functional fixedness?
Maier’s (1931) two-string problem
What’s mental fixedness?
- Overusing mental sets
- Responding with previously learned rule sequences even when they are inappropriate or less productive
- The tendency to respond inflexibly to a particular type of problem and not alter your response
- Ex: The water jug problem -> when you test people’s ability to solve this problem in the lab, you’ll find that a lot of people ( about 74%) used the complex equation for problems 7 and 8 to remain consistent even though there’s easy ways to solve them
What are the 4 features of insight?
- Suddenness: The solution pops into mind with surprise
- Ease: The solution comes quickly and fluently
- Positive: A pleasant experience, even before assessing if the solution is effective
- Confidence: The solution is believed to be the right one
What’s an insight problem?
- A productive thinking process of forming new patterns or ways to view a problem
- Restructuring a problem in a new way leads to a sudden solution
- The Aha moment
- Gestalt switches: the experience of having a sudden switch in how you see something
- Ex: The triangle problem -> How can you move
3 circles to get the triangle to point to the bottom of the page? - If you apply your standard way of solving a problem to this problem, it won’t work
Insight results from what?
- Impasse
- Mental impasse is being stuck in a solution path
- Leads to sudden insight from restructuring the problem to see a new solution
What’s the difference between insight and non-insight?
- Insight problem-solving feels like it happens suddenly
- People cannot accurately predict performance (finding solution)
- Non-insight problem solving comes with awareness
- Step-by-step algorithms help predict performance
Metacognitive assessments (What you know about what you know) is not accurate for what kind of problems?
Insight problems
Describe the Electroencephalography (EEG)
- An active brain produces electrical activity
- Event-related potentials (ERP)
- EEG measures activity in a large group of neurons at certain times
- Provides estimate of when the brain is active
- EEG provides information about activity in the brain at certain time periods
- Good timing information (temporal resolution); millisecond level
- Not good location information (spatial resolution)
- Lots of things can affect ERP signals, which means a researcher needs to collect a lot experimental trials and this limits the studies you can run
Describe Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI)
Structural MRI
* Anatomy of the brain
* E.g., volume, location of grey matter
* Used to detect structural anomalies
Functional (f)MRI
* Information about activity in the brain
* An indirect measure as it measures blood flow and not neural activity
* Active brain areas need oxygen (metabolic energy)
* A magnet detects changes in oxygenated blood
* Measure ratio of oxygenated and de- oxygenated blood flow in regions of the brain during a task
* Use measurements to create a spatial image of brain activity
Strengths:
* Provides good spatial resolution
* About a 1000 papers published per month ( lots of replication, validation)
Weaknesses:
* Does not provide good temporal resolution to determine timing of brain activity
* It is an indirect measure of neural activity: correlational
* Assumption that increase in blood flow means more activity
* It is very noisy …
Describe Brain stimulation as neuroimaging technique
- Noninvasive method of changing brain activity that can inhibit or increase activity
- A main form is Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS) in a focal magnetic field induces temporary change in brain activity
- TMS may improve memory (Participants in the TMS group had improved scores (up to 25%) on the post-
training compared to pre-training memory test) - Good to test causality (testing effect of temporary lesion or stimulation)
- fMRI and EEG are correlational (associate brain activity to task)
- The way it works is not entirely clear
- Stimulation techniques have broad effects on the brain, so hard to localize effects
What are exteroceptive sensations?
Any form of sensation that results from stimuli located outside the body detected by sensory organs
What are interoceptive sensations?
- Sensations from inside our body
- Proprioception: Sense of where our limbs are in space
- Nociception: Sense of pain due to body damage
- Equilibrioception: Sense of balance
- Dancers have increased interoceptive accuracy (Christensen et al., 2017)
- They could estimate heart rate more accurately than non-dancers
- This was unrelated to fitness levels or counting ability
Describe early visual processing
- Light waves enter the eye and are projected onto the retina
* The retina, a thin layer of tissue at the back of the eye, forms an inverted image
* Later processes turn this image around - Photoreceptors in the retina convert light to electrical activity
* Rods: low light levels for night vision
* Cones: high light levels for detailed color vision - The electrical signal is sent to bipolar cells and then to the ganglion cells
- The signal exits through the optic nerve to the brain
What’s information compression in the visual system?
- Millions of photoreceptors in each retina converge onto 100 x fewer ganglion cells -> optic nerve à brain
- Input from the eyes to the brain is compressed
- You don’t ‘see’ everything that is out there in the world
Describe the difference between the dorsal and ventral pathways
- What (ventral) pathway
- Occipital to temporal lobes
- Shape, size, visual details
- Where (dorsal) pathway
- Occipital to parietal lobes
- Location, space, movement information
- spatial information
- depth perception
- estimating movement and direction of objects
- Neuroimaging studies show separation of what and where pathways
What form of processing do we use for visual illusions?
Top-down processing
Describe the primary visual cortex
Primary Visual Cortex contains specialized regions that process particular visual attributes or features (functional specialization)
* Edges
* Angles
* Color
* Light
Describe the visual association areas
Visual Association Areas interpret visual information and assigns meaning
What could akinetopsia come from?
Damage to the dorsal where pathway
What could visual agnosia come from?
Damage to the ventral what pathway
What are the agnosia subtypes?
- The location of the deficit along the visual information processing pipeline determines impairment
- Apperceptive agnosia
- Associative agnosia
What’s apperceptive agnosia?
- Problems perceiving objects (faces for prosopagnosia look contorted)
- A failure in recognizing objects due to problems with perceiving the elements of the objects as a whole
- Single visual feature perception (e.g., color, motion) are relatively intact
- Impairment is in grouping visual features to form perceptions that can interpreted as meaningful
- She can’t copy these objects when they’re shown to her but she can draw them from memory (long term memory) -> she’s not drawing the model just a label that she knows already
What’s associative agnosia
- Problems assigning meaning or labelling objects (can’t recognize familiar famous faces for prosopagnosia)
- An inability to associate visual input with meaning
- Problems on tests that require accessing information from memory:
- Drawing objects from memory
- Naming objects
- Indicating the functions objects
- Determining if a visual object is a possible or impossible object
What are the Gestalt organizational principles?
- The principle of experience: Figure ground segmentation
- Visual grouping principles:
- Principle of proximity
- Principle of closed forms
- Principle of good contour
- Principle of similarity
What’s the load theory of selective attention?
- Attentional filtering can occur at different points
- Filter placement will depend on how much of your resources are required for your currently attended-to task
- If low resource load, we process non-attended information to a later stage in the pipeline (late-model)
- If high resource load, we process non-attended information only to an early stage the pipeline (early-model)
What are the 2 ways to define load?
Central resource capacity view
- One resource pool from which all attention resources are allocated
Multiple resource capacity view
* Multiple resources from which attention resources are allocated
* Attentional load depend on the match between the relevant and irrelevant information
* E.g., Attentional capacity is reached sooner if relevant and irrelevant information are from the same modality