Exam II Flashcards
What is the standard of evidence in a civil liability case?
Preponderance of the evidence (which essentially means that it was more likely than not that something occurred in a certain way)
What is the standard of evidence in a criminal case?
Beyond a reasonable doubt
What sources of law can the plaintiff sue under in a civil liability case?
- Common law
- Statutory law
What is common law?
- Written opinions of prior courts within a state (called legal precedent)
- Each state has its own common law
What is statutory law?
- Written, legislated
- Refers to written statutes established by Congress at the federal level and by state legislatures at the state level
Are more cases tried under SA ‘33 or SEA ‘34?
SEA ‘34 (Securities Exchange Act of 1934)
What four potential parties can sue under common law?
(1) Client (management of company)
(2) 3rd Party Primary Beneficiary
(3) 3rd Party Foreseen Beneficiary
(4) Foreseeable 3rd Party
What are three sources of potential liability for an auditor? Expand.
(1) Ordinary negligence (lack of reasonable care)
(2) Gross negligence (lack of even min. care)
(3) Fraud (intentional misrepresentation of material fact)
Give an example of ordinary negligence.
Violate GAAP/GAAS
Give an example of gross negligence.
- Reckless departure from GAAP/GAAS
- Audit staff checks off procedures he/she didn’t actually do
- Audit partner moves work down the line to save on costs but staff not experienced enough to do it right
Give an example of fraud.
Deceive user of F/S, and as a result they suffer financial damage.
What are the two ways fraud plays out in practice? Give an example for each.
(1) “Aiding and abetting” - Global Crossings - capacity swaps perpetrated by the independent auditors
(2) “Knew or should’ve known” - Sunbeam - auditors knew about channel stuffing and bill and hold - auditors should’ve known have restructuring accruals
What does burden of proof vary by?
- By Source of Law
- By Jurisidiction
What is the auditor’s primary defense to the deficient conduct argument?
Due Diligence Defense
What are the names of the three key criminal liability cases?
1) National Student Marketing (US v. Natelli)
2) ESM Government Securities (ESM v. Alex Grant Co.)
3) US vs. Arthur Andersen
What happened in the criminal National Student Marketing case (co. wrongdoing; auditor conviction)?
- Co. overstated A/R and revenues (did so by hiring college students to stuff mailboxes with consumer products with order form; students received huge discounts if they used order forms; but co. significantly overstated #order forms actually executed)
- Auditor convicted for criminal liability for certifying Nat’l Student Marketing Co. financial statements with material A/R disclosure omisions
What happened in the criminal ESM v. Alexander Grant Co. case (co. wrongdoing; auditor conviction)?
- Co. repeatedly resold same block of securities
- Co. told AG partner about a fraud the prior year and partner agreed to say nothing for $100,000
- Partner was sentenced to 12 years in prison when this was uncovered
Why did the USA v. AA case become criminal?
- DOJ won case from SEC
- Became criminal b/c AA announced “doc shredding” and AA had entered into a consent decree with the SEC after Waste Management to “not violate laws anymore”
Under common law, who does the burden of proof fall on?
- Plaintiff (needs to prove damage or loss, misstated F/S, reliance on F/S, deficient auditor conduct)
Under common law, what is the auditor’s minimum basis for liability to the client?
- Ordinary negligence
Under common law, what is the auditor’s minimum basis for liability to the primary beneficiary?
- Ordinary negligence
Under common law, what is the auditor’s minimum basis for liability to foreseen third parties
- Restatement of Torts v. NY Rule
Under common law, what is the auditor’s minimum basis for liability to foreseeable third parties?
- Fraud (majority view)
- Ordinary neg. (minority view in Mississippi and Wisconsin)
What is the distinction among “restatement-majority,” “restatement-minority,” and “credit alliance” states?
- Majority states: requires that auditor knew recipient would “use” report to influence plaintiff
- Minority states: adds that auditor knew recipient would “rely” on report
- Credit Alliance states: adds that evidence “links” the auditor and plaintif
Under statutory law, what is the auditor’s minimum basis for liability under sec. 11 to the plaintiff?
- Ordinary negligence
Under statutory law, what is the auditor’s minimum basis for liability under sec. 10b to the plaintiff?
- Gross negligence or fraud
Under statutory law, what is the auditor’s minimum basis for liability under sec. 18 to the plaintiff?
- Gross negligence
Under statutory law sec. 11, what’s the burden of proof on the plaintiff? On the defendant?
- Plaintiff: damage, F/S misstated
- Defendant: lack reliance or due diligience
What does the auditor need to do to prove due diligence?
- Enter evidence showing he/she followed all 10 auditing standards
Under statutory law sec. 10b, what’s the burden of proof on the plaintiff? On the defendant?
- Plaintiff: damage, F/S misstated, reliance, deficient conduct
- Defendant: none
Under statutory law sec. 18, what’s the burden of proof on the plaintiff? On the defendant?
- Plaintiff: damage, F/S misstated, reliance
- Defendant: due diligence
Do many securities class action suits go to trial?
- No, few go to trial
- Most are settled outside of court
What did the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995 introduce?
Proportionate liability
In settlements, how much do auditors generally pay?
- Less than 30% of settlement fee
Why is the Big 4’s ability to pay settlement fees low?
- B/c can’t float stock
- Total Big 4 partner capital is likely less than $2 billion
What are the six key issues in litigation support services?
1) Business valuation
2) Forensic accounting
3) Tax laws
4) Damage calculations
5) Accounting principles (GAAP)
6) Auditor performance (GAAS)
What are the three key tasks in litigation support services?
1) Arbitrator or mediator
2) Court master
3) Expert witness
What are the three key deliverables in litigation support services?
1) Report
2) Deposition testimony
3) Trial testimony
What’s an independent auditor’s responsibility for a client’s accounting under rule 203 (accounting principles)?
- …shall not express an opinion that the F/S are presented in conformity with GAAP …if the statements depart from principles promulgated by bodies designated by Council…
What’s an independent auditor’s responsibility for the auditor’s auditing under rule 202 (compliance with standards)?
- …shall comply with standards promulgated by bodies designated by Council…
Most suits against auditors under the SA ‘33 are brought under what?
Section 11
Summarize SA’33 Section 11.
- Intended to protect potential investors by imposing liability on anyone who makes untrue statements or omits material facts in connection with a registration statement.
An auditor’s liability under the SEA ‘34 derives typically from his involvement with Forms 10K and 10Q. Most suits brought against auditors under the SEA ‘34 relate to either what 2 sections?
- Section 10(b)
- Section 18
Summarize SEA ‘34 Section 10(b).
- Antifraud provision
- Protects purchasers and sellers of securities from manipulation and deception by an auditor or any other person
Summarize SEA ‘34 Rule 10b-5.
- Antifraud provision
- Protects purchasers and sellers of securities from manipulation and deception by an auditor or any other person
Summarize SEA ‘34 Section 18.
- Disclosure provision
- Protects purchasers and sellers from false and misleading statements
What is the rule of Daubert?
The Daubert standard provides a rule of evidence regarding the admissibility of expert witnesses’ testimony during United States federal legal proceedings
What is the origin of the rule of Daubert?
- Derives from Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals
What happened in Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals?
- Judge threw out expert testimony b/c he reached unsound conclusion based on unsound “methodological reliability”
AICPA Statement on Standards for Consulting Services
What are general standards that the AICPA requires of auditors to follow?
- Professional competence
- Due professional care
- Planning and supervision
- Sufficient relevant data