Extent of economic change Flashcards

1
Q

Industrialisation under both Tsars/communists

A

-Consistent emphasis on heavy industry (e.g steel/engineering) as opposed to light (everyone but Krushchev)
-Main motive to catch up with West/emulate their industrial revolution to increase/maintain world power status

-Affected by relationship with agriculture/peculiar nature of Russian society

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

Industry under Alexander II

A

More committed move towards state involvement🏭 in industry (not scared of proletariat unrest like others)
=Mikhail Reutern as Minister of Finance
-Sensible approach revolving around railway construction🛤️/foreign technical expertise🌍/employment of foreign investment capital

=Modernisation/expansion

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

Example of the value of employing foreign technical expertise to move Russia forwards (Alexander II/industry)

A

Welshman J.J Hughes was responsible for 1/2 steel production in Russia start of 20th century

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

Railway construction under Nicholas I (industrialisation)

A

-1837= first railway
-1851= St Petersburg-Moscow line inspired by Manchester-Liverpool railway
👇
Built to high technical standard/shows competing with West

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

Railway construction under Alexander III/finance minister Reutern (industrialisation)

A

-Sevenfold increase in track🛤️7️⃣= doubling of industrial output🏭2️⃣/6% annual growth rate💸6️⃣
-also showed importance of attracting foreign investment capital (got through gov bonds/taxation exemptions/monopoly concessions)🌍
-Construction placed in hands of private contractors like West (94% by 1880)🌎🍔, downside= corruption/expensive transport system😈🛤️🫰
-“First state managed exercise in industrial advance”
-Efforts cut short by Russo-Turkish war⚠️ BUT paved the way for others (e.g Sergei Witte)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

Who took over finance minister after Reutern/Alexander III

A

Bunge

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

Economic reforms under Bunge/Alexander III (industrial)

A

More liberal approach
-Fiscal amendments (e.g 1886 poll tax based on number of ppl in household)
-1883 Peasant Land Bank
-Greater state ownership (69% by 1911)

Not long-lasting as blamed for declining value of rouble/replaced

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

Who was Bunge replaced by

A

Vyshnegradskii

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

Economic reforms under Vyshnegradskii (Alexander III)

A

-More efficient utilisation of income
-Revenue raised through Medele’ev tariff of 1891
-Exported large amounts of grain (even when shortage/starvation)

=Balance of budget but still surplus

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

Summary of industrialisation achievements of finance ministers before Witte

A

Modest
-e.g 1893 still largely agrarian economy

-Witte first to show commitment to industrialisation🏭 to compete with West🌍/improve military🪖

(may have influenced Stalin’s industrialisation)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

Sergei Witte’s industrialisation plans (Alexander III)

A

-Restarted encouraging foreign expertise/taking foreign loans/raising taxes/interest rates🌎
-1897 placed rouble on gold standard🪙🥇
-Most investment on heavy industry (like West)⛏️🏭🌎
-Moved away from private enterprise

=Great spurt🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

Effect of “Great spurt” (Sergei Witte/Alexander III industrialisation)

A

-Coal production doubled⛏️2️⃣
-Steel/iron production increased sevenfold⚒️7️⃣
-Stimulus provided to development of technologies in oil/chemical industries🛢️⚗️🏭
-Big increase in railway track🛤️ (from 120% annual increase in capital from abroad)🌎💸
-Income from industry shot up 119 million roubles🏭🪙1️⃣1️⃣9️⃣
-Catching up (e.g surpassed France in iron production 1900)🐸
-Increase in industrial production of 7.5%- higher than any other period

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

Criticisms of Witte’s policies

A

-Neglected other industries (e.g textiles)
-Reliance on foreign capital dangerous as loans could be recalled at short notice
-Using foreign expertise stunted home talents
-Railway construction expensive/often rushed/not as impressive as other places (e.g 11x less than Germany)
-Neglecting agriculture= rural unrest/mistrust from other members of gov

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

Evidence that without WW1 Russia would have caught up with West

A

-Great spurt
-Stolypin/Witte together= revival of economy, e.g 1909 industrial output increased 7%/year and GNP by 3.5%

