Exam 2 Flashcards
Why Linguistic Universals are a potential argument for the Innateness Hypothesis
- Universals are unique to a language (not shared with other mental modules)
- Hard to explain in any other way than to say that they are ‘built in’
What are the two steps of finding Universals of a language?
Description
Explanation
Define description as a step of finding universals of a language
Gathering data
Define explanation as a step of finding universals of a language
Formulating hypotheses, building theories
How many languages are in the world?
Around 7,000
Explain the logical status of a valid linguistic universal
True language universals must be language-specific universals
Why we cannot say that any linguistic universal supports the IH
- Something that is true of all communication systems is true of all languages… therefore it is not a language-specific universal
- If a property is innate, it is universal… however, every universal property is not innate
Criterial for a good universal
- One has to exclude other possible explanations
* The universal has to be language-specific (i.e. exclusive to language and not some broader class of cognitive systems)
List 4 possible alternative explanations for language specific universals
- Monogenesis
- Evolution
- Neural Architecture
- Other biological constraints
Alternative Explanations for language-specific universals: define monogenesis
All languages stem from one mother language
Alternative Explanations for language-specific universals: define evolution
all evolved things have hierarchical structure
Alternative Explanations for language-specific universals: define other biological constraints
Speech/hearing apparatus
Covert Universals
Regard the mental grammar which is ‘hidden’
Overt Universals
Regard properties of utterances which are observable
language-specific universal
The universal is specific to the cognitive domain that we call language. (specific does not mean a type of language ex. English & Russian)
What are the 3 types of language-specific universals
- Unconditional
- Implicational
- Disjunctive (Parameters)
Explain unconditional universals
X is (un)true of all languages
Explain implicational universals
If a language has property X it will have property Y. Or it cannot also have property Y
Explain disjunctive universals (AKA Parameters)
Each language has either X or Y
What do parameters capture?
That the differences between languages are limited.
Universals can be…
Absolute or statistical
Absolute Universal
All languages have X, meaning there is no language without X
Statistical universal
All languages have X, meaning there is a strong tendency for language to have X
What is typological studies? What universal is it related to?
Covers large numbers of languages. Focus on shallow, observable, measurable properties of utterances. Overt Universal
What is theoretical linguistics
Focuses on covert universals ex. properties of the mental grammar
What is the nature side of universals?
Theoretical studies - assert that the mental grammar is based on an innate ‘template’
What is the nurture side of universals
Typological studies - is no reliance on innate properties of language.