Executive Flashcards
What is a Minister?
old fashioned word for helper
What is a Privy Council?
- Came from Henry VIII, 1540
means Private council
What is the role of an Executive Branch?
Executive branch carries out actions of government such as implementing laws passed by parliaments, meeting foreign leaders, negotiating ending strikes
Until 1689, who worked under who in the executive branch and how was this chosen?
Until 1689- absolute monarch had all the power helped by advisors they chose who ministered to them. Ministers had more technical people who often stayed in post a long time, working anonymously. Now permenant officials called civil servants
How does a constitutional monarchy change the way the executive branch is appointed + why is this important?
Foundation of constitutional monarchy, monarch chose ministers from largest party in parliament rather than having a free choice
Important because they need to make sure their ministers could get new laws passed smoothly
What happened from the 18th century onwards within the executive branch?
From 18th century, monarchs stopped chairing meetings of ministers so they chose one of them to be the Prime Minister
What did the custom of the Monarch choosing the PM grow to?
the monarch would choose the leader of the largest party to be PM and the PM would choose the ministers
How many government departments are there?
25 government departments
How are government departments split?
Political or Administrative
What are the shorthands for the different government areas?
Whitehall- shorthand for departments
Westminster= shorthand for parliament
What are the levels of seniority
in political government departments?
- Secretary of state
- Has ministers of state (junior ministers)
- Parliamentary under-secretary (very junior)
- Political advisers (SPAD- Special Political ADvisors)
What are the different types of Administrative/Civil Servants in government departments?
- Permanent Secretary
- Civil Servants (From senior to junior)
What does the recent failure of Conservative PMs like Sunak Truss and Johnson show about the Executive?
Show the dysfunction of British Politics (ie Boris Johnson, Liz Truss) + show importance of a functioning executive for a smooth performance in government
How did Sunak’s appointment as PM in October 2022 differ from Johnson and Truss?
He restored executive competence and tried to improve cabinet decision making
- Better connectivity between cabinet members, Conservative MPs/backbenchers, advisers and civil servants
What style of Executive did Johnson have?
Presidential style
What are examples of Johnson’s presidential style of Executive?
- Unlawful prorogation, September 2019
- Redrawing electoral map (reminiscent of gerrymandering) to balance power in favour of PM over the Cabinet and Conservative party
How did Johnson resemble May?
Get Brexit Done’
- European Union Withdrawal Agreement Act published January 2020-> parallels to Theresa May pushing her version in 2019
What was an early example/sign of how his Executive overreach manifested within Johnson’s Cabinet + party?
Resignations:
First resignation= Sajid Javid, Chancellor, Feb 2020 over Johnson’s request to sack all his advisers
Also Cabinet was largely sidelined:
Government measures on COVID 19 largely decided by small court of cabinet ministers + advisers (ie lockdowns, vaccine rollouts)
What led to Johnson’s demise?
2022 Summer- 62 ministerial resignations led to his downfall, 6 cabinet resignations like Rishi Sunak (chancellor of the exchequer)
- Prompted by his disrespect for the cabinet importance as a decision making body
- Cabinet members said he failed to take difficult decisions
- Johnson blamed ‘herd instinct’ (ie others) in Westminster for his downfall
What was the initial opinion of Truss at the beginning of her premiership as PM?
Truss won the membership vote (57.4%) against Sunak but only 4/10 MPs endorsed her in the leadership contest
- Lack of support for her more Neo-liberal programme ie deregulations and tax cuts
What were highlights of how Truss ruled as Executive?
Cabinet of political allies (ie Kwasi Kwarteng as Chancellor)
- Marginalised one nation faction of party + those who supported Sunak
- Tainted with ‘mini budget’ that crashed the pound
- Resigned after 45 days as PM
How did Sunak fail at improving governing competence?
Some scandals/tensions with MPs
Lost Gavin Williamson and Dominic Raab to bullying charges + Nadhim Zahawi for breaching ministerial code in relation to tax affairs
What is the job of the Executive?
Execute laws and policy
What is the Executive’s relationship with legislature?
In the UK, Executive is fused with legislature
- some argue it allows the executive to dominate legislature, especially with a large majority
Who makes up the Executive?
1.PM appointed by monarch, head of executive
2.Ministers appointed by PM to a position of responsibility such as to lead a department within the executive. Ministers are split into a) top senior 22 (or so) who are members of the cabinet and b) junior ministers who assist cabinet ministers eg Secretary of State for Education Gillian Keegan has junior Ministers for Early years, Schools and Universities.
3.Civil servants (see next box)
4.Party advisers (Special party advisers known as SPADs)
What do members of the government also have to be members of?
Parliament, Commons or Lords
How many members of government are there usually?
Usually around 120
20 top ministers in cabinet, 100+ junior ministers
eg since 2019 116 in total consisting of 92 MPs and 24 peers
What does the salary for government members look like?
Nearly all unless very junior get an additional salary on top of their backbench MP one, or in case of peers, their allowance. They are sometimes known as ‘the payroll vote’ because gov’t could sack them from ministerial post if disloyal.
What is the Role of the Executive?
PEF
Proposing legislation including Budget
Executing carrying out government as specified by legislation
Foreign affairs/national crises
What is the title of top Civil Servants?
Permenant
- ie Permenant Secretary at Department of Education
What does the Title of Top Civil Servants entail?
Reflects that civil servants in the UK should not fear being sacked if they give advice to a Minister they do not like
What is expected of Top Civil Servants?
PAN
Permenant
Anonymous
Neutral
What does being anonymous mean as a Civil Servant?
Be in the background whilst the Minister takes the blame and credit
What does being neutral mean as a Civil Servant?
non party political including not joining a political party. Civil servants are supposed to advise the Minister on policy only, not do their party political or campaigning work
How did the Johnson government blur the neutrality of Civil Servants?
The Cabinet Secretary is the top civil servant and some argue Cab Sec during Covid Simon Case should have controlled parties in Number 10 more strictly and that he is less ‘neutral’ than his predecessors.
How has the practice of Ministers appointing party advisers grown in recent years?
They are increasingly being giving a temporary civil servant status
How can N10 SPADs become controversial?
if they are seen as too powerful or excluding ministers
What are examples of SPAD controversies?
May’s top chief of staff SPADs Nick Timothy and Fiona Hill, both ‘left’ conservatives on economic matters and starting the ‘levelling up’ agenda, were resented by ERG Ministers and sacked after the 2017 election. Johnsons Svengali Dominic Cummings (Barnard Castle fame) was considered to be his ‘brain’ and was the most controversial SPAD to date, sacked Nov 2020 due to COVID breaches and power struggle with Carrie Johnson, later to claim Johnson ‘unfit for office’. Sunak has deliberately uncontroversial SPAD chief of staff (Liam Booth-Smith).
What are Key Dates for the Executive topic
Until 1649
1721-42
18th Century
By 1800
By 1900
1979
What was the case until 1649?
Monarch has absolute power as head of executive
What happened between 1721-42?
Sir Robert Walpole, first ‘PM’: When monarch’s ministers meet without the monarch they need a leader who unofficially becomes known as Prime Minister
What happened in the 18th Century?
when ministers meet they call themselves cabinet (office furniture). The conventions develop that they should be collectively responsible as a cabinet and individually responsible for what happens in their departments as ministers
What happened by 1800?
gradually monarch has handed ‘royal prerogative powers’ to appoint ministers, declare war etc to Prime Minister and cabinet. Due to organic uncodified constitution the powers of PM and cabinet depend on conventions rather than being spelled out in statutes or other written docs.