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

Evidence that even without WW1 Russia wouldn’t have caught up with West

A

-Still behind- e.g coal production only 10% of Britain’s/GNP 20%
-Factories employed vast amounts of labour to compensate for lack of modern technology/equipment
-Gains masked by huge population increase
-Neglection of agriculture made future famine likely
-Fact economy fell apart during WW1

(Shows Witte’s reforms maybe only short-term positive effect)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

Summary of industry under Tsars

A

-Growth of proto-industry/early factory system with production plants/railway
-“Great spurt”
-Impact of WW1

=Rapid economic growth at times comparable with West

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
17
Q

Impact of WW1 on economy

A

-Industry struggled to meet demands🏭😢
-Railway system lacked efficiency🛤️😢
-More money borrowed from abroad🌍
-Taxes increased💸
-Gold standard abandoned= rampant inflation (food/fuel prices quadrupled but NOT wages)😢😢

-Bolsheviks took over= major turning point to management of economy

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
18
Q

Impact of WW1 on economy

A

-Industry struggled to meet demands
-Railway system lacked efficiency
-More money borrowed from abroad
-Taxes increased
-Gold standard abandoned= rampant inflation (food/fuel prices quadrupled but NOT wages)

-Bolsheviks took over= major turning point to management of economy

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
19
Q

Lenin strategies to revive economy after WW1

A

War communism
State capitalism
NEP

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
20
Q

State capitalism (Lenin/Bolshevik)

A

State took control of economy until it could be handed to Proletariat (Nov 1917)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
21
Q

How was state capitalism introduced (Lenin/Bolshevik)

A

-Nov 1917 Decree on land= private land given to peasants
-Nov 1918 Decree on Workers control= Workers committees get “extra powers” to run factories
-December 1917= Supreme Economic Council formed to manage nationalised enterprises (over 30,000 by 1920)/council of labour defebce

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
22
Q

Impact of State capitalism (Lenin/Bolshevik)

A

Opposition within/outside party, worsened by signing of Brest-Litovsk (March 1918)🥷

Civil war🪖 nullified any positive impact as:
-Industrial output fell dramatically🏭😭
-Hyperinflation (e.g rouble worth 1% what it was in 1917= abandonment of currency)💸💸😭😭😭

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
23
Q

War communism (Lenin/Bolshevik)

A

State capitalism/grain requisitioning:
-Nationalisation of larger enterprises/state monopoly of markets🏭
-Partial militarisation of labour🪖👷
-Grain requisitioning🌾🫳

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
24
Q

Impact of war communism (Lenin/Bolshevik)

A

-Nationalisation= unrest as ppl lost ownership/control of businesses
-Militarisation also disliked
-Requisitioning= most hated, disincentive to grow more than needed as majority of food taken away/starvation

Quickly replaced with NEP

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
25
NEP 1921 (Lenin/Bolshevik)
-Denationalisation of smaller enterprises (to allow production of consumer goods)🏭🆓🛍️ -Use of trust organisations to help manage heavy industry⚒️ -Removal of trade restrictions -Re encouragement of foreign trade/investment/expertise🌎 -End to grain requisitioning🌾🆓/peasants could sell in markets👨‍🌾🧺
26
Positive impact of NEP (Lenin/Bolshevik)
-Removal of trade restrictions= shops flourished/rationing ended/new rouble🛍️🍒🪙 -New breed of entrepreneur Nepman 🧑‍🔬(1923 responsible for 60% retail trade)
27
Negative impact of NEP (Lenin/Bolshevik)✂️
Scissors crisis: -Food increased faster than demand= lower prices🍒-🫰 -Industry increased much slower= high prices🏭+🫰 =Peasants reluctant to sell at lower prices but industrialists needed them to -Debates over continuation= 1929 Stalin replaced with the Great turn
28
Stalin's aims in industry
More worker autonomy/system that made workers believe they were key to economic success= becoming major industrial source Prepare for potential conflict with capitalists (linked to economic autarky) Using 7 five-year plans
29
Weaknesses of five-year plans (Stalin)
-Little strategic planning -Targets set by ruling elite with little research -Managers constantly feared failure -Little guidance for managers
30
Structure to target setting and planning process (five-year plans Stalin)
-Targets made by key officials -Gosplan calculated figures -Passed to industrial commissariats -Passed to regional managers to implement
31
Summary of success of five-year plans (Stalin)
-First did not run full course as gov exaggerated achievement/unrealistic targets -False claims about production from managers (climate of fear) HOWEVER some success (e.g coal increased 474.5 tonnes) -Most in post-war period as ppl worked so hard Continued by Krushchev but slower growth
32
Success of 1st five-year plan (Stalin)M
-Increased heavy industry output⛏️🏭 -Engineering industry developed👨‍🔬 -Specialised industrial centres (e.g Magnitogorsk)🌆
33
Weaknesses of 1st five-year plan (Stalin)
-Consumer industries neglected -Shortage of skilled workers (purges) -Targets not met
34
Success of 2nd five-year plan (Stalin)
-Electrical industry took off -4500 new enterprises -Engineering= self-sufficient -Transport/communications network -Chemical industry made up for lack of progress in 1st plan -Tin/zinc/copper mined for first time -Specialist training schemes for workers -More realistic targets -Commissariats better organised
35
Weaknesses of 2nd five-year plan (Stalin)
-Consumer industries continued to decline🛍️🚫 -Oil industry slower than West🛢️🚫🌎
36
Success of 3rd five-year plan (Stalin)
-Continued impressive production in heavy industry (varied by region) -Improvement in armaments
37
Weaknesses of 3rd five-year plan (Stalin)
-War= diversion of resources -Shortage of raw materials -Progress slowed -Lack of planning/expert workers (purges)
38
Success of 4th five-year plan (Stalin)
-Rapid recovery (e.g pre-war production figures returned in 3 years)
39
Weaknesses of 4th five-year plan (Stalin)
-Extreme pressure on ppl
40
Success of 5th five-year plan (Stalin/Krushchev)
Rapid growth especially with agricultural equipment
41
Weaknesses of 5th five-year plan (Stalin/Krushchev)hs
Too many resources devoted to useless projects (e.g hydroelectric schemes)
42
Successes of 6th five-year plan (Krushchev)
-More modern industries -Consumer goods more prevelant
43
Weaknesses of 6th five-year plan (Krushchev)
-Unrealistic targets= abandoned after 2 years
44
Successes of 7th five-year plan (Krushchev)
-Substantial + in production -More realistic targets
45
Weaknesses of 7th five-year plan (Krushchev)
-Rate of growth slower than US
46
Summary of industrial growth under communists
-State capitalism -War communism -Centralised planning: 7 5-year plans Rapid but variable Greater than Tsars/comparable with West
47
Agriculture under Tsars/communists
Always subservient to industry Peasants treated as second-class citizens Failed to deal with land-ownership effectively
48
Peasant land ownership under Tsars
Land redistribution policies never met rising expectations of peasants
49
Peasant land ownership under communists
All land state-owned= resentment especially as rulers kept land for personal use
50
When were the serfs emancipated (agriculture, tsars, Alexander II)
February 1861
51
Terms of emancipation (agriculture, tsars, Alexander II)
-Privately owned serfs free- state serfs to be freed 1866 -Nobles to give them land -State gave landowners compensation/peasants contributed through redemption payments handled by mir (land not their until last payment)
52
Who were the mir
Village council of elders
53
How did emancipation cause unrest in the long-term for peasants/nobility (agriculture)
-Peasants had poorer quality/less land than before act -Struggled to meet redemption payments/rural poll taxes -Not totally free as had to answer to mir, subsidence farming= no incentive to produce surpluses -Redemption payments not always enough to pay debts from loans taken out before emancipation= 1905 noble land - 40%
54
Alexander III and agriculture
1891= big crazy famine, blamed on poor farming/resentful peasants =Ministry of agriculture/Land captain for discipline
55
Aims of Stolypin's reform (Agriculture/tsars/Nicholas II)
Use land redistribution to build class of more able/educated peasants to act as role model for others/end rural unrest
56
Stolypin's reform (Agriculture/tsars/Nicholas II)
-Unused land could be bought by peasants from peasant land bank -Peasants farming strips could join their land into small farm units As wanted mainstay of Russian farming to be independently-ran peasant farm
57
Why did Stolypin's reform backfire? (Agriculture/tsars/Nicholas II)
-Expansion in wealthier peasant class but still not satisfied as said best land still inaccessible -1914 2 million peasants left village (sped up by WW1)= Shortage of rural labour/food
58
Land issues under Provisional gov
Did little to resolve -Peasants seized land during July days -Bolsheviks exploited saying "peace, bread and land"/proclaimed they represented peasant and worker interests
59
Decree on land (land issues under Bolsheviks)
Aimed to keep peasants on their side but still treated as second class (e.g war communism/grain requisitioning)
60
War communism and the kulaks (agriculture/Lenin/Bolsheviks)
-Blamed for food shortages= food/seeds/property confiscated -Got poorer peasants to denounce them for class war
61
NEP and the kulaks (agriculture/Lenin/Bolsheviks)
-More tolerated but still had higher taxes/were disenfranchised/children no allowed to go to state schools -Respected within peasant class as voiced concerns about living/working conditions (maybe real reason were mistreated by authorities)
62
Collectivisation (agriculture/Stalin/Bolsheviks)
Farms merged together/managed by state so peasants would collaborate/no hoard surpluses
63
Mass collectivisation 1929 (agriculture/Stalin/Bolsheviks)
Prompted by 1927 famine Aims= socialism in the countryside by eradication NEP/Kulaks/Rightists Hand in hand with dekulakisation
64
Process of mass collectivisation 1929 (agriculture/Stalin/Bolsheviks)
-Principles explained to villagers -Poorer peasants/komsomols/workers recruited to denounce kulaks = fear/other incentives= new farming equipment
65
Consequences of mass collectivisation 1929 (agriculture/Stalin/Bolsheviks)
Widespread opposition from peasants/local officials -e.g Bransk-Oblast Komsomols driven away -Migration (e.g 75% Kazakstan) =Stalin allowed peasants to quit collectives March 1930 but then renewed it
66
Renewed collectivisation 1929 (agriculture/Stalin/Bolsheviks)
-Could keep small plots of land -Motor tractor stations organised -Special charter issued after famine (1924) to improve payments to farmers/security for owners of small plots =98% peasant households collectivised 1941
67
Why was there still opposition to renewed collectivisation (agriculture/Stalin/Bolsheviks)
-Preferred traditional way of organising farms with mir/village autonomy -Couldn't make extra income/restrictions of variety of crops/rural activities -1932-4 famine considered to be caused by requisitioning
68
Krushchev's agriculturual policies
-Emphasis on + production in state farms at the expensive of smaller collectives (merged) -Ministry of Agriculture= advisory body -Abolition of MTS To raise incentives: -Reduced procurements/peasant taxes/more electricity to isolated areas
69
Outcome of Krushchev's agriculturual policies
-Increasing price of procurements (food taken) angered urban dwellers -Some success achieved but unlucky as 1962-3= disaster years: -Bad weather=terrible harvest= riots in countryside/town -e.g in Novocherkassk KGB killed 23 protestors
70
Virgin land campaign aims (1954) (Agriculture/Communists/Krushchev)
-More land to be cultivated (Stolypin had introduced but stopped by dekulakisation)
71
Results of virgin land campaign (Agriculture/Communists/Krushchev)
-1950= 96 million acres for wheat, 165 million in 1964 -Urban dwellers satisfied with amount of food HOWEVER -Land overused -Little attention to crop rotation -Soil erosion -Reduction in soil fertility =Production/productivity fell in long-term (Maybe main reason for Krushchev's downfall)
72
Factors for social/economic
-Working conditions -Housing conditions -Food supplies -Urban -Rural -Education -Religion -Women -Propaganda -Censorship
73
“Economic policies consistently failed to benefit the rural population”
-Heavy industry (e.g 5 year plans) -Agriculture -Modernisation -Competition with West -Railways Even when rulers set out to benefit effect limited e.g emancipation limited with redemption payments/failures e.g virgin land scheme